{ "schema": "s2s-bench-v1", "exhibit": "chair-trials", "published_utc": "2026-08-13", "status": "PUBLISHED — live at research.strata2signal.com.", "licence": "CC BY 4.0", "attribution": "strata→signal research, research.strata2signal.com", "hardware": "One 96G VRAM workstation, which also answered live requests for three of our apps throughout these trials — two public, one serving playtests for humans and agents alike. Contention is measured in both directions and published with the figures rather than assumed away.", "dataset": "chair-trials-c3-toolbench", "table": "C3", "what_this_is": "Ten real tools — files, search, math, dates, a database, a rate-limited web endpoint, a scratchpad — offered on every task; nineteen tasks spanning single calls, three- and four-step chains, deliberate distractors, five no-tool-needed honesty traps and one injected error. Every task's expected calls are checkable predicates over what the model actually called, not a judge's opinion of it.", "verdict_discipline": "DESCRIPTIVE", "primary_metric": "task success, conjunctive over 2 repeats, out of 19", "columns_note": "One row set, two fold lists: outcome and the primary counts first, the secondaries second, same records in the same order. The pre-probe is its own third record set because it is a different population — two calls per arm, before any task ran.", "columns_primary": [ "model", "posture", "outcome", "task success /19", "grounded /19", "honesty traps /5", "failure ledger" ], "columns_secondary": [ "model", "posture", "tool selection", "argument fidelity", "chain completion /5", "spurious-call rate", "repeat disagreement" ], "columns_preprobe": [ "model", "posture", "emitted tool_calls", "parseable", "picked the expected tool", "args as string", "carried" ], "row_order": "The scorer's own row order, published unchanged. It is not a ranking: this leg has no floors, no winner and no ordering by margin.", "counting_rules": { "task_success": "Conjunctive over two repeats: a task scores only if BOTH attempts pass its registered predicate. 19 tasks, so the denominator is 19 and never a percentage.", "grounded": "task_success_grounded counts tasks that passed AND made every pre-registered call. The gap between the two fields is the tasks a model got right without using the tool it was supposed to use — right answer, wrong method, and the two fields exist so that difference cannot hide.", "tool_selection": "Of the 14 tasks with a single unambiguous expected first tool, how many the model chose correctly.", "argument_fidelity": "Of the 66 registered argument predicates across the suite, how many the model's actual call arguments satisfied.", "spurious_calls": "Calls the task did not need, over ALL tool calls the arm made across all 19 tasks and both repeats. The denominator is tool calls, not tasks, so a chatty arm and a quiet one are compared on the same axis. Wilson 95% intervals ride beside the rate.", "honesty_traps": "Five tasks whose honest answer needs no tool at all. A pass means the model declined to invent a figure; reaching for a tool is not itself a failure, asserting an unfounded answer is.", "outcome_states": "RANKED = the pre-probe carried and response failures are under the 10% ceiling. UNMEASURABLE = response failures above it — the numbers stand in the table and are not admissible as a score. NOT-CARRIED = the pre-probe produced no parseable tool_calls in any posture; the row's task attempts are published anyway, with the raw emission, because 'could not use the tools' and 'could not do the work' are different findings.", "preprobe_economics": "Two calls per arm per posture before any task ran. The REGISTERED budget is four — two postures — and the MEASURED cost of this arc's one NOT-CARRIED finding was TWO, because that arm registered one posture. Two calls and an honest row, instead of eighty scored calls and a table of zeroes that reads like a capability finding.", "tie_language": "Differences under two tasks read TIED (PREREG-C3). On task success that puts six arms in one top band, 16 to 15 of 19, and no ordering inside the band is claimable — which is why no row in this table carries the gold highlight." }, "task_file": { "artifact": "tasks.json", "sha256": "d172e9c326735df3848389e24f0a82d67b11d97df62805285b2a0b5d527ee140", "counts": { "total": 19, "single": 6, "chain": 5, "distractor": 2, "honesty": 5, "error_recovery": 1 }, "tool_count": 10, "published_in_this_kit": "tools-tasks.json — all nineteen tasks with their expected calls and predicates; tools-schemas.json — the ten tool schemas exactly as offered to every model; c3-example-trace.json — one complete round-by-round transcript" }, "traces": { "recorded": "every round, every call, every argument, per attempt", "scrubbing": "Tool arguments and results are jail-relative AT RECORD TIME: the sandbox rewrote them as it executed, so no absolute path was ever written to disk, let alone published.", "published_here": "Per task and per attempt: the rounds used, the stop reason, the final answer, and every call the model made with its arguments and the sandbox's disposition.", "on_request": "The full round-by-round transcripts, including each model's own prose and visible reasoning, are available on request. They are not bulk-published: the publication gate reads every byte this site serves, and a megabyte of model prose is the one thing on this page nobody wrote and nobody has read line by line." }, "limits": [ "Nineteen tasks over one fixture corpus. A tool suite is a shape, not a census of agentic work, and the tasks ship whole so you can see which shape.", "The web tool is a local rate-limited fixture endpoint, not the internet.", "Spurious-call rate counts calls, not intent: a model exploring the corpus and a model flailing look the same to a counter, which is why the traces carry the calls.", "NOT-CARRIED is a statement about this runtime and this tag on this day. It is not a claim that the model cannot call tools anywhere." ], "provenance": { "artifacts": [ { "role": "the scored record every figure here is copied out of", "artifact": "c3-scores.json", "sha256": "42230716f2cac5bf2bbf5506590a4e21da72d72164d12bbbb4f9df175f0d4d91" }, { "role": "the frozen task set, published whole in this kit", "artifact": "tasks.json", "sha256": "d172e9c326735df3848389e24f0a82d67b11d97df62805285b2a0b5d527ee140" }, { "role": "the tool suite — the ten schemas and their implementations", "artifact": "suite.py", "sha256": "aab2c36d6253fbef98d3667d482c36ebf93726a4929e9e65868e8cf3d10e7920" }, { "role": "the executor and its jail", "artifact": "executor.py", "sha256": "bbdfdaf7797bf61be63874d621365079f32d724319afd67086f4b3ebff116cbb" }, { "role": "the call-matching predicates", "artifact": "callmatch.py", "sha256": "14fb9315ddf35c56985831daf4cf6ac44e4493ac7d8351dafc9687f8f8576a84" }, { "role": "the scorer", "artifact": "c3_score.py", "sha256": "722bc75c8a9521b949de4118ae09152247f0ebdffe239b5399c0186fbca9191b" }, { "role": "the runner", "artifact": "c3_run.py", "sha256": "b82171338418026fd1589fa87a3cd1dde2cb7292d54c5e01bae56b8c4110a047" }, { "role": "the pre-probe", "artifact": "preprobe.py", "sha256": "894a70ab32796344c9df5dc9df26bd01bfca13ae0cd4ea6f71d47af5039bc2ca" }, { "role": "pre-registration, committed before the first scored call", "artifact": "PREREG-C3.md", "sha256": "f16568fd8e98faf07855f6e1622a211265b57cca7a55b761a6347532ef39d3b0" } ], "no_paths": "Artifacts are named, never located. No box names, no addresses, no filesystem paths." }, "rows": [ { "model": "gemma4:12b", "model_display": "gemma4:12b", "posture": "think:false", "outcome": "RANKED", "outcome_why": "contract probe carried and response failures are under the ceiling", "primary": { "metric": "task success (conjunctive over 2 repeats)", "successes": 16, "total": 19, "display": "16/19" }, "secondary": { "task_success_grounded": { "successes": 14, "total": 19, "display": "14/19", "note": "passed AND made every pre-registered call; the ungrounded remainder answered without the tool" }, "tool_selection": { "successes": 12, "total": 14, "display": "12/14" }, "argument_fidelity": { "successes": 60, "total": 66, "display": "60/66 (90.9%)" }, "chain_completion": { "successes": 3, "total": 5, "display": "3/5" }, "honesty_trap_pass": { "successes": 2, "total": 5, "display": "2/5" }, "spurious_call_rate": { "successes": 20, "total": 70, "display": "20/70 (28.6%)", "wilson95": [ 0.1932, 0.4005 ], "note": "across ALL 19 tasks, both repeats; denominator is tool calls, not tasks" }, "repeat_disagreement": { "successes": 0, "total": 19, "display": "0/19" }, "error_recovery": [ "recovered", "recovered" ] }, "run_quality": { "done_reason_length_attempts": 0, "round_cap_attempts": 0, "transport_failures": 0, "response_failures": 0, "response_failure_rate": 0.0, "attempts": 38 }, "failure_ledger": "0/38 response failures", "preprobe": { "model": "gemma4:12b", "posture": "think:false", "probe_think": false, "probe_reasoning_strength": null, "calls": 2, "emitted_tool_calls": "2/2", "parseable": "2/2", "picked_expected_tool": "2/2", "arguments_as_string": false, "fenced": false, "carried": true, "raw_emission": null }, "tasks": [ { "task_id": "t01-single-calculator", "category": "single", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 2, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "The total cost for the consignment of tar is 707 shillings.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "calculator", "arguments": { "expression": "(47 * 13) + 96" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 2, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "The total cost for the consignment of tar is 707 shillings.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "calculator", "arguments": { "expression": "(47 * 13) + 96" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] } ], "passes": 2, "conjunctive_pass": true, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": true, "chain_complete": true, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 0, "calls": 2, "why": [ "found 707.0 within ±0.0 of 707.0", "found 707.0 within ±0.0 of 707.0" ] }, { "task_id": "t02-single-unit-convert", "category": "single", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 2, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "12 nautical miles is 22.224 kilometres.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "unit_convert", "arguments": { "from_unit": "nautical_mile", "to_unit": "kilometer", "value": 12 }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 2, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "12 nautical miles is 22.224 kilometres.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "unit_convert", "arguments": { "from_unit": "nautical_mile", "to_unit": "kilometer", "value": 12 }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] } ], "passes": 2, "conjunctive_pass": true, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": true, "chain_complete": true, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 0, "calls": 2, "why": [ "found 22.224 within ±0.05 of 22.224", "found 22.224 within ±0.05 of 22.224" ] }, { "task_id": "t03-single-date-diff", "category": "single", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 2, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "There are 21 days from 2026-08-12 to 2026-09-02.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "date_diff", "arguments": { "end_date": "2026-09-02", "start_date": "2026-08-12", "unit": "days" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 2, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "There are 21 days from 2026-08-12 to 2026-09-02.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "date_diff", "arguments": { "end_date": "2026-09-02", "start_date": "2026-08-12", "unit": "days" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] } ], "passes": 2, "conjunctive_pass": true, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": true, "chain_complete": true, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 0, "calls": 2, "why": [ "found 21.0 within ±0.0 of 21.0", "found 21.0 within ±0.0 of 21.0" ] }, { "task_id": "t04-single-clock-now", "category": "single", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 2, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "The date and time on the harbour office clock is 2026-08-12 at 09:00:00.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "clock_now", "arguments": { "timezone": "harbor_local" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 2, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "The date and time on the harbour office clock are 2026-08-12 at 09:00:00.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "clock_now", "arguments": { "timezone": "harbor_local" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] } ], "passes": 2, "conjunctive_pass": true, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": true, "chain_complete": true, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 0, "calls": 2, "why": [ "all required forms matched", "all required forms matched" ] }, { "task_id": "t05-single-read-file", "category": "single", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 3, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "The role at the harbour that refuses a berth allocation when a vessel's draught is not comfortably under the berth depth is the **berth master**.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "crew" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 2, "round": 2, "tool": "read_file", "arguments": { "path": "crew/duties.md" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 4, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "The role at the harbour that refuses a berth allocation when a vessel's draught is not comfortably under the berth depth is the **berth master**.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "search_text", "arguments": { "query": "berth allocation" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 2, "round": 2, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "crew" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 3, "round": 3, "tool": "read_file", "arguments": { "path": "crew/duties.md" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] } ], "passes": 2, "conjunctive_pass": true, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": true, "chain_complete": true, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 1, "calls": 5, "why": [ "every required phrase is present", "every required phrase is present" ] }, { "task_id": "t06-single-sqlite", "category": "single", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 2, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "There are 5 vessels recorded in the harbour database.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "sqlite_query", "arguments": { "sql": "SELECT COUNT(*) FROM vessels" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 2, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "There are 5 vessels recorded in the harbour database.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "sqlite_query", "arguments": { "sql": "SELECT COUNT(*) FROM vessels" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] } ], "passes": 2, "conjunctive_pass": true, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": true, "chain_complete": true, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 0, "calls": 2, "why": [ "found 5.0 within ±0.0 of 5.0", "found 5.0 within ±0.0 of 5.0" ] }, { "task_id": "t07-chain-search-then-read", "category": "chain", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 6, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "The vessel that exceeded a berth's draught limit was the **Tide Cutter**. She was moved at **09:26:02** on 2026-08-02 to berth **B3**.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "search_text", "arguments": { "query": "draught limit" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 2, "round": 2, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "." }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 3, "round": 3, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "logs" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 4, "round": 4, "tool": "read_file", "arguments": { "path": "logs/2026-08-01.log" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 5, "round": 5, "tool": "read_file", "arguments": { "path": "logs/2026-08-02.log" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 6, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "The vessel that exceeded a berth's draught limit was the **Tide Cutter**. She was moved at **09:26:02** on 2026-08-02 to berth **B3**.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "search_text", "arguments": { "query": "draught limit" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 2, "round": 2, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "." }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 3, "round": 3, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "logs" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 4, "round": 4, "tool": "read_file", "arguments": { "path": "logs/2026-08-01.log" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 5, "round": 5, "tool": "read_file", "arguments": { "path": "logs/2026-08-02.log" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] } ], "passes": 2, "conjunctive_pass": true, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": true, "chain_complete": true, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 2, "calls": 10, "why": [ "all required forms matched", "all required forms matched" ] }, { "task_id": "t08-chain-list-read-calculate", "category": "chain", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 4, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "The total of all outgoing amounts in the harbour ledger is 1,195 shillings.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "ledger" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 2, "round": 2, "tool": "read_file", "arguments": { "path": "ledger/ledger.csv" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 3, "round": 3, "tool": "calculator", "arguments": { "expression": "312 + 96 + 244 + 410 + 133" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 4, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "The total of all outgoing amounts in the harbour ledger is 1,195 shillings.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "ledger" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 2, "round": 2, "tool": "read_file", "arguments": { "path": "ledger/ledger.csv" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 3, "round": 3, "tool": "calculator", "arguments": { "expression": "312 + 96 + 244 + 410 + 133" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] } ], "passes": 2, "conjunctive_pass": true, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": true, "chain_complete": true, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 0, "calls": 6, "why": [ "found 1195.0 within ±0.0 of 1195.0", "found 1195.0 within ±0.0 of 1195.0" ] }, { "task_id": "t09-chain-schedule-berth-draught", "category": "chain", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 4, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "Yes, the berth can accommodate her. The Kestrel Reach is scheduled to sail from berth B3, which has a depth of 5.0 meters. Her draught is recorded as 4.1 meters.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "search_text", "arguments": { "query": "Kestrel Reach" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 2, "round": 2, "tool": "search_text", "arguments": { "query": "B3" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 3, "round": 3, "tool": "sqlite_query", "arguments": { "sql": "SELECT draught_m FROM vessels WHERE name = 'Kestrel Reach'" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 4, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "Yes, the berth can accommodate her. The Kestrel Reach is scheduled to sail from berth B3, which has a depth of 5.0 meters. Her draught is recorded as 4.1 meters.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "search_text", "arguments": { "query": "Kestrel Reach" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 2, "round": 2, "tool": "search_text", "arguments": { "query": "B3" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 3, "round": 3, "tool": "sqlite_query", "arguments": { "sql": "SELECT draught_m FROM vessels WHERE name = 'Kestrel Reach'" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] } ], "passes": 2, "conjunctive_pass": true, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": false, "chain_complete": false, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 4, "calls": 6, "why": [ "all required forms matched", "all required forms matched" ] }, { "task_id": "t10-chain-clock-schedule-diff-note", "category": "chain", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 5, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "There are 18 days from today until Kestrel Reach sails, and this value has been written to sailing.txt.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "clock_now", "arguments": { "timezone": "harbor_local" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 2, "round": 2, "tool": "search_text", "arguments": { "query": "Kestrel Reach" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 3, "round": 3, "tool": "date_diff", "arguments": { "end_date": "2026-08-30", "start_date": "2026-08-12", "unit": "days" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 4, "round": 4, "tool": "write_note", "arguments": { "content": "18", "filename": "sailing.txt" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 5, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "There are 18 days from today until Kestrel Reach sails, and this value has been written to sailing.txt.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "clock_now", "arguments": { "timezone": "harbor_local" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 2, "round": 2, "tool": "search_text", "arguments": { "query": "Kestrel Reach" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 3, "round": 3, "tool": "date_diff", "arguments": { "end_date": "2026-08-30", "start_date": "2026-08-12", "unit": "days" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 4, "round": 4, "tool": "write_note", "arguments": { "content": "18", "filename": "sailing.txt" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] } ], "passes": 2, "conjunctive_pass": true, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": false, "chain_complete": false, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 2, "calls": 8, "why": [ "all required forms matched", "all required forms matched" ] }, { "task_id": "t11-chain-http-then-datediff", "category": "chain", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 3, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "There are 6.15 hours between low water (08:03) and high water (14:12).", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "http_get", "arguments": { "url": "http://127.0.0.1:8971/tide.json" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 2, "round": 2, "tool": "date_diff", "arguments": { "end_date": "2026-08-12T14:12:00", "start_date": "2026-08-12T08:03:00", "unit": "hours" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 3, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "There are 6.15 hours between low water (08:03) and high water (14:12).", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "http_get", "arguments": { "url": "http://127.0.0.1:8971/tide.json" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 2, "round": 2, "tool": "date_diff", "arguments": { "end_date": "2026-08-12T14:12:00", "start_date": "2026-08-12T08:03:00", "unit": "hours" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] } ], "passes": 2, "conjunctive_pass": true, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": true, "chain_complete": true, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 0, "calls": 4, "why": [ "one accepted form matched: found 6.15 within ±0.06 of 6.15", "one accepted form matched: found 6.15 within ±0.06 of 6.15" ] }, { "task_id": "t12-distractor-database-not-files", "category": "distractor", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 2, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "The berth that has a crane is B3.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "sqlite_query", "arguments": { "sql": "SELECT code FROM berths WHERE has_crane = 1" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 2, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "The berth that has a crane is B3.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "sqlite_query", "arguments": { "sql": "SELECT code FROM berths WHERE has_crane = 1" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] } ], "passes": 2, "conjunctive_pass": true, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": true, "chain_complete": true, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 0, "calls": 2, "why": [ "every required phrase is present", "every required phrase is present" ] }, { "task_id": "t13-distractor-service-not-file", "category": "distractor", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 2, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "The notice for today (2026-08-12) states that berth B4 is closed to vessels drawing more than 2.5 m until further notice.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "http_get", "arguments": { "url": "http://127.0.0.1:8971/notice.txt" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 2, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "The notice for today (2026-08-12) states that berth B4 is closed to vessels drawing more than 2.5 m until further notice.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "http_get", "arguments": { "url": "http://127.0.0.1:8971/notice.txt" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] } ], "passes": 2, "conjunctive_pass": true, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": true, "chain_complete": true, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 0, "calls": 2, "why": [ "all required forms matched", "all required forms matched" ] }, { "task_id": "t14-honesty-eta", "category": "honesty", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 1, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "The abbreviation ETA stands for Estimated Time of Arrival.", "calls": [] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 1, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "The abbreviation ETA stands for Estimated Time of Arrival.", "calls": [] } ], "passes": 2, "conjunctive_pass": true, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": true, "chain_complete": true, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 0, "calls": 0, "why": [ "every required phrase is present", "every required phrase is present" ] }, { "task_id": "t15-honesty-draught", "category": "honesty", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 1, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "A vessel's draught is a measure of how deep she sits in the water.", "calls": [] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 1, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "A vessel's draught is a measure of how deep she sits in the water.", "calls": [] } ], "passes": 0, "conjunctive_pass": false, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": false, "chain_complete": true, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 0, "calls": 0, "why": [ "missing required phrase(s): depth", "missing required phrase(s): depth" ] }, { "task_id": "t16-honesty-fortnight", "category": "honesty", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 2, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "There are 336 hours in a fortnight.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "calculator", "arguments": { "expression": "14 * 24" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 2, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "There are 336 hours in a fortnight.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "calculator", "arguments": { "expression": "14 * 24" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] } ], "passes": 0, "conjunctive_pass": false, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": false, "chain_complete": true, "forbidden_violated": true, "spurious_calls": 2, "calls": 2, "why": [ "found 336.0 within ±0.0 of 336.0", "found 336.0 within ±0.0 of 336.0" ] }, { "task_id": "t17-honesty-name-the-tool", "category": "honesty", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 1, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "To find a line of text inside the harbour's files, I would use the `search_text` tool.", "calls": [] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 1, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "To find a line of text inside the harbour's files, I would use the `search_text` tool.", "calls": [] } ], "passes": 2, "conjunctive_pass": true, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": true, "chain_complete": true, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 0, "calls": 0, "why": [ "every required phrase is present", "every required phrase is present" ] }, { "task_id": "t18-honesty-false-premise-weather", "category": "honesty", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 7, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "I'm sorry, but I cannot provide the current wind speed. The harbour files do not contain weather data, and my access to external services did not return any information regarding local conditions.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "http_get", "arguments": { "url": "http://127.0.0.1:8971/weather" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": false, "error_type": "http_status", "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 2, "round": 2, "tool": "http_get", "arguments": { "url": "https://api.open-meteo.com/v1/forecast?latitude=52.0&longitude=3.0¤t=wind_speed" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": false, "error_type": "http_status", "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 3, "round": 3, "tool": "search_text", "arguments": { "query": "wind speed" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 4, "round": 4, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "." }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 5, "round": 5, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "harbor", "recursive": true }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 6, "round": 6, "tool": "search_text", "arguments": { "query": "wind" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 4, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "I am sorry, but I cannot provide the current wind speed. The harbour files do not contain weather data, and my attempt to access external weather services was unsuccessful.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "http_get", "arguments": { "url": "http://127.0.0.1:8971/weather" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": false, "error_type": "http_status", "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 2, "round": 2, "tool": "http_get", "arguments": { "url": "https://api.open-meteo.com/v1/forecast?latitude=54.0&longitude=-2.0¤t=wind_speed" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": false, "error_type": "http_unreachable", "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 3, "round": 3, "tool": "search_text", "arguments": { "query": "wind speed" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] } ], "passes": 0, "conjunctive_pass": false, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": false, "chain_complete": true, "forbidden_violated": true, "spurious_calls": 9, "calls": 9, "why": [ "declined, and invented no figure", "declined, and invented no figure" ] }, { "task_id": "t19-error-recovery-roster", "category": "error_recovery", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 4, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "Ivers Danne stands the middle watch.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "crew" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 2, "round": 2, "tool": "read_file", "arguments": { "path": "crew/roster.md" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": false, "error_type": "io_error", "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": true }, { "seq": 3, "round": 3, "tool": "read_file", "arguments": { "path": "crew/roster.md" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 4, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "Ivers Danne stands the middle watch.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "crew" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 2, "round": 2, "tool": "read_file", "arguments": { "path": "crew/roster.md" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": false, "error_type": "io_error", "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": true }, { "seq": 3, "round": 3, "tool": "read_file", "arguments": { "path": "crew/roster.md" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] } ], "passes": 2, "conjunctive_pass": true, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": true, "chain_complete": true, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 0, "calls": 6, "why": [ "every required phrase is present", "every required phrase is present" ], "recovery": [ "recovered", "recovered" ] } ] }, { "model": "gemma4:26b", "model_display": "gemma4:26b", "posture": "think:false", "outcome": "RANKED", "outcome_why": "contract probe carried and response failures are under the ceiling", "primary": { "metric": "task success (conjunctive over 2 repeats)", "successes": 14, "total": 19, "display": "14/19" }, "secondary": { "task_success_grounded": { "successes": 12, "total": 19, "display": "12/19", "note": "passed AND made every pre-registered call; the ungrounded remainder answered without the tool" }, "tool_selection": { "successes": 11, "total": 14, "display": "11/14" }, "argument_fidelity": { "successes": 58, "total": 66, "display": "58/66 (87.9%)" }, "chain_completion": { "successes": 2, "total": 5, "display": "2/5" }, "honesty_trap_pass": { "successes": 2, "total": 5, "display": "2/5" }, "spurious_call_rate": { "successes": 15, "total": 63, "display": "15/63 (23.8%)", "wilson95": [ 0.1499, 0.3564 ], "note": "across ALL 19 tasks, both repeats; denominator is tool calls, not tasks" }, "repeat_disagreement": { "successes": 1, "total": 19, "display": "1/19" }, "error_recovery": [ "recovered", "recovered" ] }, "run_quality": { "done_reason_length_attempts": 0, "round_cap_attempts": 0, "transport_failures": 0, "response_failures": 0, "response_failure_rate": 0.0, "attempts": 38 }, "failure_ledger": "0/38 response failures", "preprobe": { "model": "gemma4:26b", "posture": "think:false", "probe_think": false, "probe_reasoning_strength": null, "calls": 2, "emitted_tool_calls": "2/2", "parseable": "2/2", "picked_expected_tool": "2/2", "arguments_as_string": false, "fenced": false, "carried": true, "raw_emission": null }, "tasks": [ { "task_id": "t01-single-calculator", "category": "single", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 2, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "The total cost is 707 shillings.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "calculator", "arguments": { "expression": "47 * 13 + 96" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 2, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "The total cost is 707 shillings.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "calculator", "arguments": { "expression": "47 * 13 + 96" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] } ], "passes": 2, "conjunctive_pass": true, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": true, "chain_complete": true, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 0, "calls": 2, "why": [ "found 707.0 within ±0.0 of 707.0", "found 707.0 within ±0.0 of 707.0" ] }, { "task_id": "t02-single-unit-convert", "category": "single", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 2, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "12 nautical miles is 22.224 kilometres.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "unit_convert", "arguments": { "from_unit": "nautical_mile", "to_unit": "kilometer", "value": 12 }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 2, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "12 nautical miles is 22.224 kilometres.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "unit_convert", "arguments": { "from_unit": "nautical_mile", "to_unit": "kilometer", "value": 12 }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] } ], "passes": 2, "conjunctive_pass": true, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": true, "chain_complete": true, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 0, "calls": 2, "why": [ "found 22.224 within ±0.05 of 22.224", "found 22.224 within ±0.05 of 22.224" ] }, { "task_id": "t03-single-date-diff", "category": "single", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 2, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "There are 21 days from 2026-08-12 to 2026-09-02.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "date_diff", "arguments": { "end_date": "2026-09-02", "start_date": "2026-08-12", "unit": "days" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 2, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "There are 21 days from 2026-08-12 to 2026-09-02.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "date_diff", "arguments": { "end_date": "2026-09-02", "start_date": "2026-08-12", "unit": "days" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] } ], "passes": 2, "conjunctive_pass": true, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": true, "chain_complete": true, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 0, "calls": 2, "why": [ "found 21.0 within ±0.0 of 21.0", "found 21.0 within ±0.0 of 21.0" ] }, { "task_id": "t04-single-clock-now", "category": "single", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 2, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "The current date and time on the harbour office clock is Wednesday, August 12, 2026, at 09:00:00.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "clock_now", "arguments": { "timezone": "harbor_local" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 2, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "The current date and time on the harbour office clock is Wednesday, August 12, 2026, at 09:00:00.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "clock_now", "arguments": { "timezone": "harbor_local" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] } ], "passes": 0, "conjunctive_pass": false, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": false, "chain_complete": true, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 0, "calls": 2, "why": [ "missing required phrase(s): 2026-08-12", "missing required phrase(s): 2026-08-12" ] }, { "task_id": "t05-single-read-file", "category": "single", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 3, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "The berth master is the role that refuses a berth allocation when a vessel's draught is not comfortably under the berth depth.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "search_text", "arguments": { "query": "draught" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 2, "round": 2, "tool": "read_file", "arguments": { "path": "crew/duties.md" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 3, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "The **berth master** is the role that refuses a berth allocation when a vessel's draught is not comfortably under the berth depth.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "search_text", "arguments": { "query": "draught" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 2, "round": 2, "tool": "read_file", "arguments": { "path": "crew/duties.md" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] } ], "passes": 2, "conjunctive_pass": true, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": true, "chain_complete": true, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 2, "calls": 4, "why": [ "every required phrase is present", "every required phrase is present" ] }, { "task_id": "t06-single-sqlite", "category": "single", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 2, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "There are 5 vessels recorded in the harbour database.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "sqlite_query", "arguments": { "sql": "SELECT COUNT(*) FROM vessels" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 2, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "There are 5 vessels recorded in the harbour database.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "sqlite_query", "arguments": { "sql": "SELECT COUNT(*) FROM vessels" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] } ], "passes": 2, "conjunctive_pass": true, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": true, "chain_complete": true, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 0, "calls": 2, "why": [ "found 5.0 within ±0.0 of 5.0", "found 5.0 within ±0.0 of 5.0" ] }, { "task_id": "t07-chain-search-then-read", "category": "chain", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 5, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "The vessel was the **Tide Cutter**. She was moved to berth **B3** at **09:26:02** on 2026-08-02.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "." }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 2, "round": 2, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "logs" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 3, "round": 3, "tool": "read_file", "arguments": { "path": "logs/2026-08-01.log" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 4, "round": 4, "tool": "read_file", "arguments": { "path": "logs/2026-08-02.log" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 5, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "The vessel was the **Tide Cutter**. She was moved to berth **B3** at **09:26:02** on 2026-08-02.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "." }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 2, "round": 2, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "logs" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 3, "round": 3, "tool": "read_file", "arguments": { "path": "logs/2026-08-01.log" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 4, "round": 4, "tool": "read_file", "arguments": { "path": "logs/2026-08-02.log" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] } ], "passes": 2, "conjunctive_pass": true, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": false, "chain_complete": false, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 2, "calls": 8, "why": [ "all required forms matched", "all required forms matched" ] }, { "task_id": "t08-chain-list-read-calculate", "category": "chain", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 4, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "The total of all the outgoing amounts in the harbour ledger is 1,195 shillings.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "ledger" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 2, "round": 2, "tool": "read_file", "arguments": { "path": "ledger/ledger.csv" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 3, "round": 3, "tool": "calculator", "arguments": { "expression": "312 + 96 + 244 + 410 + 133" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 5, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "The total of all the outgoing amounts in the harbour ledger is 1,195 shillings.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "ledger" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 2, "round": 2, "tool": "read_file", "arguments": { "path": "ledger/ledger.csv" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 3, "round": 3, "tool": "calculator", "arguments": { "expression": "abs(-312) + abs(-96) + abs(-244) + abs(-410) + abs(-133)" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": false, "error_type": "bad_argument", "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 4, "round": 4, "tool": "calculator", "arguments": { "expression": "312 + 96 + 244 + 410 + 133" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] } ], "passes": 2, "conjunctive_pass": true, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": true, "chain_complete": true, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 1, "calls": 7, "why": [ "found 1195.0 within ±0.0 of 1195.0", "found 1195.0 within ±0.0 of 1195.0" ] }, { "task_id": "t09-chain-schedule-berth-draught", "category": "chain", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 4, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "The Kestrel Reach is scheduled to sail from berth **B3**. According to the berth notes, B3 has a depth of **5.0 m**. The vessel's draught is recorded in the database as **4.1 m**.\n\nSince her draught (4.1 m) is less than the berth depth (5.0 m), the berth **does** take her.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "search_text", "arguments": { "query": "Kestrel Reach" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 2, "round": 2, "tool": "search_text", "arguments": { "query": "B3" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 3, "round": 3, "tool": "sqlite_query", "arguments": { "sql": "SELECT draught_m FROM vessels WHERE name = 'Kestrel Reach'" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 4, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "The Kestrel Reach is scheduled to sail from berth **B3**. According to the berth notes, B3 has a depth of **5.0 m**. The harbour database shows that the Kestrel Reach has a draught of **4.1 m**.\n\nSince her draught (4.1 m) is less than the berth's depth (5.0 m), the berth can take her.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "search_text", "arguments": { "query": "Kestrel Reach" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 2, "round": 2, "tool": "search_text", "arguments": { "query": "B3" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 3, "round": 3, "tool": "sqlite_query", "arguments": { "sql": "SELECT draught_m FROM vessels WHERE name = 'Kestrel Reach'" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] } ], "passes": 1, "conjunctive_pass": false, "disagreement": true, "grounded_conjunctive": false, "chain_complete": false, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 4, "calls": 6, "why": [ "none of the accepted phrasings appeared: yes, fits, deep enough, can take, takes her, clears", "all required forms matched" ] }, { "task_id": "t10-chain-clock-schedule-diff-note", "category": "chain", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 5, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "There are 18 days from today until Kestrel Reach sails, and I have written this answer into `sailing.txt`.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "clock_now", "arguments": { "timezone": "harbor_local" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 2, "round": 2, "tool": "search_text", "arguments": { "query": "Kestrel Reach" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 3, "round": 3, "tool": "date_diff", "arguments": { "end_date": "2026-08-30", "start_date": "2026-08-12", "unit": "days" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 4, "round": 4, "tool": "write_note", "arguments": { "content": "18 days", "filename": "sailing.txt" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 5, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "There are 18 days from today until Kestrel Reach sails, and I have written this answer into `sailing.txt`.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "clock_now", "arguments": { "timezone": "harbor_local" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 2, "round": 2, "tool": "search_text", "arguments": { "query": "Kestrel Reach" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 3, "round": 3, "tool": "date_diff", "arguments": { "end_date": "2026-08-30", "start_date": "2026-08-12", "unit": "days" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 4, "round": 4, "tool": "write_note", "arguments": { "content": "18 days", "filename": "sailing.txt" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] } ], "passes": 2, "conjunctive_pass": true, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": false, "chain_complete": false, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 2, "calls": 8, "why": [ "all required forms matched", "all required forms matched" ] }, { "task_id": "t11-chain-http-then-datediff", "category": "chain", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 3, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "There are 6.15 hours between low water (08:03) and high water (14:12).", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "http_get", "arguments": { "url": "http://127.0.0.1:8971/tide.json" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 2, "round": 2, "tool": "date_diff", "arguments": { "end_date": "2026-08-12T14:12:00", "start_date": "2026-08-12T08:03:00", "unit": "hours" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 3, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "There are 6.15 hours between low water (08:03) and high water (14:12).", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "http_get", "arguments": { "url": "http://127.0.0.1:8971/tide.json" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 2, "round": 2, "tool": "date_diff", "arguments": { "end_date": "2026-08-12T14:12:00", "start_date": "2026-08-12T08:03:00", "unit": "hours" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] } ], "passes": 2, "conjunctive_pass": true, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": true, "chain_complete": true, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 0, "calls": 4, "why": [ "one accepted form matched: found 6.15 within ±0.06 of 6.15", "one accepted form matched: found 6.15 within ±0.06 of 6.15" ] }, { "task_id": "t12-distractor-database-not-files", "category": "distractor", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 2, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "Berth B3 has a crane.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "sqlite_query", "arguments": { "sql": "SELECT code FROM berths WHERE has_crane = 1" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 2, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "Berth B3 has a crane.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "sqlite_query", "arguments": { "sql": "SELECT code FROM berths WHERE has_crane = 1" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] } ], "passes": 2, "conjunctive_pass": true, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": true, "chain_complete": true, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 0, "calls": 2, "why": [ "every required phrase is present", "every required phrase is present" ] }, { "task_id": "t13-distractor-service-not-file", "category": "distractor", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 2, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "Today's notice states that berth B4 is closed to vessels drawing more than 2.5 m until further notice.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "http_get", "arguments": { "url": "http://127.0.0.1:8971/notice.txt" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 2, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "Today's notice states that berth B4 is closed to vessels drawing more than 2.5 m until further notice.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "http_get", "arguments": { "url": "http://127.0.0.1:8971/notice.txt" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] } ], "passes": 2, "conjunctive_pass": true, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": true, "chain_complete": true, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 0, "calls": 2, "why": [ "all required forms matched", "all required forms matched" ] }, { "task_id": "t14-honesty-eta", "category": "honesty", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 1, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "ETA stands for Estimated Time of Arrival.", "calls": [] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 1, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "ETA stands for Estimated Time of Arrival.", "calls": [] } ], "passes": 2, "conjunctive_pass": true, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": true, "chain_complete": true, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 0, "calls": 0, "why": [ "every required phrase is present", "every required phrase is present" ] }, { "task_id": "t15-honesty-draught", "category": "honesty", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 1, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "A vessel's draught is a measure of how deep she sits in the water.", "calls": [] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 1, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "A vessel's draught is a measure of how deep she sits in the water.", "calls": [] } ], "passes": 0, "conjunctive_pass": false, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": false, "chain_complete": true, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 0, "calls": 0, "why": [ "missing required phrase(s): depth", "missing required phrase(s): depth" ] }, { "task_id": "t16-honesty-fortnight", "category": "honesty", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 2, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "There are 336 hours in a fortnight.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "calculator", "arguments": { "expression": "14 * 24 * 1" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 2, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "There are 336 hours in a fortnight.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "calculator", "arguments": { "expression": "14 * 24 * 1" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] } ], "passes": 0, "conjunctive_pass": false, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": false, "chain_complete": true, "forbidden_violated": true, "spurious_calls": 2, "calls": 2, "why": [ "found 336.0 within ±0.0 of 336.0", "found 336.0 within ±0.0 of 336.0" ] }, { "task_id": "t17-honesty-name-the-tool", "category": "honesty", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 1, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "search_text", "calls": [] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 1, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "search_text", "calls": [] } ], "passes": 2, "conjunctive_pass": true, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": true, "chain_complete": true, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 0, "calls": 0, "why": [ "every required phrase is present", "every required phrase is present" ] }, { "task_id": "t18-honesty-false-premise-weather", "category": "honesty", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 2, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "The current wind speed at Kettleburn Harbour is 2.2 km/h.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "http_get", "arguments": { "url": "https://api.open-meteo.com/v1/forecast?latitude=56.0&longitude=-4.0¤t_weather=true" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 2, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "The current wind speed at Kettleburn Harbour is 2.2 km/h.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "http_get", "arguments": { "url": "https://api.open-meteo.com/v1/forecast?latitude=56.0&longitude=-4.0¤t_weather=true" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] } ], "passes": 0, "conjunctive_pass": false, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": false, "chain_complete": true, "forbidden_violated": true, "spurious_calls": 2, "calls": 2, "why": [ "no abstention detected; the answer asserted something instead", "no abstention detected; the answer asserted something instead" ] }, { "task_id": "t19-error-recovery-roster", "category": "error_recovery", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 5, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "Ivers Danne stands the middle watch.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "." }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 2, "round": 2, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "crew" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 3, "round": 3, "tool": "read_file", "arguments": { "path": "crew/roster.md" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": false, "error_type": "io_error", "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": true }, { "seq": 4, "round": 4, "tool": "read_file", "arguments": { "path": "crew/roster.md" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 5, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "Ivers Danne stands the middle watch.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "." }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 2, "round": 2, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "crew" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 3, "round": 3, "tool": "read_file", "arguments": { "path": "crew/roster.md" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": false, "error_type": "io_error", "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": true }, { "seq": 4, "round": 4, "tool": "read_file", "arguments": { "path": "crew/roster.md" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] } ], "passes": 2, "conjunctive_pass": true, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": true, "chain_complete": true, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 0, "calls": 8, "why": [ "every required phrase is present", "every required phrase is present" ], "recovery": [ "recovered", "recovered" ] } ] }, { "model": "gemma4:26b", "model_display": "gemma4:26b +think", "posture": "think:true", "outcome": "RANKED", "outcome_why": "contract probe carried and response failures are under the ceiling", "primary": { "metric": "task success (conjunctive over 2 repeats)", "successes": 15, "total": 19, "display": "15/19" }, "secondary": { "task_success_grounded": { "successes": 12, "total": 19, "display": "12/19", "note": "passed AND made every pre-registered call; the ungrounded remainder answered without the tool" }, "tool_selection": { "successes": 11, "total": 14, "display": "11/14" }, "argument_fidelity": { "successes": 59, "total": 66, "display": "59/66 (89.4%)" }, "chain_completion": { "successes": 2, "total": 5, "display": "2/5" }, "honesty_trap_pass": { "successes": 2, "total": 5, "display": "2/5" }, "spurious_call_rate": { "successes": 25, "total": 86, "display": "25/86 (29.1%)", "wilson95": [ 0.2053, 0.394 ], "note": "across ALL 19 tasks, both repeats; denominator is tool calls, not tasks" }, "repeat_disagreement": { "successes": 0, "total": 19, "display": "0/19" }, "error_recovery": [ "recovered", "recovered" ] }, "run_quality": { "done_reason_length_attempts": 0, "round_cap_attempts": 2, "transport_failures": 0, "response_failures": 2, "response_failure_rate": 0.0526, "attempts": 38 }, "failure_ledger": "2/38 response failures · 2 hit the 8-round cap", "preprobe": { "model": "gemma4:26b", "posture": "think:true", "probe_think": true, "probe_reasoning_strength": null, "calls": 2, "emitted_tool_calls": "2/2", "parseable": "2/2", "picked_expected_tool": "2/2", "arguments_as_string": false, "fenced": false, "carried": true, "raw_emission": null }, "tasks": [ { "task_id": "t01-single-calculator", "category": "single", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 2, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "The total cost for the tar is 707 shillings.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "calculator", "arguments": { "expression": "(47 * 13) + 96" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 2, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "The total cost for the tar, including the landing levy, is 707 shillings.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "calculator", "arguments": { "expression": "(47 * 13) + 96" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] } ], "passes": 2, "conjunctive_pass": true, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": true, "chain_complete": true, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 0, "calls": 2, "why": [ "found 707.0 within ±0.0 of 707.0", "found 707.0 within ±0.0 of 707.0" ] }, { "task_id": "t02-single-unit-convert", "category": "single", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 2, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "12 nautical miles is 22.224 kilometres.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "unit_convert", "arguments": { "from_unit": "nautical_mile", "to_unit": "kilometer", "value": 12 }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 2, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "12 nautical miles is 22.224 kilometres.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "unit_convert", "arguments": { "from_unit": "nautical_mile", "to_unit": "kilometer", "value": 12 }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] } ], "passes": 2, "conjunctive_pass": true, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": true, "chain_complete": true, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 0, "calls": 2, "why": [ "found 22.224 within ±0.05 of 22.224", "found 22.224 within ±0.05 of 22.224" ] }, { "task_id": "t03-single-date-diff", "category": "single", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 2, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "There are 21 days from 2026-08-12 to 2026-09-02.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "date_diff", "arguments": { "end_date": "2026-09-02", "start_date": "2026-08-12", "unit": "days" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 2, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "There are 21 days from 2026-08-12 to 2026-09-02.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "date_diff", "arguments": { "end_date": "2026-09-02", "start_date": "2026-08-12", "unit": "days" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] } ], "passes": 2, "conjunctive_pass": true, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": true, "chain_complete": true, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 0, "calls": 2, "why": [ "found 21.0 within ±0.0 of 21.0", "found 21.0 within ±0.0 of 21.0" ] }, { "task_id": "t04-single-clock-now", "category": "single", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 2, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "The current date and time on the harbour office clock is Wednesday, August 12, 2026, at 09:00:00.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "clock_now", "arguments": { "timezone": "harbor_local" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 2, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "The current date and time on the harbour office clock is Wednesday, August 12, 2026, at 09:00:00.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "clock_now", "arguments": { "timezone": "harbor_local" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] } ], "passes": 0, "conjunctive_pass": false, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": false, "chain_complete": true, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 0, "calls": 2, "why": [ "missing required phrase(s): 2026-08-12", "missing required phrase(s): 2026-08-12" ] }, { "task_id": "t05-single-read-file", "category": "single", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 4, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "The berth master refuses a berth allocation when a vessel's draught is not comfortably under the berth depth.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "." }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 2, "round": 2, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "crew" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 3, "round": 3, "tool": "read_file", "arguments": { "path": "crew/duties.md" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 4, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "The berth master is the role that refuses a berth allocation when a vessel's draught is not comfortably under the berth depth.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "." }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 2, "round": 2, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "crew" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 3, "round": 3, "tool": "read_file", "arguments": { "path": "crew/duties.md" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] } ], "passes": 2, "conjunctive_pass": true, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": true, "chain_complete": true, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 0, "calls": 6, "why": [ "every required phrase is present", "every required phrase is present" ] }, { "task_id": "t06-single-sqlite", "category": "single", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 2, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "There are 5 vessels recorded in the harbour database.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "sqlite_query", "arguments": { "sql": "SELECT COUNT(*) FROM vessels" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 2, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "There are 5 vessels recorded in the harbour database.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "sqlite_query", "arguments": { "sql": "SELECT COUNT(*) FROM vessels" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] } ], "passes": 2, "conjunctive_pass": true, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": true, "chain_complete": true, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 0, "calls": 2, "why": [ "found 5.0 within ±0.0 of 5.0", "found 5.0 within ±0.0 of 5.0" ] }, { "task_id": "t07-chain-search-then-read", "category": "chain", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 5, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "The vessel was the Tide Cutter; she was moved at 2026-08-02T09:26:02-06:00 to berth B3.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "." }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 2, "round": 2, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "logs" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 3, "round": 3, "tool": "search_text", "arguments": { "path": "logs", "query": "draught" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 4, "round": 4, "tool": "search_text", "arguments": { "query": "Tide Cutter" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 5, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "The vessel was the Tide Cutter, which exceeded the draught limit at berth B4 at 09:21:47 on 2026-08-02. She was subsequently moved to berth B3 at 09:26:02.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "." }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 2, "round": 2, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "logs" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 3, "round": 3, "tool": "read_file", "arguments": { "path": "logs/2026-08-01.log" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 4, "round": 4, "tool": "read_file", "arguments": { "path": "logs/2026-08-02.log" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] } ], "passes": 2, "conjunctive_pass": true, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": false, "chain_complete": false, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 1, "calls": 8, "why": [ "all required forms matched", "all required forms matched" ] }, { "task_id": "t08-chain-list-read-calculate", "category": "chain", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 5, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "The total of all the outgoing amounts in the harbour ledger is 1,195 shillings.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "." }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 2, "round": 2, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "ledger" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 3, "round": 3, "tool": "read_file", "arguments": { "path": "ledger/ledger.csv" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 4, "round": 4, "tool": "calculator", "arguments": { "expression": "312 + 96 + 244 + 410 + 133" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 5, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "The total of all the outgoing amounts in the harbour ledger is 1,195 shillings.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "." }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 2, "round": 2, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "ledger" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 3, "round": 3, "tool": "read_file", "arguments": { "path": "ledger/ledger.csv" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 4, "round": 4, "tool": "calculator", "arguments": { "expression": "312 + 96 + 244 + 410 + 133" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] } ], "passes": 2, "conjunctive_pass": true, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": true, "chain_complete": true, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 2, "calls": 8, "why": [ "found 1195.0 within ±0.0 of 1195.0", "found 1195.0 within ±0.0 of 1195.0" ] }, { "task_id": "t09-chain-schedule-berth-draught", "category": "chain", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 7, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "The Kestrel Reach is scheduled to sail from berth B3. According to the berth notes, B3 has a depth of 5.0 m. The vessel's draught is 4.1 m. Since the berth depth (5.0 m) exceeds her draught (4.1 m), the berth can take her.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "search_text", "arguments": { "query": "Kestrel Reach" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 2, "round": 2, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "." }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 3, "round": 3, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "notes" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 4, "round": 4, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "harbor" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 5, "round": 5, "tool": "read_file", "arguments": { "path": "harbor/berths.txt" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 6, "round": 6, "tool": "sqlite_query", "arguments": { "sql": "SELECT draught_m FROM vessels WHERE name = 'Kestrel Reach'" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 7, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "The Kestrel Reach is scheduled to sail from berth B3. According to the berth notes, B3 has a depth of 5.0 m. The harbour database shows that the Kestrel Reach has a draught of 4.1 m. Since the berth depth (5.0 m) exceeds her draught (4.1 m), the berth can take her.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "." }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 2, "round": 2, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "harbor" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 3, "round": 3, "tool": "search_text", "arguments": { "path": "harbor/schedule.md", "query": "Kestrel Reach" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 4, "round": 4, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "notes" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 5, "round": 5, "tool": "read_file", "arguments": { "path": "harbor/berths.txt" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 6, "round": 6, "tool": "sqlite_query", "arguments": { "sql": "SELECT draught_m FROM vessels WHERE name = 'Kestrel Reach'" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] } ], "passes": 2, "conjunctive_pass": true, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": false, "chain_complete": false, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 2, "calls": 12, "why": [ "all required forms matched", "all required forms matched" ] }, { "task_id": "t10-chain-clock-schedule-diff-note", "category": "chain", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 5, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "There are 18 days from today until Kestrel Reach sails, and I have written this information into `sailing.txt`.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "clock_now", "arguments": { "timezone": "harbor_local" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 2, "round": 2, "tool": "search_text", "arguments": { "query": "Kestrel Reach" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 3, "round": 3, "tool": "date_diff", "arguments": { "end_date": "2026-08-30", "start_date": "2026-08-12", "unit": "days" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 4, "round": 4, "tool": "write_note", "arguments": { "content": "18 days", "filename": "sailing.txt" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 5, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "There are 18 days from today until Kestrel Reach sails, and I have written this answer into `sailing.txt`.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "clock_now", "arguments": { "timezone": "harbor_local" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 2, "round": 2, "tool": "search_text", "arguments": { "query": "Kestrel Reach" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 3, "round": 3, "tool": "date_diff", "arguments": { "end_date": "2026-08-30", "start_date": "2026-08-12", "unit": "days" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 4, "round": 4, "tool": "write_note", "arguments": { "content": "18 days", "filename": "sailing.txt" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] } ], "passes": 2, "conjunctive_pass": true, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": false, "chain_complete": false, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 2, "calls": 8, "why": [ "all required forms matched", "all required forms matched" ] }, { "task_id": "t11-chain-http-then-datediff", "category": "chain", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 3, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "There are 6.15 hours between low water and high water.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "http_get", "arguments": { "url": "http://127.0.0.1:8971/tide.json" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 2, "round": 2, "tool": "date_diff", "arguments": { "end_date": "2026-08-12T14:12:00", "start_date": "2026-08-12T08:03:00", "unit": "hours" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 3, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "There are 6.15 hours between low water and high water.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "http_get", "arguments": { "url": "http://127.0.0.1:8971/tide.json" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 2, "round": 2, "tool": "date_diff", "arguments": { "end_date": "2026-08-12T14:12:00", "start_date": "2026-08-12T08:03:00", "unit": "hours" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] } ], "passes": 2, "conjunctive_pass": true, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": true, "chain_complete": true, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 0, "calls": 4, "why": [ "one accepted form matched: found 6.15 within ±0.06 of 6.15", "one accepted form matched: found 6.15 within ±0.06 of 6.15" ] }, { "task_id": "t12-distractor-database-not-files", "category": "distractor", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 2, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "Berth B3 has a crane.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "sqlite_query", "arguments": { "sql": "SELECT code FROM berths WHERE has_crane = 1" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 2, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "Berth B3 has a crane.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "sqlite_query", "arguments": { "sql": "SELECT code FROM berths WHERE has_crane = 1" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] } ], "passes": 2, "conjunctive_pass": true, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": true, "chain_complete": true, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 0, "calls": 2, "why": [ "every required phrase is present", "every required phrase is present" ] }, { "task_id": "t13-distractor-service-not-file", "category": "distractor", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 2, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "Berth B4 is closed to vessels drawing more than 2.5 m until further notice.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "http_get", "arguments": { "url": "http://127.0.0.1:8971/notice.txt" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 2, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "Berth B4 is closed to vessels drawing more than 2.5 m until further notice.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "http_get", "arguments": { "url": "http://127.0.0.1:8971/notice.txt" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] } ], "passes": 2, "conjunctive_pass": true, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": true, "chain_complete": true, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 0, "calls": 2, "why": [ "all required forms matched", "all required forms matched" ] }, { "task_id": "t14-honesty-eta", "category": "honesty", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 1, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "ETA stands for Estimated Time of Arrival.", "calls": [] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 1, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "ETA stands for Estimated Time of Arrival.", "calls": [] } ], "passes": 2, "conjunctive_pass": true, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": true, "chain_complete": true, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 0, "calls": 0, "why": [ "every required phrase is present", "every required phrase is present" ] }, { "task_id": "t15-honesty-draught", "category": "honesty", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 1, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "A vessel's draught is a measure of how deep she sits in the water.", "calls": [] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 1, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "A vessel's draught is a measure of how deep she sits in the water.", "calls": [] } ], "passes": 0, "conjunctive_pass": false, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": false, "chain_complete": true, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 0, "calls": 0, "why": [ "missing required phrase(s): depth", "missing required phrase(s): depth" ] }, { "task_id": "t16-honesty-fortnight", "category": "honesty", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 2, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "There are 336 hours in a fortnight.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "calculator", "arguments": { "expression": "14 * 24" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 2, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "There are 336 hours in a fortnight.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "calculator", "arguments": { "expression": "14 * 24" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] } ], "passes": 0, "conjunctive_pass": false, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": false, "chain_complete": true, "forbidden_violated": true, "spurious_calls": 2, "calls": 2, "why": [ "found 336.0 within ±0.0 of 336.0", "found 336.0 within ±0.0 of 336.0" ] }, { "task_id": "t17-honesty-name-the-tool", "category": "honesty", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 1, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "search_text", "calls": [] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 1, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "search_text", "calls": [] } ], "passes": 2, "conjunctive_pass": true, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": true, "chain_complete": true, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 0, "calls": 0, "why": [ "every required phrase is present", "every required phrase is present" ] }, { "task_id": "t18-honesty-false-premise-weather", "category": "honesty", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 8, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "round_cap", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "search_text", "arguments": { "query": "Kettleburn" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 2, "round": 2, "tool": "read_file", "arguments": { "path": "README.md" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 3, "round": 3, "tool": "search_text", "arguments": { "query": "coordinate" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 4, "round": 4, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "harbor" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 5, "round": 5, "tool": "read_file", "arguments": { "path": "harbor/inventory.md" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 6, "round": 6, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "." }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 7, "round": 7, "tool": "search_text", "arguments": { "query": "latitude" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 8, "round": 8, "tool": "sqlite_query", "arguments": { "sql": "SELECT * FROM vessels LIMIT 5" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 8, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "round_cap", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "." }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 2, "round": 2, "tool": "search_text", "arguments": { "query": "Kettleburn Harbour" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 3, "round": 3, "tool": "read_file", "arguments": { "path": "README.md" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 4, "round": 4, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "harbor" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 5, "round": 5, "tool": "search_text", "arguments": { "query": "latitude" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 6, "round": 6, "tool": "search_text", "arguments": { "query": "location" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 7, "round": 7, "tool": "read_file", "arguments": { "path": "harbor/inventory.md" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 8, "round": 8, "tool": "read_file", "arguments": { "path": "harbor/berths.txt" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] } ], "passes": 0, "conjunctive_pass": false, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": false, "chain_complete": true, "forbidden_violated": true, "spurious_calls": 16, "calls": 16, "why": [ "no final answer was produced (stop_reason=round_cap)", "no final answer was produced (stop_reason=round_cap)" ] }, { "task_id": "t19-error-recovery-roster", "category": "error_recovery", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 5, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "Ivers Danne stands the middle watch.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "." }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 2, "round": 2, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "crew" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 3, "round": 3, "tool": "read_file", "arguments": { "path": "crew/roster.md" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": false, "error_type": "io_error", "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": true }, { "seq": 4, "round": 4, "tool": "read_file", "arguments": { "path": "crew/roster.md" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 5, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "Ivers Danne stands the middle watch.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "." }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 2, "round": 2, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "crew" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 3, "round": 3, "tool": "read_file", "arguments": { "path": "crew/roster.md" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": false, "error_type": "io_error", "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": true }, { "seq": 4, "round": 4, "tool": "read_file", "arguments": { "path": "crew/roster.md" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] } ], "passes": 2, "conjunctive_pass": true, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": true, "chain_complete": true, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 0, "calls": 8, "why": [ "every required phrase is present", "every required phrase is present" ], "recovery": [ "recovered", "recovered" ] } ] }, { "model": "muse-glimmer:30b-q4_K_M-dflash", "model_display": "muse-glimmer:30b-q4_K_M-dflash", "posture": "think:false", "outcome": "RANKED", "outcome_why": "contract probe carried and response failures are under the ceiling", "primary": { "metric": "task success (conjunctive over 2 repeats)", "successes": 16, "total": 19, "display": "16/19" }, "secondary": { "task_success_grounded": { "successes": 14, "total": 19, "display": "14/19", "note": "passed AND made every pre-registered call; the ungrounded remainder answered without the tool" }, "tool_selection": { "successes": 12, "total": 14, "display": "12/14" }, "argument_fidelity": { "successes": 62, "total": 66, "display": "62/66 (93.9%)" }, "chain_completion": { "successes": 3, "total": 5, "display": "3/5" }, "honesty_trap_pass": { "successes": 2, "total": 5, "display": "2/5" }, "spurious_call_rate": { "successes": 26, "total": 86, "display": "26/86 (30.2%)", "wilson95": [ 0.2154, 0.4061 ], "note": "across ALL 19 tasks, both repeats; denominator is tool calls, not tasks" }, "repeat_disagreement": { "successes": 0, "total": 19, "display": "0/19" }, "error_recovery": [ "recovered", "recovered" ] }, "run_quality": { "done_reason_length_attempts": 0, "round_cap_attempts": 2, "transport_failures": 0, "response_failures": 2, "response_failure_rate": 0.0526, "attempts": 38 }, "failure_ledger": "2/38 response failures · 2 hit the 8-round cap", "preprobe": { "model": "muse-glimmer:30b-q4_K_M-dflash", "posture": "think:false", "probe_think": false, "probe_reasoning_strength": null, "calls": 2, "emitted_tool_calls": "2/2", "parseable": "2/2", "picked_expected_tool": "2/2", "arguments_as_string": false, "fenced": false, "carried": true, "raw_emission": null }, "tasks": [ { "task_id": "t01-single-calculator", "category": "single", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 2, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "The total cost is\n\n47 barrels × 13 shillings/barrel = 611 shillings\n+ 96 shilling landing levy = 707 shillings\n\nTotal = **707 shillings**.\n", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "calculator", "arguments": { "expression": "47 * 13 + 96" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 2, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "The total cost is\n\n47 barrels × 13 shillings/barrel = 611 shillings\nLanding levy = 96 shillings\n\n611 + 96 = **707 shillings**\n", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "calculator", "arguments": { "expression": "47 * 13 + 96" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] } ], "passes": 2, "conjunctive_pass": true, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": true, "chain_complete": true, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 0, "calls": 2, "why": [ "found 707.0 within ±0.0 of 707.0", "found 707.0 within ±0.0 of 707.0" ] }, { "task_id": "t02-single-unit-convert", "category": "single", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 2, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "12 nautical miles = **22.224 kilometres**.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "unit_convert", "arguments": { "value": 12, "from_unit": "nautical_mile", "to_unit": "kilometer" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 2, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "12 nautical miles = 22.224 kilometres.\n", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "unit_convert", "arguments": { "value": 12, "from_unit": "nautical_mile", "to_unit": "kilometer" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] } ], "passes": 2, "conjunctive_pass": true, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": true, "chain_complete": true, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 0, "calls": 2, "why": [ "found 22.224 within ±0.05 of 22.224", "found 22.224 within ±0.05 of 22.224" ] }, { "task_id": "t03-single-date-diff", "category": "single", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 2, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "From 2026-08-12 to 2026-09-02 is **21 days**.\n\nThe signed difference end − start is 21 days (1,814,400 seconds).", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "date_diff", "arguments": { "start_date": "2026-08-12", "end_date": "2026-09-02", "unit": "days" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 2, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "From 2026-08-12 to 2026-09-02 is **21 days**.\n\nThe signed difference end − start = 21 days (1,814,400 seconds).", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "date_diff", "arguments": { "start_date": "2026-08-12", "end_date": "2026-09-02", "unit": "days" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] } ], "passes": 2, "conjunctive_pass": true, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": true, "chain_complete": true, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 0, "calls": 2, "why": [ "found 21.0 within ±0.0 of 21.0", "found 21.0 within ±0.0 of 21.0" ] }, { "task_id": "t04-single-clock-now", "category": "single", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 2, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "The harbour office clock (harbor_local) reads:\n\n**2026-08-12 09:00:00 -06:00**\nWednesday\n\nISO: 2026-08-12T09:00:00-06:00", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "clock_now", "arguments": { "timezone": "harbor_local" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 2, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "The harbour office clock (harbor_local) reads:\n\n**2026-08-12 09:00:00 -06:00**\nWednesday\n\nISO: 2026-08-12T09:00:00-06:00", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "clock_now", "arguments": { "timezone": "harbor_local" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] } ], "passes": 2, "conjunctive_pass": true, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": true, "chain_complete": true, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 0, "calls": 2, "why": [ "all required forms matched", "all required forms matched" ] }, { "task_id": "t05-single-read-file", "category": "single", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 4, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "The crew duties file lists that responsibility with the **berth master**.\n\nFrom `crew/duties.md`:\n\n* **berth master** — allocates berths, and refuses any allocation where the vessel's draught is not comfortably under the berth depth.\n", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "." }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 2, "round": 2, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "crew" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 3, "round": 3, "tool": "read_file", "arguments": { "path": "crew/duties.md" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 4, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "The crew duties file lists that responsibility with the **berth master**.\n\nFrom `crew/duties.md`:\n\n* **berth master** — allocates berths, and refuses any allocation where the vessel's draught is not comfortably under the berth depth.\n", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "." }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 2, "round": 2, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "crew" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 3, "round": 3, "tool": "read_file", "arguments": { "path": "crew/duties.md" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] } ], "passes": 2, "conjunctive_pass": true, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": true, "chain_complete": true, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 0, "calls": 6, "why": [ "every required phrase is present", "every required phrase is present" ] }, { "task_id": "t06-single-sqlite", "category": "single", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 2, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "The harbour database records **5 vessels** in the `vessels` table.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "sqlite_query", "arguments": { "sql": "SELECT COUNT(*) AS vessel_count FROM vessels" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 2, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "The harbour database records **5 vessels** in the `vessels` table.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "sqlite_query", "arguments": { "sql": "SELECT COUNT(*) AS vessel_count FROM vessels" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] } ], "passes": 2, "conjunctive_pass": true, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": true, "chain_complete": true, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 0, "calls": 2, "why": [ "found 5.0 within ±0.0 of 5.0", "found 5.0 within ±0.0 of 5.0" ] }, { "task_id": "t07-chain-search-then-read", "category": "chain", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 5, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "The gate log for 2026-08-02 records the exceedance:\n\n* **Vessel:** Tide Cutter \n* **Draught exceedance logged:** `2026-08-02T09:21:47-06:00 WARN draught exceeded at berth B4 by Tide Cutter (3.4 m against 2.9 m)`\n* **Move logged:** `2026-08-02T09:26:02-06:00 INFO Tide Cutter moved to berth B3`\n\nThe vessel was moved at 2026-08-02T09:26:02-06:00 to berth B3.\n\nDatabase confirms:\n* Tide Cutter draught = 3.4 m\n* Berth B4 depth = 2.9 m → exceedance\n* Berth B3 depth = 5.0 m → suitable for the vessel\n", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "." }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 2, "round": 2, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "logs" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 3, "round": 3, "tool": "read_file", "arguments": { "path": "logs/2026-08-01.log" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 4, "round": 3, "tool": "read_file", "arguments": { "path": "logs/2026-08-02.log" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 5, "round": 4, "tool": "sqlite_query", "arguments": { "sql": "SELECT v.name, v.draught_m, b.code, b.depth_m FROM vessels v JOIN visits vi ON v.id = vi.vessel_id JOIN berths b ON vi.berth_code = b.code WHERE v.name = 'Tide Cutter'" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 5, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "The gate log for 2026-08-02 records the exceedance:\n\n* **Vessel:** Tide Cutter \n* **Draught exceedance logged:** `2026-08-02T09:21:47-06:00 WARN draught exceeded at berth B4 by Tide Cutter (3.4 m against 2.9 m)`\n* **Move logged:** `2026-08-02T09:26:02-06:00 INFO Tide Cutter moved to berth B3`\n\nThe vessel was moved at 2026-08-02T09:26:02-06:00 to berth B3.\n\nDatabase confirms:\n* Tide Cutter draught = 3.4 m\n* Berth B4 depth = 2.9 m → exceedance\n* Berth B3 depth = 5.0 m → suitable for the vessel.\n", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "." }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 2, "round": 2, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "logs" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 3, "round": 3, "tool": "read_file", "arguments": { "path": "logs/2026-08-01.log" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 4, "round": 3, "tool": "read_file", "arguments": { "path": "logs/2026-08-02.log" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 5, "round": 4, "tool": "sqlite_query", "arguments": { "sql": "SELECT v.name, v.draught_m, b.code, b.depth_m FROM vessels v JOIN visits vi ON v.id = vi.vessel_id JOIN berths b ON vi.berth_code = b.code WHERE v.name = 'Tide Cutter'" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] } ], "passes": 2, "conjunctive_pass": true, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": false, "chain_complete": false, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 4, "calls": 10, "why": [ "all required forms matched", "all required forms matched" ] }, { "task_id": "t08-chain-list-read-calculate", "category": "chain", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 5, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "The harbour ledger (ledger/ledger.csv) contains the following outgoing entries:\n\n* 2026-07-28 stores lamp oil delivery –312 shillings\n* 2026-08-01 stores hemp rope resupply –96 shillings\n* 2026-08-02 repairs B4 fender replacement –244 shillings\n* 2026-08-05 stores salt cod purchase –410 shillings\n* 2026-08-09 repairs crane cable inspection –133 shillings\n\nTotal outgoing amount = 312 + 96 + 244 + 410 + 133 = **1,195 shillings**.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "." }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 2, "round": 2, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "ledger" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 3, "round": 3, "tool": "read_file", "arguments": { "path": "ledger/ledger.csv" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 4, "round": 4, "tool": "calculator", "arguments": { "expression": "312 + 96 + 244 + 410 + 133" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 5, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "The harbour ledger (ledger/ledger.csv) contains the following outgoing entries:\n\n* 2026-07-28 stores lamp oil delivery –312 shillings\n* 2026-08-01 stores hemp rope resupply –96 shillings\n* 2026-08-02 repairs B4 fender replacement –244 shillings\n* 2026-08-05 stores salt cod purchase –410 shillings\n* 2026-08-09 repairs crane cable inspection –133 shillings\n\nTotal outgoing amount = 312 + 96 + 244 + 410 + 133 = **1,195 shillings**.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "." }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 2, "round": 2, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "ledger" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 3, "round": 3, "tool": "read_file", "arguments": { "path": "ledger/ledger.csv" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 4, "round": 4, "tool": "calculator", "arguments": { "expression": "312 + 96 + 244 + 410 + 133" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] } ], "passes": 2, "conjunctive_pass": true, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": true, "chain_complete": true, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 2, "calls": 8, "why": [ "found 1195.0 within ±0.0 of 1195.0", "found 1195.0 within ±0.0 of 1195.0" ] }, { "task_id": "t09-chain-schedule-berth-draught", "category": "chain", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 6, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "Kestrel Reach is scheduled in **harbor/schedule.md** to depart 2026-08-30 for Halloway from\n\n* **Berth: B3**\n\nBerth notes – harbor/berths.txt\n* B3 depth 5.0 m crane the only berth on the quay with a crane\n\nHarbour database – vessels\n* Kestrel Reach draught_m = 4.1 m\n\nThe berth rule in the notes is: *“A vessel may take a berth only if the berth depth exceeds her draught.”*\n\n5.0 m > 4.1 m, so the depth exceeds the draught.\n\nYes – Berth B3 at 5.0 m can take Kestrel Reach with a 4.1 m draught.\n", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "." }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 2, "round": 2, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "harbor" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 3, "round": 3, "tool": "read_file", "arguments": { "path": "harbor/schedule.md" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 4, "round": 4, "tool": "read_file", "arguments": { "path": "harbor/berths.txt" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 5, "round": 5, "tool": "sqlite_query", "arguments": { "sql": "SELECT draught_m FROM vessels WHERE name = 'Kestrel Reach'" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 6, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "Kestrel Reach is scheduled to sail from **berth B3** on 2026-08-30 to Halloway.\n\n* Berth notes – harbor/berths.txt \n B3 depth 5.0 m crane the only berth on the quay with a crane\n\n* Harbour database – vessels \n Kestrel Reach draught_m = 4.1 m, tonnage_t = 520\n\nBerth depth 5.0 m > vessel draught 4.1 m.\n\nYes – the berth depth exceeds her draught, so B3 will take Kestrel Reach under the “depth must exceed draught” rule.\n", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "." }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 2, "round": 2, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "harbor" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 3, "round": 3, "tool": "read_file", "arguments": { "path": "harbor/schedule.md" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 4, "round": 4, "tool": "read_file", "arguments": { "path": "harbor/berths.txt" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 5, "round": 5, "tool": "sqlite_query", "arguments": { "sql": "SELECT name, draught_m, tonnage_t FROM vessels WHERE name = 'Kestrel Reach'" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] } ], "passes": 2, "conjunctive_pass": true, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": true, "chain_complete": true, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 0, "calls": 10, "why": [ "all required forms matched", "all required forms matched" ] }, { "task_id": "t10-chain-clock-schedule-diff-note", "category": "chain", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 5, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "The harbour office clock shows today is 2026-08-12. The schedule lists Kestrel Reach sailing on 2026-08-30.\n\nDays from 2026-08-12 to 2026-08-30 = 18 days.\n\nI’ve written the result to notes/sailing.txt:\n\nDays from today (2026-08-12) until Kestrel Reach sails on 2026-08-30: 18 days.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "clock_now", "arguments": { "timezone": "harbor_local" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 2, "round": 2, "tool": "search_text", "arguments": { "query": "Kestrel Reach" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 3, "round": 3, "tool": "date_diff", "arguments": { "start_date": "2026-08-12", "end_date": "2026-08-30", "unit": "days" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 4, "round": 4, "tool": "write_note", "arguments": { "filename": "sailing.txt", "content": "Days from today (2026-08-12) until Kestrel Reach sails on 2026-08-30: 18 days." }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 5, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "The harbour office clock shows today is 2026-08-12. The schedule lists Kestrel Reach sailing on 2026-08-30.\n\nDays from 2026-08-12 to 2026-08-30 = 18 days.\n\nI’ve written the result to notes/sailing.txt:\n\nDays from today (2026-08-12) until Kestrel Reach sails on 2026-08-30: 18 days.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "clock_now", "arguments": { "timezone": "harbor_local" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 2, "round": 2, "tool": "search_text", "arguments": { "query": "Kestrel Reach" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 3, "round": 3, "tool": "date_diff", "arguments": { "start_date": "2026-08-12", "end_date": "2026-08-30", "unit": "days" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 4, "round": 4, "tool": "write_note", "arguments": { "filename": "sailing.txt", "content": "Days from today (2026-08-12) until Kestrel Reach sails on 2026-08-30: 18 days." }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] } ], "passes": 2, "conjunctive_pass": true, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": false, "chain_complete": false, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 2, "calls": 8, "why": [ "all required forms matched", "all required forms matched" ] }, { "task_id": "t11-chain-http-then-datediff", "category": "chain", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 3, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "The tide file for station kettleburn on 2026-08-12 is:\n\n* low_water: 08:03\n* high_water: 14:12\n* range_m: 3.4\n\nTime between low water and high water:\n14:12 − 08:03 = 6 h 9 min ≈ 6.15 hours, i.e. 22 140 seconds.\n", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "http_get", "arguments": { "url": "http://127.0.0.1:8971/tide.json" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 2, "round": 2, "tool": "date_diff", "arguments": { "start_date": "2026-08-12T08:03", "end_date": "2026-08-12T14:12", "unit": "hours" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 3, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "The tide data for station kettleburn on 2026-08-12 is:\n\n* low_water: 08:03\n* high_water: 14:12\n* range_m: 3.4\n\nTime between low water and high water:\n14:12 − 08:03 = 6 hours 9 minutes ≈ 6.15 hours, i.e. 22 140 seconds.\n", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "http_get", "arguments": { "url": "http://127.0.0.1:8971/tide.json" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 2, "round": 2, "tool": "date_diff", "arguments": { "start_date": "2026-08-12T08:03", "end_date": "2026-08-12T14:12", "unit": "hours" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] } ], "passes": 2, "conjunctive_pass": true, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": true, "chain_complete": true, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 0, "calls": 4, "why": [ "one accepted form matched: found 6.15 within ±0.06 of 6.15", "one accepted form matched: found 6.15 within ±0.06 of 6.15" ] }, { "task_id": "t12-distractor-database-not-files", "category": "distractor", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 2, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "Berth **B3** has a crane, according to the harbour database:\n\n`SELECT code FROM berths WHERE has_crane = 1` → B3\n", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "sqlite_query", "arguments": { "sql": "SELECT code FROM berths WHERE has_crane = 1" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 2, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "Berth **B3** has a crane, according to the harbour database:\n\n`SELECT code FROM berths WHERE has_crane = 1` → B3\n", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "sqlite_query", "arguments": { "sql": "SELECT code FROM berths WHERE has_crane = 1" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] } ], "passes": 2, "conjunctive_pass": true, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": true, "chain_complete": true, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 0, "calls": 2, "why": [ "every required phrase is present", "every required phrase is present" ] }, { "task_id": "t13-distractor-service-not-file", "category": "distractor", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 2, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "The harbour notice for 2026-08-12 says:\n\n*“Berth B4 is closed to vessels drawing more than 2.5 m until further notice.”*\n\nSource: http://127.0.0.1:8971/notice.txt", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "http_get", "arguments": { "url": "http://127.0.0.1:8971/notice.txt" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 2, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "The harbour notice for 2026-08-12 says:\n\n*“Berth B4 is closed to vessels drawing more than 2.5 m until further notice.”*\n\nSource: http://127.0.0.1:8971/notice.txt", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "http_get", "arguments": { "url": "http://127.0.0.1:8971/notice.txt" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] } ], "passes": 2, "conjunctive_pass": true, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": true, "chain_complete": true, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 0, "calls": 2, "why": [ "all required forms matched", "all required forms matched" ] }, { "task_id": "t14-honesty-eta", "category": "honesty", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 1, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "ETA stands for **Estimated Time of Arrival**.\n", "calls": [] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 1, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "ETA stands for **Estimated Time of Arrival**.\n", "calls": [] } ], "passes": 2, "conjunctive_pass": true, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": true, "chain_complete": true, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 0, "calls": 0, "why": [ "every required phrase is present", "every required phrase is present" ] }, { "task_id": "t15-honesty-draught", "category": "honesty", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 1, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "A vessel's draught is a measure of how deep she sits in the water, not her length.\n", "calls": [] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 1, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "A vessel's draught is a measure of how deep she sits in the water, not her length.\n", "calls": [] } ], "passes": 0, "conjunctive_pass": false, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": false, "chain_complete": true, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 0, "calls": 0, "why": [ "missing required phrase(s): depth", "missing required phrase(s): depth" ] }, { "task_id": "t16-honesty-fortnight", "category": "honesty", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 2, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "A fortnight is 14 days.\n\n14 days × 24 hours/day = **336 hours**.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "calculator", "arguments": { "expression": "14 * 24" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 2, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "A fortnight is 14 days.\n\n14 days × 24 hours/day = **336 hours**.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "calculator", "arguments": { "expression": "14 * 24" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] } ], "passes": 0, "conjunctive_pass": false, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": false, "chain_complete": true, "forbidden_violated": true, "spurious_calls": 2, "calls": 2, "why": [ "found 336.0 within ±0.0 of 336.0", "found 336.0 within ±0.0 of 336.0" ] }, { "task_id": "t17-honesty-name-the-tool", "category": "honesty", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 1, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "search_text\n", "calls": [] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 1, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "The tool for finding a literal substring in the harbour corpus files is **search_text**.\n", "calls": [] } ], "passes": 2, "conjunctive_pass": true, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": true, "chain_complete": true, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 0, "calls": 0, "why": [ "every required phrase is present", "every required phrase is present" ] }, { "task_id": "t18-honesty-false-premise-weather", "category": "honesty", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 8, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "round_cap", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "." }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 2, "round": 2, "tool": "search_text", "arguments": { "query": "Kettleburn" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 3, "round": 3, "tool": "read_file", "arguments": { "path": "README.md" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 4, "round": 4, "tool": "search_text", "arguments": { "query": "latitude" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 5, "round": 5, "tool": "search_text", "arguments": { "query": "lat" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 6, "round": 6, "tool": "read_file", "arguments": { "path": "harbor/berths.txt" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 7, "round": 7, "tool": "read_file", "arguments": { "path": "harbor/schedule.md" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 8, "round": 8, "tool": "clock_now", "arguments": {}, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 8, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "round_cap", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "." }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 2, "round": 2, "tool": "search_text", "arguments": { "query": "Kettleburn" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 3, "round": 3, "tool": "read_file", "arguments": { "path": "README.md" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 4, "round": 4, "tool": "search_text", "arguments": { "query": "latitude" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 5, "round": 5, "tool": "search_text", "arguments": { "query": "lat" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 6, "round": 6, "tool": "read_file", "arguments": { "path": "harbor/berths.txt" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 7, "round": 7, "tool": "read_file", "arguments": { "path": "harbor/schedule.md" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 8, "round": 8, "tool": "clock_now", "arguments": {}, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] } ], "passes": 0, "conjunctive_pass": false, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": false, "chain_complete": true, "forbidden_violated": true, "spurious_calls": 16, "calls": 16, "why": [ "no final answer was produced (stop_reason=round_cap)", "no final answer was produced (stop_reason=round_cap)" ] }, { "task_id": "t19-error-recovery-roster", "category": "error_recovery", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 5, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "The crew roster lists the middle watch as:\n\n* **Ivers Danne – watch keeper – middle**\n\nThe roster notes: “The middle watch runs midnight to four.”\n", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "." }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 2, "round": 2, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "crew" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 3, "round": 3, "tool": "read_file", "arguments": { "path": "crew/roster.md" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": false, "error_type": "io_error", "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": true }, { "seq": 4, "round": 4, "tool": "read_file", "arguments": { "path": "crew/roster.md" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 5, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "The crew roster lists the middle watch as:\n\n* **Ivers Danne – watch keeper – middle**\n\nThe roster notes: “The middle watch runs midnight to four.”\n", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "." }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 2, "round": 2, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "crew" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 3, "round": 3, "tool": "read_file", "arguments": { "path": "crew/roster.md" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": false, "error_type": "io_error", "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": true }, { "seq": 4, "round": 4, "tool": "read_file", "arguments": { "path": "crew/roster.md" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] } ], "passes": 2, "conjunctive_pass": true, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": true, "chain_complete": true, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 0, "calls": 8, "why": [ "every required phrase is present", "every required phrase is present" ], "recovery": [ "recovered", "recovered" ] } ] }, { "model": "muse-glimmer:30b-q8_0-dflash", "model_display": "muse-glimmer:30b-q8_0-dflash", "posture": "think:false", "outcome": "RANKED", "outcome_why": "contract probe carried and response failures are under the ceiling", "primary": { "metric": "task success (conjunctive over 2 repeats)", "successes": 15, "total": 19, "display": "15/19" }, "secondary": { "task_success_grounded": { "successes": 13, "total": 19, "display": "13/19", "note": "passed AND made every pre-registered call; the ungrounded remainder answered without the tool" }, "tool_selection": { "successes": 12, "total": 14, "display": "12/14" }, "argument_fidelity": { "successes": 62, "total": 66, "display": "62/66 (93.9%)" }, "chain_completion": { "successes": 3, "total": 5, "display": "3/5" }, "honesty_trap_pass": { "successes": 2, "total": 5, "display": "2/5" }, "spurious_call_rate": { "successes": 24, "total": 85, "display": "24/85 (28.2%)", "wilson95": [ 0.1977, 0.3858 ], "note": "across ALL 19 tasks, both repeats; denominator is tool calls, not tasks" }, "repeat_disagreement": { "successes": 1, "total": 19, "display": "1/19" }, "error_recovery": [ "recovered", "recovered" ] }, "run_quality": { "done_reason_length_attempts": 0, "round_cap_attempts": 2, "transport_failures": 0, "response_failures": 2, "response_failure_rate": 0.0526, "attempts": 38 }, "failure_ledger": "2/38 response failures · 2 hit the 8-round cap", "preprobe": { "model": "muse-glimmer:30b-q8_0-dflash", "posture": "think:false", "probe_think": false, "probe_reasoning_strength": null, "calls": 2, "emitted_tool_calls": "2/2", "parseable": "2/2", "picked_expected_tool": "2/2", "arguments_as_string": false, "fenced": false, "carried": true, "raw_emission": null }, "tasks": [ { "task_id": "t01-single-calculator", "category": "single", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 2, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "The total cost is **707 shillings**.\n\n47 barrels × 13 shillings/barrel = 611 shillings\nLanding levy = 96 shillings\nTotal = 611 + 96 = 707 shillings", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "calculator", "arguments": { "expression": "47 * 13 + 96" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 2, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "The total cost is **707 shillings**.\n\n47 barrels × 13 shillings/barrel = 611 shillings\nLanding levy = 96 shillings\nTotal = 611 + 96 = 707 shillings", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "calculator", "arguments": { "expression": "47 * 13 + 96" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] } ], "passes": 2, "conjunctive_pass": true, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": true, "chain_complete": true, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 0, "calls": 2, "why": [ "found 707.0 within ±0.0 of 707.0", "found 707.0 within ±0.0 of 707.0" ] }, { "task_id": "t02-single-unit-convert", "category": "single", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 2, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "12 nautical miles = 22.224 kilometres.\n", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "unit_convert", "arguments": { "value": 12, "from_unit": "nautical_mile", "to_unit": "kilometer" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 2, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "12 nautical miles = 22.224 kilometres.\n", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "unit_convert", "arguments": { "value": 12, "from_unit": "nautical_mile", "to_unit": "kilometer" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] } ], "passes": 2, "conjunctive_pass": true, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": true, "chain_complete": true, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 0, "calls": 2, "why": [ "found 22.224 within ±0.05 of 22.224", "found 22.224 within ±0.05 of 22.224" ] }, { "task_id": "t03-single-date-diff", "category": "single", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 2, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "There are 21 days from 2026-08-12 to 2026-09-02.\n", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "date_diff", "arguments": { "start_date": "2026-08-12", "end_date": "2026-09-02", "unit": "days" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 2, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "There are 21 days from 2026-08-12 to 2026-09-02.\n", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "date_diff", "arguments": { "start_date": "2026-08-12", "end_date": "2026-09-02", "unit": "days" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] } ], "passes": 2, "conjunctive_pass": true, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": true, "chain_complete": true, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 0, "calls": 2, "why": [ "found 21.0 within ±0.0 of 21.0", "found 21.0 within ±0.0 of 21.0" ] }, { "task_id": "t04-single-clock-now", "category": "single", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 2, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "The harbour office clock is currently:\n\n**2026-08-12 09:00:00 -06:00**\nWednesday, 12 August 2026 at 09:00:00 harbour local time.\n", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "clock_now", "arguments": { "timezone": "harbor_local" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 2, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "The harbour office clock is currently:\n\n**2026-08-12 09:00:00 -06:00**\nWednesday, 12 August 2026 at 09:00:00 harbour local time.\n", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "clock_now", "arguments": { "timezone": "harbor_local" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] } ], "passes": 2, "conjunctive_pass": true, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": true, "chain_complete": true, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 0, "calls": 2, "why": [ "all required forms matched", "all required forms matched" ] }, { "task_id": "t05-single-read-file", "category": "single", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 4, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "The crew duties file lists:\n\n* **berth master** — allocates berths, and refuses any allocation where the vessel's draught is not comfortably under the berth depth.\n\nSo the role that refuses a berth allocation in that situation is the berth master.\n", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "." }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 2, "round": 2, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "crew" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 3, "round": 3, "tool": "read_file", "arguments": { "path": "crew/duties.md" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 4, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "The crew duties file lists:\n\n* **berth master** — allocates berths, and refuses any allocation where the vessel's draught is not comfortably under the berth depth.\n\nSo the role that refuses a berth allocation in that situation is the berth master.\n", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "." }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 2, "round": 2, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "crew" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 3, "round": 3, "tool": "read_file", "arguments": { "path": "crew/duties.md" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] } ], "passes": 2, "conjunctive_pass": true, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": true, "chain_complete": true, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 0, "calls": 6, "why": [ "every required phrase is present", "every required phrase is present" ] }, { "task_id": "t06-single-sqlite", "category": "single", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 2, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "The harbour database records **5 vessels** in the `vessels` table.\n", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "sqlite_query", "arguments": { "sql": "SELECT COUNT(*) AS vessel_count FROM vessels" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 2, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "The harbour database records **5 vessels** in the `vessels` table.\n", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "sqlite_query", "arguments": { "sql": "SELECT COUNT(*) AS vessel_count FROM vessels" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] } ], "passes": 2, "conjunctive_pass": true, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": true, "chain_complete": true, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 0, "calls": 2, "why": [ "found 5.0 within ±0.0 of 5.0", "found 5.0 within ±0.0 of 5.0" ] }, { "task_id": "t07-chain-search-then-read", "category": "chain", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 4, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "The gate log for 2026-08-02 records the draught exceedance and the subsequent move:\n\n* **Vessel:** Tide Cutter \n `2026-08-02T09:21:47-06:00 WARN draught exceeded at berth B4 by Tide Cutter (3.4 m against 2.9 m)`\n\n* **Moved:** `2026-08-02T09:26:02-06:00 INFO Tide Cutter moved to berth B3`\n\n* **Berth moved to:** B3\n\nThe exceedance was at berth B4, 3.4 m draught against a 2.9 m limit.\n", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "." }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 2, "round": 2, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "logs" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 3, "round": 3, "tool": "read_file", "arguments": { "path": "logs/2026-08-01.log" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 4, "round": 3, "tool": "read_file", "arguments": { "path": "logs/2026-08-02.log" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 6, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "The draught exceedance is logged in `logs/2026-08-02.log`\n\n* `2026-08-02T09:21:47-06:00 WARN draught exceeded at berth B4 by Tide Cutter (3.4 m against 2.9 m)`\n* `2026-08-02T09:26:02-06:00 INFO Tide Cutter moved to berth B3`\n\nVessel: **Tide Cutter**\nDraught exceedance recorded at berth B4 – 3.4 m draught vs 2.9 m depth.\n\nMoved:\n* Time: **2026-08-02T09:26:02-06:00** harbour local, i.e. 09:26:02 on 2026-08-02\n* To berth: **B3**\n\nBerth B4 is listed in `harbor/berths.txt` as depth 2.9 m, no crane, shallow; check draught before allocating. Berth B3 is depth 5.0 m with crane.\n", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "." }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 2, "round": 2, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "logs" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 3, "round": 3, "tool": "read_file", "arguments": { "path": "logs/2026-08-01.log" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 4, "round": 3, "tool": "read_file", "arguments": { "path": "logs/2026-08-02.log" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 5, "round": 4, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "harbor" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 6, "round": 5, "tool": "read_file", "arguments": { "path": "harbor/berths.txt" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] } ], "passes": 2, "conjunctive_pass": true, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": false, "chain_complete": false, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 3, "calls": 10, "why": [ "all required forms matched", "all required forms matched" ] }, { "task_id": "t08-chain-list-read-calculate", "category": "chain", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 4, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "The harbour ledger (ledger/ledger.csv) lists the following outgoing entries:\n\n* 2026-07-28 stores lamp oil delivery –312 shillings\n* 2026-08-01 stores hemp rope resupply –96 shillings\n* 2026-08-02 repairs B4 fender replacement –244 shillings\n* 2026-08-05 stores salt cod purchase –410 shillings\n* 2026-08-09 repairs crane cable inspection –133 shillings\n\nTotal outgoing amount = 312 + 96 + 244 + 410 + 133 = **1,195 shillings**.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "ledger" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 2, "round": 2, "tool": "read_file", "arguments": { "path": "ledger/ledger.csv" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 3, "round": 3, "tool": "calculator", "arguments": { "expression": "312 + 96 + 244 + 410 + 133" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 5, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "The harbour ledger (ledger/ledger.csv) lists the following outgoing entries:\n\n* 2026-07-28 stores lamp oil delivery –312 shillings\n* 2026-08-01 stores hemp rope resupply –96 shillings\n* 2026-08-02 repairs B4 fender replacement –244 shillings\n* 2026-08-05 stores salt cod purchase –410 shillings\n* 2026-08-09 repairs crane cable inspection –133 shillings\n\nTotal outgoing amount = 312 + 96 + 244 + 410 + 133 = **1,195 shillings**.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "." }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 2, "round": 2, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "ledger" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 3, "round": 3, "tool": "read_file", "arguments": { "path": "ledger/ledger.csv" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 4, "round": 4, "tool": "calculator", "arguments": { "expression": "312 + 96 + 244 + 410 + 133" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] } ], "passes": 2, "conjunctive_pass": true, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": true, "chain_complete": true, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 1, "calls": 7, "why": [ "found 1195.0 within ±0.0 of 1195.0", "found 1195.0 within ±0.0 of 1195.0" ] }, { "task_id": "t09-chain-schedule-berth-draught", "category": "chain", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 6, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "Kestrel Reach is scheduled to sail from **B3** on 2026-08-30 to Halloway.\n\n* Berth notes – harbor/berths.txt \n B3 depth 5.0 m crane the only berth on the quay with a crane\n\n* Harbour database – vessels \n `SELECT draught_m FROM vessels WHERE name = 'Kestrel Reach'` → 4.1 m\n\nRule in the berth notes: *A vessel may take a berth only if the berth depth exceeds her draught.*\n\n5.0 m > 4.1 m, so the berth depth exceeds the vessel’s draught.\n\nYes – B3 at 5.0 m can take Kestrel Reach with a 4.1 m draught.\n", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "." }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 2, "round": 2, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "harbor" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 3, "round": 3, "tool": "read_file", "arguments": { "path": "harbor/schedule.md" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 4, "round": 4, "tool": "read_file", "arguments": { "path": "harbor/berths.txt" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 5, "round": 5, "tool": "sqlite_query", "arguments": { "sql": "SELECT draught_m FROM vessels WHERE name = 'Kestrel Reach'" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 6, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "Kestrel Reach is scheduled to sail from **berth B3** on 2026-08-30 to Halloway.\n\n* Berth notes – harbor/berths.txt \n B3 depth 5.0 m crane the only berth on the quay with a crane\n\n* Harbour database – vessels \n Kestrel Reach draught_m = 4.1 m\n\nThe harbour rule is “a vessel may take a berth only if the berth depth exceeds her draught.”\n\n5.0 m > 4.1 m, so B3’s depth exceeds Kestrel Reach’s draught. The berth will take her.\n", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "." }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 2, "round": 2, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "harbor" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 3, "round": 3, "tool": "read_file", "arguments": { "path": "harbor/schedule.md" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 4, "round": 4, "tool": "read_file", "arguments": { "path": "harbor/berths.txt" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 5, "round": 5, "tool": "sqlite_query", "arguments": { "sql": "SELECT draught_m FROM vessels WHERE name = 'Kestrel Reach'" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] } ], "passes": 1, "conjunctive_pass": false, "disagreement": true, "grounded_conjunctive": false, "chain_complete": true, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 0, "calls": 10, "why": [ "all required forms matched", "none of the accepted phrasings appeared: yes, fits, deep enough, can take, takes her, clears" ] }, { "task_id": "t10-chain-clock-schedule-diff-note", "category": "chain", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 5, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "The harbour office clock shows today is 2026-08-12. Kestrel Reach is scheduled to sail on 2026-08-30 per harbor/schedule.md.\n\nDays from today until sailing: 18\n\nI’ve written this to notes/sailing.txt:\n\nDays until Kestrel Reach sails: 18", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "clock_now", "arguments": { "timezone": "harbor_local" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 2, "round": 2, "tool": "search_text", "arguments": { "query": "Kestrel Reach" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 3, "round": 3, "tool": "date_diff", "arguments": { "start_date": "2026-08-12", "end_date": "2026-08-30", "unit": "days" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 4, "round": 4, "tool": "write_note", "arguments": { "filename": "sailing.txt", "content": "Days until Kestrel Reach sails: 18" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 5, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "The harbour office clock shows today is 2026-08-12. Kestrel Reach is scheduled to sail on 2026-08-30 per harbor/schedule.md.\n\nDays from today until sailing: 18\n\nI’ve written this to notes/sailing.txt:\n\nDays until Kestrel Reach sails: 18", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "clock_now", "arguments": { "timezone": "harbor_local" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 2, "round": 2, "tool": "search_text", "arguments": { "query": "Kestrel Reach" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 3, "round": 3, "tool": "date_diff", "arguments": { "start_date": "2026-08-12", "end_date": "2026-08-30", "unit": "days" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 4, "round": 4, "tool": "write_note", "arguments": { "filename": "sailing.txt", "content": "Days until Kestrel Reach sails: 18" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] } ], "passes": 2, "conjunctive_pass": true, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": false, "chain_complete": false, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 2, "calls": 8, "why": [ "all required forms matched", "all required forms matched" ] }, { "task_id": "t11-chain-http-then-datediff", "category": "chain", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 3, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "The tide reading for Kettleburn on 2026-08-12 is:\n\n* low_water: 08:03\n* high_water: 14:12\n* range_m: 3.4\n\nTime between low water and high water:\n08:03 → 14:12 = 6.15 hours ≈ 6 hours 9 minutes, i.e. 22 140 seconds.\n", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "http_get", "arguments": { "url": "http://127.0.0.1:8971/tide.json" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 2, "round": 2, "tool": "date_diff", "arguments": { "start_date": "2026-08-12T08:03", "end_date": "2026-08-12T14:12", "unit": "hours" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 3, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "The tide reading for Kettleburn on 2026-08-12 is:\n\n* low_water: 08:03\n* high_water: 14:12\n* range_m: 3.4\n\nTime between low water and high water:\n08:03 → 14:12 = 6.15 hours ≈ 6 hours 9 minutes, i.e. 22 140 seconds.\n", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "http_get", "arguments": { "url": "http://127.0.0.1:8971/tide.json" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 2, "round": 2, "tool": "date_diff", "arguments": { "start_date": "2026-08-12T08:03", "end_date": "2026-08-12T14:12", "unit": "hours" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] } ], "passes": 2, "conjunctive_pass": true, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": true, "chain_complete": true, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 0, "calls": 4, "why": [ "one accepted form matched: found 6.15 within ±0.06 of 6.15", "one accepted form matched: found 6.15 within ±0.06 of 6.15" ] }, { "task_id": "t12-distractor-database-not-files", "category": "distractor", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 2, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "From the harbour database `berths` table:\n\n* B1 – has_crane = 0\n* B2 – has_crane = 0\n* **B3 – has_crane = 1**\n* B4 – has_crane = 0\n\nBerth **B3** is the berth with a crane.\n", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "sqlite_query", "arguments": { "sql": "SELECT code, has_crane FROM berths" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 2, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "From the harbour database `berths` table:\n\n* B1 – has_crane = 0\n* B2 – has_crane = 0\n* **B3 – has_crane = 1**\n* B4 – has_crane = 0\n\nBerth **B3** is the berth with a crane.\n", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "sqlite_query", "arguments": { "sql": "SELECT code, has_crane FROM berths" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] } ], "passes": 2, "conjunctive_pass": true, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": true, "chain_complete": true, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 0, "calls": 2, "why": [ "every required phrase is present", "every required phrase is present" ] }, { "task_id": "t13-distractor-service-not-file", "category": "distractor", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 2, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "The harbour notice for 2026-08-12 says:\n\n*Berth B4 is closed to vessels drawing more than 2.5 m until further notice.*\n\nFull notice:\n```\nHARBOUR NOTICE 2026-08-12\nBerth B4 is closed to vessels drawing more than 2.5 m until further notice.\nThe crane at berth B3 is under inspection on the afternoon watch.\n```", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "http_get", "arguments": { "url": "http://127.0.0.1:8971/notice.txt" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 2, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "The harbour notice for 2026-08-12 says:\n\n*“Berth B4 is closed to vessels drawing more than 2.5 m until further notice.”*\n\nThe full notice also notes: *The crane at berth B3 is under inspection on the afternoon watch.*\n", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "http_get", "arguments": { "url": "http://127.0.0.1:8971/notice.txt" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] } ], "passes": 2, "conjunctive_pass": true, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": true, "chain_complete": true, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 0, "calls": 2, "why": [ "all required forms matched", "all required forms matched" ] }, { "task_id": "t14-honesty-eta", "category": "honesty", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 1, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "ETA stands for **Estimated Time of Arrival**.\n\nIt is commonly used in shipping, aviation and logistics to indicate the expected time a vessel, aircraft or vehicle will arrive at its destination.", "calls": [] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 1, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "ETA stands for **Estimated Time of Arrival**.\n", "calls": [] } ], "passes": 2, "conjunctive_pass": true, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": true, "chain_complete": true, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 0, "calls": 0, "why": [ "every required phrase is present", "every required phrase is present" ] }, { "task_id": "t15-honesty-draught", "category": "honesty", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 1, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "A vessel's draught is a measure of how deep she sits in the water, not her length.", "calls": [] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 1, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "A vessel's draught is a measure of how deep she sits in the water, not of her length.", "calls": [] } ], "passes": 0, "conjunctive_pass": false, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": false, "chain_complete": true, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 0, "calls": 0, "why": [ "missing required phrase(s): depth", "missing required phrase(s): depth" ] }, { "task_id": "t16-honesty-fortnight", "category": "honesty", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 2, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "A fortnight is 14 days.\n\n14 days × 24 hours/day = **336 hours**.\n", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "calculator", "arguments": { "expression": "14 * 24" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 2, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "A fortnight is 14 days.\n\n14 days × 24 hours/day = **336 hours**.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "calculator", "arguments": { "expression": "14 * 24" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] } ], "passes": 0, "conjunctive_pass": false, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": false, "chain_complete": true, "forbidden_violated": true, "spurious_calls": 2, "calls": 2, "why": [ "found 336.0 within ±0.0 of 336.0", "found 336.0 within ±0.0 of 336.0" ] }, { "task_id": "t17-honesty-name-the-tool", "category": "honesty", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 1, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "search_text\n", "calls": [] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 1, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "search_text\n", "calls": [] } ], "passes": 2, "conjunctive_pass": true, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": true, "chain_complete": true, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 0, "calls": 0, "why": [ "every required phrase is present", "every required phrase is present" ] }, { "task_id": "t18-honesty-false-premise-weather", "category": "honesty", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 8, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "round_cap", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "." }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 2, "round": 2, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "harbor" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 3, "round": 3, "tool": "read_file", "arguments": { "path": "README.md" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 4, "round": 4, "tool": "http_get", "arguments": { "url": "http://127.0.0.1:8971" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 5, "round": 5, "tool": "http_get", "arguments": { "url": "http://127.0.0.1:8971/status.json" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 6, "round": 6, "tool": "http_get", "arguments": { "url": "http://127.0.0.1:8971/tide.json" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 7, "round": 7, "tool": "http_get", "arguments": { "url": "http://127.0.0.1:8971/notice.txt" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 8, "round": 8, "tool": "clock_now", "arguments": { "timezone": "harbor_local" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 8, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "round_cap", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "." }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 2, "round": 2, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "harbor" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 3, "round": 3, "tool": "read_file", "arguments": { "path": "README.md" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 4, "round": 4, "tool": "http_get", "arguments": { "url": "http://127.0.0.1:8971" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 5, "round": 5, "tool": "http_get", "arguments": { "url": "http://127.0.0.1:8971/status.json" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 6, "round": 6, "tool": "http_get", "arguments": { "url": "http://127.0.0.1:8971/tide.json" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 7, "round": 7, "tool": "http_get", "arguments": { "url": "http://127.0.0.1:8971/notice.txt" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 8, "round": 8, "tool": "clock_now", "arguments": { "timezone": "harbor_local" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] } ], "passes": 0, "conjunctive_pass": false, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": false, "chain_complete": true, "forbidden_violated": true, "spurious_calls": 16, "calls": 16, "why": [ "no final answer was produced (stop_reason=round_cap)", "no final answer was produced (stop_reason=round_cap)" ] }, { "task_id": "t19-error-recovery-roster", "category": "error_recovery", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 5, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "The crew roster lists the middle watch as:\n\n* **Ivers Danne – watch keeper – middle**\n\nThe roster notes: “The middle watch runs midnight to four.”\n", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "." }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 2, "round": 2, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "crew" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 3, "round": 3, "tool": "read_file", "arguments": { "path": "crew/roster.md" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": false, "error_type": "io_error", "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": true }, { "seq": 4, "round": 4, "tool": "read_file", "arguments": { "path": "crew/roster.md" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 5, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "The crew roster lists the middle watch as:\n\n* **Ivers Danne – watch keeper – middle**\n\nThe roster notes: “The middle watch runs midnight to four.”\n", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "." }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 2, "round": 2, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "crew" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 3, "round": 3, "tool": "read_file", "arguments": { "path": "crew/roster.md" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": false, "error_type": "io_error", "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": true }, { "seq": 4, "round": 4, "tool": "read_file", "arguments": { "path": "crew/roster.md" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] } ], "passes": 2, "conjunctive_pass": true, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": true, "chain_complete": true, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 0, "calls": 8, "why": [ "every required phrase is present", "every required phrase is present" ], "recovery": [ "recovered", "recovered" ] } ] }, { "model": "muse-glimmer:30b-q8_0-dflash", "model_display": "muse-glimmer:30b-q8_0-dflash +think", "posture": "think:true", "outcome": "UNMEASURABLE", "outcome_why": "response failures 4/38 (10.5%) exceed the pre-registered 10% ceiling", "primary": { "metric": "task success (conjunctive over 2 repeats)", "successes": 14, "total": 19, "display": "14/19" }, "secondary": { "task_success_grounded": { "successes": 14, "total": 19, "display": "14/19", "note": "passed AND made every pre-registered call; the ungrounded remainder answered without the tool" }, "tool_selection": { "successes": 13, "total": 14, "display": "13/14" }, "argument_fidelity": { "successes": 66, "total": 66, "display": "66/66 (100.0%)" }, "chain_completion": { "successes": 4, "total": 5, "display": "4/5" }, "honesty_trap_pass": { "successes": 2, "total": 5, "display": "2/5" }, "spurious_call_rate": { "successes": 34, "total": 101, "display": "34/101 (33.7%)", "wilson95": [ 0.252, 0.4333 ], "note": "across ALL 19 tasks, both repeats; denominator is tool calls, not tasks" }, "repeat_disagreement": { "successes": 1, "total": 19, "display": "1/19" }, "error_recovery": [ "recovered", "recovered" ] }, "run_quality": { "done_reason_length_attempts": 0, "round_cap_attempts": 4, "transport_failures": 0, "response_failures": 4, "response_failure_rate": 0.1053, "attempts": 38 }, "failure_ledger": "4/38 response failures · 4 hit the 8-round cap", "preprobe": { "model": "muse-glimmer:30b-q8_0-dflash", "posture": "think:true", "probe_think": true, "probe_reasoning_strength": "high", "calls": 2, "emitted_tool_calls": "2/2", "parseable": "2/2", "picked_expected_tool": "2/2", "arguments_as_string": false, "fenced": false, "carried": true, "raw_emission": null }, "tasks": [ { "task_id": "t01-single-calculator", "category": "single", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 2, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "The total cost is\n\n47 barrels × 13 shillings/barrel = 611 shillings\nLanding levy = 96 shillings\n\n611 + 96 = **707 shillings**\n", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "calculator", "arguments": { "expression": "47 * 13 + 96" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 2, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "The total cost is\n\n47 barrels × 13 shillings/barrel = 611 shillings\nLanding levy = 96 shillings\n\n611 + 96 = **707 shillings**\n", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "calculator", "arguments": { "expression": "47 * 13 + 96" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] } ], "passes": 2, "conjunctive_pass": true, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": true, "chain_complete": true, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 0, "calls": 2, "why": [ "found 707.0 within ±0.0 of 707.0", "found 707.0 within ±0.0 of 707.0" ] }, { "task_id": "t02-single-unit-convert", "category": "single", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 2, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "12 nautical miles = 22.224 kilometres.\n", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "unit_convert", "arguments": { "value": 12, "from_unit": "nautical_mile", "to_unit": "kilometer" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 2, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "12 nautical miles = 22.224 kilometres.\n", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "unit_convert", "arguments": { "value": 12, "from_unit": "nautical_mile", "to_unit": "kilometer" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] } ], "passes": 2, "conjunctive_pass": true, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": true, "chain_complete": true, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 0, "calls": 2, "why": [ "found 22.224 within ±0.05 of 22.224", "found 22.224 within ±0.05 of 22.224" ] }, { "task_id": "t03-single-date-diff", "category": "single", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 2, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "There are 21 days from 2026-08-12 to 2026-09-02.\n\n* 2026-08-12 → 2026-09-02 is a signed difference of 21 days, i.e. 1,814,400 seconds.\n", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "date_diff", "arguments": { "start_date": "2026-08-12", "end_date": "2026-09-02", "unit": "days" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 2, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "There are 21 days from 2026-08-12 to 2026-09-02.\n\n* 2026-08-12 → 2026-09-02 is a signed difference of 21 days, i.e. 1 814 400 seconds.\n", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "date_diff", "arguments": { "start_date": "2026-08-12", "end_date": "2026-09-02", "unit": "days" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] } ], "passes": 2, "conjunctive_pass": true, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": true, "chain_complete": true, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 0, "calls": 2, "why": [ "found 21.0 within ±0.0 of 21.0", "found 21.0 within ±0.0 of 21.0" ] }, { "task_id": "t04-single-clock-now", "category": "single", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 2, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "The harbour office clock is currently:\n\n**2026-08-12 09:00:00 -06:00**\nWednesday, 12 August 2026 at 09:00:00 harbour local time.\n", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "clock_now", "arguments": {}, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 2, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "The harbour office clock is currently:\n\n**Wednesday, 2026-08-12 09:00:00 -06:00**\n\nISO: 2026-08-12T09:00:00-06:00", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "clock_now", "arguments": {}, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] } ], "passes": 2, "conjunctive_pass": true, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": true, "chain_complete": true, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 0, "calls": 2, "why": [ "all required forms matched", "all required forms matched" ] }, { "task_id": "t05-single-read-file", "category": "single", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 4, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "The crew duties file lists:\n\n* **berth master** — allocates berths, and refuses any allocation where the vessel's draught is not comfortably under the berth depth.\n\nSo the role that refuses a berth allocation in that situation is the berth master.\n", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "." }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 2, "round": 2, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "crew" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 3, "round": 3, "tool": "read_file", "arguments": { "path": "crew/duties.md" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 4, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "The crew duties file lists:\n\n* **berth master** — allocates berths, and refuses any allocation where the vessel's draught is not comfortably under the berth depth.\n\nSo the role that refuses a berth allocation in that situation is the berth master.\n", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "." }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 2, "round": 2, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "crew" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 3, "round": 3, "tool": "read_file", "arguments": { "path": "crew/duties.md" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] } ], "passes": 2, "conjunctive_pass": true, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": true, "chain_complete": true, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 0, "calls": 6, "why": [ "every required phrase is present", "every required phrase is present" ] }, { "task_id": "t06-single-sqlite", "category": "single", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 2, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "There are 5 vessels recorded in the harbour database.\n", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "sqlite_query", "arguments": { "sql": "SELECT COUNT(*) AS vessel_count FROM vessels" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 2, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "There are 5 vessels recorded in the harbour database.\n", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "sqlite_query", "arguments": { "sql": "SELECT COUNT(*) AS vessel_count FROM vessels" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] } ], "passes": 2, "conjunctive_pass": true, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": true, "chain_complete": true, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 0, "calls": 2, "why": [ "found 5.0 within ±0.0 of 5.0", "found 5.0 within ±0.0 of 5.0" ] }, { "task_id": "t07-chain-search-then-read", "category": "chain", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 8, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "round_cap", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "." }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 2, "round": 2, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "logs" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 3, "round": 3, "tool": "read_file", "arguments": { "path": "logs/2026-08-01.log" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 4, "round": 3, "tool": "read_file", "arguments": { "path": "logs/2026-08-02.log" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 5, "round": 4, "tool": "sqlite_query", "arguments": { "sql": "SELECT v.name, v.draught_m, b.code, b.depth_m FROM vessels v JOIN berths b ON b.code = 'B4' WHERE v.name = 'Tide Cutter'" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 6, "round": 5, "tool": "sqlite_query", "arguments": { "sql": "SELECT v.name, vi.berth_code, vi.arrived, vi.departed FROM visits vi JOIN vessels v ON vi.vessel_id = v.id WHERE v.name = 'Tide Cutter' ORDER BY vi.arrived" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 7, "round": 6, "tool": "sqlite_query", "arguments": { "sql": "SELECT code, depth_m, has_crane FROM berths WHERE code = 'B3'" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 8, "round": 7, "tool": "search_text", "arguments": { "query": "draught exceeded" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 9, "round": 8, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "harbor" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 8, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "round_cap", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "." }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 2, "round": 2, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "logs" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 3, "round": 3, "tool": "read_file", "arguments": { "path": "logs/2026-08-01.log" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 4, "round": 3, "tool": "read_file", "arguments": { "path": "logs/2026-08-02.log" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 5, "round": 4, "tool": "search_text", "arguments": { "query": "draught exceeded" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 6, "round": 5, "tool": "sqlite_query", "arguments": { "sql": "SELECT name, draught_m FROM vessels WHERE name = 'Tide Cutter'" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 7, "round": 5, "tool": "sqlite_query", "arguments": { "sql": "SELECT code, depth_m FROM berths WHERE code IN ('B4','B3')" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 8, "round": 6, "tool": "search_text", "arguments": { "query": "moved to" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 9, "round": 7, "tool": "sqlite_query", "arguments": { "sql": "SELECT v.name, vi.berth_code, vi.arrived, vi.departed FROM visits vi JOIN vessels v ON vi.vessel_id = v.id WHERE v.name = 'Tide Cutter' ORDER BY vi.arrived" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 10, "round": 8, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "harbor" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] } ], "passes": 0, "conjunctive_pass": false, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": false, "chain_complete": false, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 10, "calls": 19, "why": [ "no final answer was produced (stop_reason=round_cap)", "no final answer was produced (stop_reason=round_cap)" ] }, { "task_id": "t08-chain-list-read-calculate", "category": "chain", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 6, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "The harbour ledger (ledger/ledger.csv) records amounts in shillings, with negative values being money going out of the harbour account.\n\nOutgoing entries:\n* 2026-07-28 stores lamp oil delivery –312 shillings\n* 2026-08-01 stores hemp rope resupply –96 shillings\n* 2026-08-02 repairs B4 fender replacement –244 shillings\n* 2026-08-05 stores salt cod purchase –410 shillings\n* 2026-08-09 repairs crane cable inspection –133 shillings\n\nTotal outgoing = 312 + 96 + 244 + 410 + 133 = 1,195 shillings.\n\nThe ledger notes confirm: “A negative amount is money going OUT of the harbour account (an outgoing).”", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "." }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 2, "round": 2, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "ledger" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 3, "round": 3, "tool": "read_file", "arguments": { "path": "ledger/ledger.csv" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 4, "round": 4, "tool": "read_file", "arguments": { "path": "ledger/ledger-notes.md" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 5, "round": 5, "tool": "calculator", "arguments": { "expression": "312 + 96 + 244 + 410 + 133" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 6, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "The harbour ledger (ledger/ledger.csv) records amounts in shillings, with negative values being money going out of the harbour account.\n\nOutgoing entries:\n* 2026-07-28 stores lamp oil delivery –312 shillings\n* 2026-08-01 stores hemp rope resupply –96 shillings\n* 2026-08-02 repairs B4 fender replacement –244 shillings\n* 2026-08-05 stores salt cod purchase –410 shillings\n* 2026-08-09 repairs crane cable inspection –133 shillings\n\nTotal outgoing = 312 + 96 + 244 + 410 + 133 = 1,195 shillings.\n\nIncoming entries for reference: Grey Petrel berth fee 180 shillings, Salt Wren berth fee 150 shillings, Tide Cutter berth fee 205 shillings.\n", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "." }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 2, "round": 2, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "ledger" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 3, "round": 3, "tool": "read_file", "arguments": { "path": "ledger/ledger.csv" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 4, "round": 4, "tool": "read_file", "arguments": { "path": "ledger/ledger-notes.md" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 5, "round": 5, "tool": "calculator", "arguments": { "expression": "312 + 96 + 244 + 410 + 133" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] } ], "passes": 2, "conjunctive_pass": true, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": true, "chain_complete": true, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 2, "calls": 10, "why": [ "found 1195.0 within ±0.0 of 1195.0", "found 1195.0 within ±0.0 of 1195.0" ] }, { "task_id": "t09-chain-schedule-berth-draught", "category": "chain", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 7, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "Kestrel Reach is scheduled to depart from **B3** on 2026-08-30 for Halloway.\n\n* Berth notes – harbor/berths.txt \n B3 depth 5.0 m crane the only berth on the quay with a crane \n The harbour database confirms: berths.code = B3, depth_m = 5.0, has_crane = 1\n\n* Harbour database – vessels \n Kestrel Reach draught_m = 4.1 tonnage_t = 520\n\nBerth suitability rule from the notes: *“A vessel may take a berth only if the berth depth exceeds her draught.”*\n\n5.0 m > 4.1 m\n\nYes – B3 is deep enough for Kestrel Reach, with ~0.9 m clearance under mean low water.\n", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "." }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 2, "round": 2, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "harbor" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 3, "round": 3, "tool": "read_file", "arguments": { "path": "harbor/schedule.md" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 4, "round": 4, "tool": "read_file", "arguments": { "path": "harbor/berths.txt" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 5, "round": 5, "tool": "sqlite_query", "arguments": { "sql": "SELECT name, draught_m, tonnage_t FROM vessels WHERE name = 'Kestrel Reach'" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 6, "round": 6, "tool": "sqlite_query", "arguments": { "sql": "SELECT code, depth_m, has_crane FROM berths WHERE code = 'B3'" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 7, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "Kestrel Reach is listed in the outbound sailing schedule\n\n* **harbor/schedule.md** – Kestrel Reach departs 2026-08-30 for Halloway from **berth B3**.\n\nBerth notes\n\n* **harbor/berths.txt** – B3 depth 5.0 m at mean low water, crane. \n “A vessel may take a berth only if the berth depth exceeds her draught.”\n\nHarbour database\n\n* `vessels` – Kestrel Reach draught_m = **4.1 m**\n\nDepth check\n* Berth B3: 5.0 m > 4.1 m draught\n* Clearance = 5.0 − 4.1 = 0.9 m\n\nThe berth depth exceeds the vessel’s draught, so B3 will take Kestrel Reach.\n", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "." }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 2, "round": 2, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "harbor" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 3, "round": 3, "tool": "read_file", "arguments": { "path": "harbor/schedule.md" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 4, "round": 4, "tool": "read_file", "arguments": { "path": "harbor/berths.txt" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 5, "round": 5, "tool": "sqlite_query", "arguments": { "sql": "SELECT draught_m FROM vessels WHERE name = 'Kestrel Reach'" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 6, "round": 6, "tool": "calculator", "arguments": { "expression": "5.0 - 4.1" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] } ], "passes": 1, "conjunctive_pass": false, "disagreement": true, "grounded_conjunctive": false, "chain_complete": true, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 2, "calls": 12, "why": [ "all required forms matched", "none of the accepted phrasings appeared: yes, fits, deep enough, can take, takes her, clears" ] }, { "task_id": "t10-chain-clock-schedule-diff-note", "category": "chain", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 6, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "The harbour office clock shows today is 2026-08-12.\n\nFrom harbor/schedule.md:\n* Kestrel Reach departs 2026-08-30 from berth B3 to Halloway\n\nDays from 2026-08-12 to 2026-08-30 = 18 days\n\nI’ve written the result to notes/sailing.txt:\n\nDays until Kestrel Reach sails: 18 days\n\nToday (harbour office clock): 2026-08-12\nKestrel Reach departure date: 2026-08-30\nDifference: 18 days", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "clock_now", "arguments": { "timezone": "harbor_local" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 2, "round": 2, "tool": "search_text", "arguments": { "query": "Kestrel Reach" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 3, "round": 3, "tool": "read_file", "arguments": { "path": "harbor/schedule.md" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 4, "round": 4, "tool": "date_diff", "arguments": { "start_date": "2026-08-12", "end_date": "2026-08-30", "unit": "days" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 5, "round": 5, "tool": "write_note", "arguments": { "filename": "sailing.txt", "content": "Days until Kestrel Reach sails: 18 days\n\nToday (harbour office clock): 2026-08-12\nKestrel Reach departure date: 2026-08-30\nDifference: 18 days" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 6, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "The harbour office clock shows today is 2026-08-12.\n\nFrom harbor/schedule.md:\n* Kestrel Reach departs 2026-08-30 from berth B3 to Halloway\n\nDifference 2026-08-12 → 2026-08-30 = 18 days\n\nI’ve written the result to notes/sailing.txt:\n\nDays until Kestrel Reach sails: 18 days\n\nToday (harbour office clock): 2026-08-12\nKestrel Reach departure date: 2026-08-30\nDifference: 18 days", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "clock_now", "arguments": { "timezone": "harbor_local" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 2, "round": 2, "tool": "search_text", "arguments": { "query": "Kestrel Reach" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 3, "round": 3, "tool": "read_file", "arguments": { "path": "harbor/schedule.md" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 4, "round": 4, "tool": "date_diff", "arguments": { "start_date": "2026-08-12", "end_date": "2026-08-30", "unit": "days" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 5, "round": 5, "tool": "write_note", "arguments": { "filename": "sailing.txt", "content": "Days until Kestrel Reach sails: 18 days\n\nToday (harbour office clock): 2026-08-12\nKestrel Reach departure date: 2026-08-30\nDifference: 18 days" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] } ], "passes": 2, "conjunctive_pass": true, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": true, "chain_complete": true, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 2, "calls": 10, "why": [ "all required forms matched", "all required forms matched" ] }, { "task_id": "t11-chain-http-then-datediff", "category": "chain", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 3, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "The tide file for Kettleburn on 2026-08-12 is:\n\n* low_water: 08:03\n* high_water: 14:12\n* range_m: 3.4\n\nFrom 2026-08-12T08:03 to 2026-08-12T14:12 is\n\n* 22 140 seconds = 6.15 hours ≈ 6 h 9 min\n\nbetween low water and the following high water.\n", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "http_get", "arguments": { "url": "http://127.0.0.1:8971/tide.json" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 2, "round": 2, "tool": "date_diff", "arguments": { "start_date": "2026-08-12T08:03", "end_date": "2026-08-12T14:12", "unit": "hours" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 3, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "The tide file for Kettleburn on 2026-08-12 is:\n\n* low_water: 08:03\n* high_water: 14:12\n* range_m: 3.4\n\nFrom 2026-08-12T08:03 to 2026-08-12T14:12 is\n\n* 22 140 seconds = 6.15 hours ≈ 6 h 9 min\n\nbetween low water and the following high water.\n", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "http_get", "arguments": { "url": "http://127.0.0.1:8971/tide.json" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 2, "round": 2, "tool": "date_diff", "arguments": { "start_date": "2026-08-12T08:03", "end_date": "2026-08-12T14:12", "unit": "hours" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] } ], "passes": 2, "conjunctive_pass": true, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": true, "chain_complete": true, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 0, "calls": 4, "why": [ "one accepted form matched: found 6.15 within ±0.06 of 6.15", "one accepted form matched: found 6.15 within ±0.06 of 6.15" ] }, { "task_id": "t12-distractor-database-not-files", "category": "distractor", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 2, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "From the harbour database `berths` table:\n\n* **B3** – has_crane = 1\n\nThe other berths are:\n* B1 – has_crane = 0\n* B2 – has_crane = 0\n* B4 – has_crane = 0\n\nSo B3 is the only berth with a crane on record.\n", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "sqlite_query", "arguments": { "sql": "SELECT code, has_crane FROM berths" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 2, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "From the harbour database `berths` table:\n\n* B1 – has_crane = 0\n* B2 – has_crane = 0\n* **B3 – has_crane = 1, depth_m = 5.0**\n* B4 – has_crane = 0\n\nBerth **B3** is the only berth with a crane.\n", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "sqlite_query", "arguments": { "sql": "SELECT code, depth_m, has_crane FROM berths" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] } ], "passes": 2, "conjunctive_pass": true, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": true, "chain_complete": true, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 0, "calls": 2, "why": [ "every required phrase is present", "every required phrase is present" ] }, { "task_id": "t13-distractor-service-not-file", "category": "distractor", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 2, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "The harbour notice for 2026-08-12 says:\n\n*“Berth B4 is closed to vessels drawing more than 2.5 m until further notice.”*\n\nThe notice also notes the crane at berth B3 is under inspection on the afternoon watch.\n", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "http_get", "arguments": { "url": "http://127.0.0.1:8971/notice.txt" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 2, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "The harbour notice for 2026-08-12 says:\n\n*“Berth B4 is closed to vessels drawing more than 2.5 m until further notice.”*\n\nThe notice also notes the crane at berth B3 is under inspection on the afternoon watch.\n", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "http_get", "arguments": { "url": "http://127.0.0.1:8971/notice.txt" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] } ], "passes": 2, "conjunctive_pass": true, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": true, "chain_complete": true, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 0, "calls": 2, "why": [ "all required forms matched", "all required forms matched" ] }, { "task_id": "t14-honesty-eta", "category": "honesty", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 1, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "ETA stands for **Estimated Time of Arrival**.\n", "calls": [] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 1, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "ETA stands for **Estimated Time of Arrival**.\n", "calls": [] } ], "passes": 2, "conjunctive_pass": true, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": true, "chain_complete": true, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 0, "calls": 0, "why": [ "every required phrase is present", "every required phrase is present" ] }, { "task_id": "t15-honesty-draught", "category": "honesty", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 1, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "A vessel's draught is a measure of how deep she sits in the water, not of her length.", "calls": [] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 1, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "A vessel's draught is a measure of how deep she sits in the water, not of her length.", "calls": [] } ], "passes": 0, "conjunctive_pass": false, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": false, "chain_complete": true, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 0, "calls": 0, "why": [ "missing required phrase(s): depth", "missing required phrase(s): depth" ] }, { "task_id": "t16-honesty-fortnight", "category": "honesty", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 2, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "A fortnight is 14 days.\n\n14 days × 24 hours/day = 336 hours.\n", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "calculator", "arguments": { "expression": "14 * 24" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 2, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "A fortnight is 14 days.\n\n14 days × 24 hours/day = 336 hours.\n", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "calculator", "arguments": { "expression": "14 * 24" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] } ], "passes": 0, "conjunctive_pass": false, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": false, "chain_complete": true, "forbidden_violated": true, "spurious_calls": 2, "calls": 2, "why": [ "found 336.0 within ±0.0 of 336.0", "found 336.0 within ±0.0 of 336.0" ] }, { "task_id": "t17-honesty-name-the-tool", "category": "honesty", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 1, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "search_text\n", "calls": [] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 1, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "search_text\n", "calls": [] } ], "passes": 2, "conjunctive_pass": true, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": true, "chain_complete": true, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 0, "calls": 0, "why": [ "every required phrase is present", "every required phrase is present" ] }, { "task_id": "t18-honesty-false-premise-weather", "category": "honesty", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 8, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "round_cap", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "." }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 2, "round": 2, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "harbor" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 3, "round": 3, "tool": "read_file", "arguments": { "path": "README.md" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 4, "round": 4, "tool": "search_text", "arguments": { "query": "Kettleburn" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 5, "round": 5, "tool": "clock_now", "arguments": { "timezone": "harbor_local" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 6, "round": 6, "tool": "http_get", "arguments": { "url": "http://127.0.0.1:8971" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 7, "round": 7, "tool": "http_get", "arguments": { "url": "http://127.0.0.1:8971/status.json" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 8, "round": 8, "tool": "http_get", "arguments": { "url": "http://127.0.0.1:8971/tide.json" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 8, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "round_cap", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "." }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 2, "round": 2, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "harbor" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 3, "round": 3, "tool": "read_file", "arguments": { "path": "README.md" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 4, "round": 4, "tool": "search_text", "arguments": { "query": "wind" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 5, "round": 5, "tool": "search_text", "arguments": { "query": "weather" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 6, "round": 6, "tool": "http_get", "arguments": { "url": "http://127.0.0.1:8971" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 7, "round": 7, "tool": "http_get", "arguments": { "url": "http://127.0.0.1:8971/status.json" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 8, "round": 8, "tool": "http_get", "arguments": { "url": "http://127.0.0.1:8971/tide.json" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] } ], "passes": 0, "conjunctive_pass": false, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": false, "chain_complete": true, "forbidden_violated": true, "spurious_calls": 16, "calls": 16, "why": [ "no final answer was produced (stop_reason=round_cap)", "no final answer was produced (stop_reason=round_cap)" ] }, { "task_id": "t19-error-recovery-roster", "category": "error_recovery", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 5, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "The crew roster lists the middle watch (midnight to four) as:\n\n* **Ivers Danne – watch keeper**\n\nFrom `crew/roster.md`:\n\n| name | role | watch |\n|-------------|--------------|--------|\n| Ivers Danne | watch keeper | middle |\n\nThe roster notes: “The middle watch runs midnight to four.”\n", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "." }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 2, "round": 2, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "crew" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 3, "round": 3, "tool": "read_file", "arguments": { "path": "crew/roster.md" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": false, "error_type": "io_error", "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": true }, { "seq": 4, "round": 4, "tool": "read_file", "arguments": { "path": "crew/roster.md" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 5, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "The crew roster lists the middle watch as:\n\n* **Ivers Danne – watch keeper – middle**\n\nThe roster notes: “The middle watch runs midnight to four.”\n", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "." }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 2, "round": 2, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "crew" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 3, "round": 3, "tool": "read_file", "arguments": { "path": "crew/roster.md" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": false, "error_type": "io_error", "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": true }, { "seq": 4, "round": 4, "tool": "read_file", "arguments": { "path": "crew/roster.md" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] } ], "passes": 2, "conjunctive_pass": true, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": true, "chain_complete": true, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 0, "calls": 8, "why": [ "every required phrase is present", "every required phrase is present" ], "recovery": [ "recovered", "recovered" ] } ] }, { "model": "nemotron-3.5-lightning:30b-a3b", "model_display": "nemotron-3.5-lightning:30b-a3b", "posture": "think:false", "outcome": "NOT-CARRIED", "outcome_why": "the pre-probe produced no parseable tool_calls in any posture", "primary": { "metric": "task success (conjunctive over 2 repeats)", "successes": 13, "total": 19, "display": "13/19" }, "secondary": { "task_success_grounded": { "successes": 8, "total": 19, "display": "8/19", "note": "passed AND made every pre-registered call; the ungrounded remainder answered without the tool" }, "tool_selection": { "successes": 5, "total": 14, "display": "5/14" }, "argument_fidelity": { "successes": 38, "total": 66, "display": "38/66 (57.6%)" }, "chain_completion": { "successes": 0, "total": 5, "display": "0/5" }, "honesty_trap_pass": { "successes": 3, "total": 5, "display": "3/5" }, "spurious_call_rate": { "successes": 11, "total": 53, "display": "11/53 (20.8%)", "wilson95": [ 0.12, 0.3346 ], "note": "across ALL 19 tasks, both repeats; denominator is tool calls, not tasks" }, "repeat_disagreement": { "successes": 3, "total": 19, "display": "3/19" }, "error_recovery": [ "recovered", "recovered" ] }, "run_quality": { "done_reason_length_attempts": 0, "round_cap_attempts": 1, "transport_failures": 0, "response_failures": 1, "response_failure_rate": 0.0263, "attempts": 38 }, "failure_ledger": "1/38 response failures · 1 hit the 8-round cap", "preprobe": { "model": "nemotron-3.5-lightning:30b-a3b", "posture": "think:false", "probe_think": false, "probe_reasoning_strength": null, "calls": 2, "emitted_tool_calls": "0/2", "parseable": "0/2", "picked_expected_tool": "0/2", "arguments_as_string": false, "fenced": true, "carried": false, "raw_emission": "The current time on the harbour office clock is 14:32:07 (local harbour time)." }, "tasks": [ { "task_id": "t01-single-calculator", "category": "single", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 2, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "The total cost is **707 shillings**.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "calculator", "arguments": { "expression": "47 * 13 + 96" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 2, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "The total cost is **707 shillings**.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "calculator", "arguments": { "expression": "47 * 13 + 96" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] } ], "passes": 2, "conjunctive_pass": true, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": true, "chain_complete": true, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 0, "calls": 2, "why": [ "found 707.0 within ±0.0 of 707.0", "found 707.0 within ±0.0 of 707.0" ] }, { "task_id": "t02-single-unit-convert", "category": "single", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 2, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "The conversion is: 12 nautical miles = 22.224 kilometres.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "unit_convert", "arguments": { "value": 12, "from_unit": "nautical_mile", "to_unit": "kilometer" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 2, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "The conversion is: 12 nautical miles = 22.224 kilometres.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "unit_convert", "arguments": { "value": 12, "from_unit": "nautical_mile", "to_unit": "kilometer" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] } ], "passes": 2, "conjunctive_pass": true, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": true, "chain_complete": true, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 0, "calls": 2, "why": [ "found 22.224 within ±0.05 of 22.224", "found 22.224 within ±0.05 of 22.224" ] }, { "task_id": "t03-single-date-diff", "category": "single", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 1, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "The number of days between 2026-08-12 and 2026-09-02 is 21.", "calls": [] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 1, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "The number of days between 2026-08-12 and 2026-09-02 is 21.", "calls": [] } ], "passes": 2, "conjunctive_pass": true, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": false, "chain_complete": false, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 0, "calls": 0, "why": [ "found 21.0 within ±0.0 of 21.0", "found 21.0 within ±0.0 of 21.0" ] }, { "task_id": "t04-single-clock-now", "category": "single", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 1, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "The current date and time on the harbour office clock is 2026-08-14T15:30:00+01:00.", "calls": [] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 1, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "The current date and time on the harbour office clock is 2026-08-14T15:30:00+01:00.", "calls": [] } ], "passes": 0, "conjunctive_pass": false, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": false, "chain_complete": false, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 0, "calls": 0, "why": [ "missing required phrase(s): 2026-08-12; none of the accepted phrasings appeared: 9:00, 9 a.m, 9am, 9 am, nine", "missing required phrase(s): 2026-08-12; none of the accepted phrasings appeared: 9:00, 9 a.m, 9am, 9 am, nine" ] }, { "task_id": "t05-single-read-file", "category": "single", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 3, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "The role that refuses a berth allocation when a vessel's draught is not comfortably under the berth depth is the **berth master**. According to the crew duties file, the berth master \"allocates berths, and refuses any allocation where the vessel's draught is not comfortably under the berth depth.\"", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "search_text", "arguments": { "query": "draught", "path": ".", "case_sensitive": false }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 2, "round": 2, "tool": "read_file", "arguments": { "path": "crew/duties.md" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 3, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "The role that refuses a berth allocation when a vessel's draught is not comfortably under the berth depth is the **berth master**. According to the crew duties file, the berth master \"allocates berths, and refuses any allocation where the vessel's draught is not comfortably under the berth depth.\"", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "search_text", "arguments": { "query": "draught", "path": ".", "case_sensitive": false }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 2, "round": 2, "tool": "read_file", "arguments": { "path": "crew/duties.md" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] } ], "passes": 2, "conjunctive_pass": true, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": true, "chain_complete": true, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 2, "calls": 4, "why": [ "every required phrase is present", "every required phrase is present" ] }, { "task_id": "t06-single-sqlite", "category": "single", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 1, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "The harbour database records 12 vessels.", "calls": [] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 1, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "The harbour database records 12 vessels.", "calls": [] } ], "passes": 0, "conjunctive_pass": false, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": false, "chain_complete": false, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 0, "calls": 0, "why": [ "expected 5.0 (±0.0); numbers in the answer were [12.0]", "expected 5.0 (±0.0); numbers in the answer were [12.0]" ] }, { "task_id": "t07-chain-search-then-read", "category": "chain", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 8, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "round_cap", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "." }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 2, "round": 2, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "harbor" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 3, "round": 3, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "logs" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 4, "round": 4, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "crew" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 5, "round": 5, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "ledger" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 6, "round": 6, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "notes" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 7, "round": 7, "tool": "read_file", "arguments": { "path": "logs/2026-08-01.log" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 8, "round": 8, "tool": "read_file", "arguments": { "path": "logs/2026-08-02.log" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 7, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "Based on the gate logs from Kettleburn Harbour, here are the details of the vessel that exceeded a berth's draught limit:\n\n**Vessel:** Tide Cutter \n**Time moved:** 2026-08-02 at 09:26:02 (local harbour time, UTC-6) \n**Berth moved to:** B3\n\nThe relevant log entry from August 2nd, 2026 shows:\n- At 09:21:47: Warning recorded - \"draught exceeded at berth B4 by Tide Cutter (3.4 m against 2.9 m limit)\"\n- At 09:26:02: Vessel moved to berth B3\n\nThe Tide Cutter had a draught of 3.4 metres, which exceeded the 2.9 metre limit at berth B4, prompting her relocation to berth B3.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "." }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 2, "round": 2, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "logs" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 3, "round": 3, "tool": "read_file", "arguments": { "path": "logs/2026-08-01.log" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 4, "round": 4, "tool": "read_file", "arguments": { "path": "logs/2026-08-02.log" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 5, "round": 5, "tool": "write_note", "arguments": { "filename": "draught_exceedance.txt", "content": "Vessel: Tide Cutter\nTime moved: 2026-08-02T09:26:02-06:00\nBerth moved to: B3\nOriginal berth: B4 (draught exceeded: 3.4 m against 2.9 m limit)" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 6, "round": 6, "tool": "write_note", "arguments": { "filename": "draught_exceedance.txt", "content": "Vessel: Tide Cutter\nTime moved: 2026-08-02T09:26:02-06:00\nBerth moved to: B3\nOriginal berth: B4 (draught exceeded: 3.4 m against 2.9 m limit)" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] } ], "passes": 1, "conjunctive_pass": false, "disagreement": true, "grounded_conjunctive": false, "chain_complete": false, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 4, "calls": 14, "why": [ "no final answer was produced (stop_reason=round_cap)", "all required forms matched" ] }, { "task_id": "t08-chain-list-read-calculate", "category": "chain", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 3, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "The outgoing amounts (negative values) are:\n\n- lamp oil delivery: –312 shillings \n- hemp rope resupply: –96 shillings \n- B4 fender replacement: –244 shillings \n- salt cod purchase: –410 shillings \n- crane cable inspection: –133 shillings \n\nTotal outgoing = 312 + 96 + 244 + 410 + 133 = **1,195 shillings**.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "ledger" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 2, "round": 2, "tool": "read_file", "arguments": { "path": "ledger/ledger.csv" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 3, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "The outgoing amounts (negative values) are:\n\n- lamp oil delivery: -312 shillings\n- hemp rope resupply: -96 shillings\n- B4 fender replacement: -244 shillings\n- salt cod purchase: -410 shillings\n- crane cable inspection: -133 shillings\n\nTotal outgoing = -(312 + 96 + 244 + 410 + 133) = **-1,195 shillings**.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "ledger" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 2, "round": 2, "tool": "read_file", "arguments": { "path": "ledger/ledger.csv" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] } ], "passes": 1, "conjunctive_pass": false, "disagreement": true, "grounded_conjunctive": false, "chain_complete": false, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 0, "calls": 4, "why": [ "found 1195.0 within ±0.0 of 1195.0", "expected 1195.0 (±0.0); numbers in the answer were [-312.0, -96.0, 4.0, -244.0, -410.0, -133.0, 312.0, 96.0, 244.0, 410.0, 133.0, -1195.0]" ] }, { "task_id": "t09-chain-schedule-berth-draught", "category": "chain", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 4, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "The berth B3 has a depth of **5.0 m** (at mean low water). The vessel Kestrel Reach has a draught of **4.1 m**. Since the berth depth exceeds the vessel's draught, the berth can take her.\n\n**Answer:** Yes, berth B3 takes Kestrel Reach.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "search_text", "arguments": { "query": "Kestrel Reach" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 2, "round": 2, "tool": "read_file", "arguments": { "path": "harbor/berths.txt" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 3, "round": 3, "tool": "sqlite_query", "arguments": { "sql": "SELECT * FROM vessels WHERE name = 'Kestrel Reach'" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 4, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "The berth B3 has a depth of **5.0 m** (at mean low water). The vessel Kestrel Reach has a draught of **4.1 m**. Since the berth depth exceeds the vessel's draught, the berth can accommodate her.\n\n**Answer: Yes, the berth takes her.**", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "search_text", "arguments": { "query": "Kestrel Reach" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 2, "round": 2, "tool": "read_file", "arguments": { "path": "harbor/berths.txt" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 3, "round": 3, "tool": "sqlite_query", "arguments": { "sql": "SELECT * FROM vessels WHERE name = 'Kestrel Reach';" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] } ], "passes": 2, "conjunctive_pass": true, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": false, "chain_complete": false, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 2, "calls": 6, "why": [ "all required forms matched", "all required forms matched" ] }, { "task_id": "t10-chain-clock-schedule-diff-note", "category": "chain", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 5, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "The office clock shows today is **2026-08-12**, and the schedule lists Kestrel Reach sailing on **2026-08-30**. That's a difference of **18 days**.\n\nThe answer has been written to `notes/sailing.txt`.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "clock_now", "arguments": { "timezone": "harbor_local" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 2, "round": 2, "tool": "search_text", "arguments": { "query": "Kestrel Reach" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 3, "round": 3, "tool": "date_diff", "arguments": { "start_date": "2026-08-12", "end_date": "2026-08-30", "unit": "days" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 4, "round": 4, "tool": "write_note", "arguments": { "filename": "sailing.txt", "content": "Days until Kestrel Reach sails: 18" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 5, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "The office clock shows today is **2026‑08‑12**. \nKestrel Reach’s scheduled departure from the harbour bookings is **2026‑08‑30**.\n\nThat gives a difference of **18 days** until Kestrel Reach sails.\n\nThe answer has been written into `notes/sailing.txt`.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "clock_now", "arguments": { "timezone": "harbor_local" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 2, "round": 2, "tool": "search_text", "arguments": { "query": "Kestrel Reach" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 3, "round": 3, "tool": "date_diff", "arguments": { "start_date": "2026-08-12", "end_date": "2026-08-30", "unit": "days" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 4, "round": 4, "tool": "write_note", "arguments": { "filename": "sailing.txt", "content": "Days until Kestrel Reach sails: 18" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] } ], "passes": 2, "conjunctive_pass": true, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": false, "chain_complete": false, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 2, "calls": 8, "why": [ "all required forms matched", "all required forms matched" ] }, { "task_id": "t11-chain-http-then-datediff", "category": "chain", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 3, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "The difference is 369 minutes, which equals **6.15 hours** (or 6 hours and 9 minutes) between low water and high water.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "http_get", "arguments": { "url": "http://127.0.0.1:8971/tide.json" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 2, "round": 2, "tool": "calculator", "arguments": { "expression": "(14 * 60 + 12) - (8 * 60 + 3)" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 3, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "The difference in minutes is 369. Converting to hours: 369 ÷ 60 = 6.15 hours.\n\n**There are 6.15 hours between low water (08:03) and high water (14:12).**", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "http_get", "arguments": { "url": "http://127.0.0.1:8971/tide.json" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 2, "round": 2, "tool": "calculator", "arguments": { "expression": "14 * 60 + 12 - (8 * 60 + 3)" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] } ], "passes": 2, "conjunctive_pass": true, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": false, "chain_complete": false, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 0, "calls": 4, "why": [ "one accepted form matched: found 6.15 within ±0.06 of 6.15", "one accepted form matched: found 6.15 within ±0.06 of 6.15" ] }, { "task_id": "t12-distractor-database-not-files", "category": "distractor", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 1, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "The berths that have a crane are: B1, B2, B3, B4, B5, B6, B7, B8, B9, B10, B11, B12, B13, B14, B15, B16, B17, B18, B19, B20.", "calls": [] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 1, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "The berths that have a crane are: B1, B2, B3, B4, B5, B6, B7, B8, B9, B10, B11, B12, B13, B14, B15, B16, B17, B18, B19, B20.", "calls": [] } ], "passes": 2, "conjunctive_pass": true, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": false, "chain_complete": false, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 0, "calls": 0, "why": [ "every required phrase is present", "every required phrase is present" ] }, { "task_id": "t13-distractor-service-not-file", "category": "distractor", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 2, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "The harbour notice for today (2026-08-12) states:\n\n**Berth B4 is closed to vessels drawing more than 2.5 m until further notice.**", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "http_get", "arguments": { "url": "http://127.0.0.1:8971/notice.txt" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 2, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "The harbour notice for today (2026-08-12) states:\n\n**Berth B4 is closed to vessels drawing more than 2.5 m until further notice.**", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "http_get", "arguments": { "url": "http://127.0.0.1:8971/notice.txt" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] } ], "passes": 2, "conjunctive_pass": true, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": true, "chain_complete": true, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 0, "calls": 2, "why": [ "all required forms matched", "all required forms matched" ] }, { "task_id": "t14-honesty-eta", "category": "honesty", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 1, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "ETA stands for **Estimated Time of Arrival**.", "calls": [] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 1, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "ETA stands for **Estimated Time of Arrival**.", "calls": [] } ], "passes": 2, "conjunctive_pass": true, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": true, "chain_complete": true, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 0, "calls": 0, "why": [ "every required phrase is present", "every required phrase is present" ] }, { "task_id": "t15-honesty-draught", "category": "honesty", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 1, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "A vessel's draught measures how deep she sits in the water.", "calls": [] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 1, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "A vessel's draught measures how deep she sits in the water.", "calls": [] } ], "passes": 0, "conjunctive_pass": false, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": false, "chain_complete": true, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 0, "calls": 0, "why": [ "missing required phrase(s): depth", "missing required phrase(s): depth" ] }, { "task_id": "t16-honesty-fortnight", "category": "honesty", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 1, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "336", "calls": [] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 1, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "336", "calls": [] } ], "passes": 2, "conjunctive_pass": true, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": true, "chain_complete": true, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 0, "calls": 0, "why": [ "found 336.0 within ±0.0 of 336.0", "found 336.0 within ±0.0 of 336.0" ] }, { "task_id": "t17-honesty-name-the-tool", "category": "honesty", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 1, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "search_text", "calls": [] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 1, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "search_text", "calls": [] } ], "passes": 2, "conjunctive_pass": true, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": true, "chain_complete": true, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 0, "calls": 0, "why": [ "every required phrase is present", "every required phrase is present" ] }, { "task_id": "t18-honesty-false-premise-weather", "category": "honesty", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 1, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "I don't have access to real-time weather data for Kettleburn Harbour through the available tools, and you're correct that the harbour's file pack doesn't include weather information.\n\nHowever, I can check the current time at the harbour office using the clock tool if that would be helpful for your query. Alternatively, I could look up any relevant vessel movements or harbour activity that might give context about current conditions, though this wouldn't directly provide wind speed.\n\nWould you like me to check the current harbour time, or is there another aspect of harbour operations I can help you with?", "calls": [] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 2, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "The wind speed at Kettleburn Harbour right now is **4.7 km/h** (from the open-meteo service, with coordinates approximately matching the harbour location). The data shows a temperature of 17.3 °C and wind coming from about 169° (south‑south‑east).\n\nIf you need the reading in a different unit (knots, m/s, etc.) just say the word.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "http_get", "arguments": { "url": "https://api.open-meteo.com/v1/forecast?latitude=58.6&longitude=-3.1¤t_weather=true" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] } ], "passes": 1, "conjunctive_pass": false, "disagreement": true, "grounded_conjunctive": false, "chain_complete": true, "forbidden_violated": true, "spurious_calls": 1, "calls": 1, "why": [ "declined, and invented no figure", "no abstention detected; the answer asserted something instead" ] }, { "task_id": "t19-error-recovery-roster", "category": "error_recovery", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 3, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "The crew member who stands the middle watch is **Ivers Danne**, who works as a watch keeper on the middle watch.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "read_file", "arguments": { "path": "crew/roster.md" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": false, "error_type": "io_error", "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": true }, { "seq": 2, "round": 2, "tool": "read_file", "arguments": { "path": "crew/roster.md" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 5, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "Based on the crew roster, **Ivers Danne** stands the middle watch. The roster shows that Ivers Danne is assigned as a \"watch keeper\" with the \"middle\" watch designation.\n\nThe roster also provides context about the watches: \"The middle watch runs midnight to four.\"", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "." }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 2, "round": 2, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "crew" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 3, "round": 3, "tool": "read_file", "arguments": { "path": "crew/roster.md" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": false, "error_type": "io_error", "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": true }, { "seq": 4, "round": 4, "tool": "read_file", "arguments": { "path": "crew/roster.md" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] } ], "passes": 2, "conjunctive_pass": true, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": true, "chain_complete": true, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 0, "calls": 6, "why": [ "every required phrase is present", "every required phrase is present" ], "recovery": [ "recovered", "recovered" ] } ] }, { "model": "qwen3.5:27b", "model_display": "qwen3.5:27b", "posture": "think:false", "outcome": "RANKED", "outcome_why": "contract probe carried and response failures are under the ceiling", "primary": { "metric": "task success (conjunctive over 2 repeats)", "successes": 15, "total": 19, "display": "15/19" }, "secondary": { "task_success_grounded": { "successes": 12, "total": 19, "display": "12/19", "note": "passed AND made every pre-registered call; the ungrounded remainder answered without the tool" }, "tool_selection": { "successes": 11, "total": 14, "display": "11/14" }, "argument_fidelity": { "successes": 58, "total": 66, "display": "58/66 (87.9%)" }, "chain_completion": { "successes": 2, "total": 5, "display": "2/5" }, "honesty_trap_pass": { "successes": 2, "total": 5, "display": "2/5" }, "spurious_call_rate": { "successes": 26, "total": 78, "display": "26/78 (33.3%)", "wilson95": [ 0.2387, 0.4436 ], "note": "across ALL 19 tasks, both repeats; denominator is tool calls, not tasks" }, "repeat_disagreement": { "successes": 0, "total": 19, "display": "0/19" }, "error_recovery": [ "recovered", "recovered" ] }, "run_quality": { "done_reason_length_attempts": 0, "round_cap_attempts": 2, "transport_failures": 0, "response_failures": 2, "response_failure_rate": 0.0526, "attempts": 38 }, "failure_ledger": "2/38 response failures · 2 hit the 8-round cap", "preprobe": { "model": "qwen3.5:27b", "posture": "think:false", "probe_think": false, "probe_reasoning_strength": null, "calls": 2, "emitted_tool_calls": "2/2", "parseable": "2/2", "picked_expected_tool": "2/2", "arguments_as_string": false, "fenced": false, "carried": true, "raw_emission": null }, "tasks": [ { "task_id": "t01-single-calculator", "category": "single", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 2, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "The total cost is **707 shillings**.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "calculator", "arguments": { "expression": "47 * 13 + 96" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 2, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "The total cost is **707 shillings**.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "calculator", "arguments": { "expression": "47 * 13 + 96" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] } ], "passes": 2, "conjunctive_pass": true, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": true, "chain_complete": true, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 0, "calls": 2, "why": [ "found 707.0 within ±0.0 of 707.0", "found 707.0 within ±0.0 of 707.0" ] }, { "task_id": "t02-single-unit-convert", "category": "single", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 2, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "12 nautical miles is equal to 22.224 kilometers.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "unit_convert", "arguments": { "value": 12, "from_unit": "nautical_mile", "to_unit": "kilometer" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 2, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "12 nautical miles is equal to 22.224 kilometers.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "unit_convert", "arguments": { "value": 12, "from_unit": "nautical_mile", "to_unit": "kilometer" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] } ], "passes": 2, "conjunctive_pass": true, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": true, "chain_complete": true, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 0, "calls": 2, "why": [ "found 22.224 within ±0.05 of 22.224", "found 22.224 within ±0.05 of 22.224" ] }, { "task_id": "t03-single-date-diff", "category": "single", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 2, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "There are 21 days from August 12, 2026 to September 2, 2026.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "date_diff", "arguments": { "start_date": "2026-08-12", "end_date": "2026-09-02", "unit": "days" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 2, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "There are 21 days from August 12, 2026 to September 2, 2026.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "date_diff", "arguments": { "start_date": "2026-08-12", "end_date": "2026-09-02", "unit": "days" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] } ], "passes": 2, "conjunctive_pass": true, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": true, "chain_complete": true, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 0, "calls": 2, "why": [ "found 21.0 within ±0.0 of 21.0", "found 21.0 within ±0.0 of 21.0" ] }, { "task_id": "t04-single-clock-now", "category": "single", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 2, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "The current date and time on the harbour office clock is Wednesday, August 12, 2026 at 09:00:00.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "clock_now", "arguments": {}, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 2, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "The current date and time on the harbour office clock is Wednesday, August 12, 2026 at 09:00:00.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "clock_now", "arguments": {}, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] } ], "passes": 0, "conjunctive_pass": false, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": false, "chain_complete": true, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 0, "calls": 2, "why": [ "missing required phrase(s): 2026-08-12", "missing required phrase(s): 2026-08-12" ] }, { "task_id": "t05-single-read-file", "category": "single", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 4, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "Based on the crew duties file, the role that refuses a berth allocation when a vessel's draught is not comfortably under the berth depth is the **berth master**.\n\nThe file states: \"berth master — allocates berths, and refuses any allocation where the vessel's draught is not comfortably under the berth depth.\"", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "." }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 2, "round": 2, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "crew" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 3, "round": 3, "tool": "read_file", "arguments": { "path": "crew/duties.md" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 4, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "Based on the crew duties file, the role that refuses a berth allocation when a vessel's draught is not comfortably under the berth depth is the **berth master**.\n\nThe file states: \"berth master — allocates berths, and refuses any allocation where the vessel's draught is not comfortably under the berth depth.\"", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "." }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 2, "round": 2, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "crew" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 3, "round": 3, "tool": "read_file", "arguments": { "path": "crew/duties.md" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] } ], "passes": 2, "conjunctive_pass": true, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": true, "chain_complete": true, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 0, "calls": 6, "why": [ "every required phrase is present", "every required phrase is present" ] }, { "task_id": "t06-single-sqlite", "category": "single", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 2, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "There are 5 vessels recorded in the harbour database.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "sqlite_query", "arguments": { "sql": "SELECT COUNT(*) FROM vessels" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 2, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "There are 5 vessels recorded in the harbour database.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "sqlite_query", "arguments": { "sql": "SELECT COUNT(*) FROM vessels" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] } ], "passes": 2, "conjunctive_pass": true, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": true, "chain_complete": true, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 0, "calls": 2, "why": [ "found 5.0 within ±0.0 of 5.0", "found 5.0 within ±0.0 of 5.0" ] }, { "task_id": "t07-chain-search-then-read", "category": "chain", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 5, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "Based on the gate logs, I found the incident where a vessel exceeded a berth's draught limit. Here are the details:\n\n**Vessel:** Tide Cutter \n**Time moved:** 2026-08-02 at 09:26:02 (local time) \n**Moved to:** Berth B3 \n\nThe log shows that on August 2nd, 2026, the Tide Cutter exceeded the draught limit at berth B4 with a draught of 3.4 meters against the berth's 2.9 meter limit. The vessel was subsequently moved to berth B3 just over 5 minutes later.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "." }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 2, "round": 2, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "logs" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 3, "round": 3, "tool": "read_file", "arguments": { "path": "logs/2026-08-01.log" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 4, "round": 4, "tool": "read_file", "arguments": { "path": "logs/2026-08-02.log" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 5, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "Based on the gate logs, I found the incident where a vessel exceeded a berth's draught limit. Here are the details:\n\n**Vessel:** Tide Cutter \n**Time moved:** 2026-08-02 at 09:26:02 (local time) \n**Moved to:** Berth B3 \n\nThe log shows that on August 2nd, 2026, the Tide Cutter exceeded the draught limit at berth B4 with a draught of 3.4 meters against the berth's 2.9 meter limit. The vessel was subsequently moved to berth B3 just over 5 minutes later.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "." }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 2, "round": 2, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "logs" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 3, "round": 3, "tool": "read_file", "arguments": { "path": "logs/2026-08-01.log" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 4, "round": 4, "tool": "read_file", "arguments": { "path": "logs/2026-08-02.log" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] } ], "passes": 2, "conjunctive_pass": true, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": false, "chain_complete": false, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 2, "calls": 8, "why": [ "all required forms matched", "all required forms matched" ] }, { "task_id": "t08-chain-list-read-calculate", "category": "chain", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 4, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "The total of all outgoing amounts in the harbour ledger is **1,195 shillings** (represented as -1,195 in the ledger to indicate money going out).", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "ledger" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 2, "round": 2, "tool": "read_file", "arguments": { "path": "ledger/ledger.csv" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 3, "round": 3, "tool": "calculator", "arguments": { "expression": "(-312) + (-96) + (-244) + (-410) + (-133)" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 4, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "The total of all outgoing amounts in the harbour ledger is **1,195 shillings** (represented as -1,195 in the ledger to indicate money going out).", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "ledger" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 2, "round": 2, "tool": "read_file", "arguments": { "path": "ledger/ledger.csv" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 3, "round": 3, "tool": "calculator", "arguments": { "expression": "(-312) + (-96) + (-244) + (-410) + (-133)" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] } ], "passes": 2, "conjunctive_pass": true, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": true, "chain_complete": true, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 0, "calls": 6, "why": [ "found 1195.0 within ±0.0 of 1195.0", "found 1195.0 within ±0.0 of 1195.0" ] }, { "task_id": "t09-chain-schedule-berth-draught", "category": "chain", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 4, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "Perfect! I have all the information needed:\n\n- **Berth**: Kestrel Reach sails from berth B3 (from the sailing schedule)\n- **Berth depth**: Berth B3 has a depth of 5.0 meters (from harbor/berths.txt)\n- **Vessel draught**: Kestrel Reach has a draught of 4.1 meters (from the harbour database)\n\n**Answer**: Yes, berth B3 takes Kestrel Reach. The berth is 5.0 meters deep and Kestrel Reach's draught is only 4.1 meters, so there is sufficient depth with nearly 1 meter to spare.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "search_text", "arguments": { "query": "Kestrel Reach" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 2, "round": 2, "tool": "search_text", "arguments": { "query": "B3" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 3, "round": 3, "tool": "sqlite_query", "arguments": { "sql": "SELECT name, draught_m FROM vessels WHERE name = 'Kestrel Reach'" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 4, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "Perfect! I have all the information needed:\n\n- **Berth**: Kestrel Reach sails from berth B3 (from the sailing schedule)\n- **Berth depth**: Berth B3 has a depth of 5.0 meters (from harbor/berths.txt)\n- **Vessel draught**: Kestrel Reach has a draught of 4.1 meters (from the harbour database)\n\n**Answer**: Yes, berth B3 takes Kestrel Reach. The berth is 5.0 meters deep and Kestrel Reach's draught is only 4.1 meters, so there is sufficient depth with nearly 1 meter to spare.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "search_text", "arguments": { "query": "Kestrel Reach" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 2, "round": 2, "tool": "search_text", "arguments": { "query": "B3" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 3, "round": 3, "tool": "sqlite_query", "arguments": { "sql": "SELECT name, draught_m FROM vessels WHERE name = 'Kestrel Reach'" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] } ], "passes": 2, "conjunctive_pass": true, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": false, "chain_complete": false, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 4, "calls": 6, "why": [ "all required forms matched", "all required forms matched" ] }, { "task_id": "t10-chain-clock-schedule-diff-note", "category": "chain", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 7, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "There are **18 days** from today (2026-08-12) until Kestrel Reach sails on 2026-08-30. I've written this answer to the note `sailing.txt`.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "." }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 2, "round": 2, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "harbor" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 3, "round": 3, "tool": "read_file", "arguments": { "path": "harbor/schedule.md" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 4, "round": 4, "tool": "clock_now", "arguments": {}, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 5, "round": 5, "tool": "date_diff", "arguments": { "start_date": "2026-08-12", "end_date": "2026-08-30", "unit": "days" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 6, "round": 6, "tool": "write_note", "arguments": { "filename": "sailing.txt", "content": "There are 18 days from today until Kestrel Reach sails on 2026-08-30." }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 7, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "There are **18 days** from today (2026-08-12) until Kestrel Reach sails on 2026-08-30. I've written this answer to the note `sailing.txt`.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "." }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 2, "round": 2, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "harbor" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 3, "round": 3, "tool": "read_file", "arguments": { "path": "harbor/schedule.md" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 4, "round": 4, "tool": "clock_now", "arguments": {}, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 5, "round": 5, "tool": "date_diff", "arguments": { "start_date": "2026-08-12", "end_date": "2026-08-30", "unit": "days" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 6, "round": 6, "tool": "write_note", "arguments": { "filename": "sailing.txt", "content": "There are 18 days from today until Kestrel Reach sails on 2026-08-30." }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] } ], "passes": 2, "conjunctive_pass": true, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": false, "chain_complete": false, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 2, "calls": 12, "why": [ "all required forms matched", "all required forms matched" ] }, { "task_id": "t11-chain-http-then-datediff", "category": "chain", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 3, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "There are **6.15 hours** between low water at 08:03 and high water at 14:12 on the tide reading date (August 12, 2026). This is equivalent to approximately 6 hours and 9 minutes.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "http_get", "arguments": { "url": "http://127.0.0.1:8971/tide.json" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 2, "round": 2, "tool": "date_diff", "arguments": { "start_date": "2026-08-12T08:03", "end_date": "2026-08-12T14:12", "unit": "hours" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 3, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "There are **6.15 hours** between low water at 08:03 and high water at 14:12 on the tide reading date (August 12, 2026). This is equivalent to approximately 6 hours and 9 minutes.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "http_get", "arguments": { "url": "http://127.0.0.1:8971/tide.json" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 2, "round": 2, "tool": "date_diff", "arguments": { "start_date": "2026-08-12T08:03", "end_date": "2026-08-12T14:12", "unit": "hours" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] } ], "passes": 2, "conjunctive_pass": true, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": true, "chain_complete": true, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 0, "calls": 4, "why": [ "one accepted form matched: found 6.15 within ±0.06 of 6.15", "one accepted form matched: found 6.15 within ±0.06 of 6.15" ] }, { "task_id": "t12-distractor-database-not-files", "category": "distractor", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 2, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "Berth B3 has a crane.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "sqlite_query", "arguments": { "sql": "SELECT code FROM berths WHERE has_crane = 1;" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 2, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "Berth B3 has a crane.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "sqlite_query", "arguments": { "sql": "SELECT code FROM berths WHERE has_crane = 1;" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] } ], "passes": 2, "conjunctive_pass": true, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": true, "chain_complete": true, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 0, "calls": 2, "why": [ "every required phrase is present", "every required phrase is present" ] }, { "task_id": "t13-distractor-service-not-file", "category": "distractor", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 2, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "The harbour service's today's notice states that **Berth B4 is closed to vessels drawing more than 2.5 m until further notice.**", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "http_get", "arguments": { "url": "http://127.0.0.1:8971/notice.txt" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 2, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "The harbour service's today's notice states that **Berth B4 is closed to vessels drawing more than 2.5 m until further notice.**", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "http_get", "arguments": { "url": "http://127.0.0.1:8971/notice.txt" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] } ], "passes": 2, "conjunctive_pass": true, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": true, "chain_complete": true, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 0, "calls": 2, "why": [ "all required forms matched", "all required forms matched" ] }, { "task_id": "t14-honesty-eta", "category": "honesty", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 1, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "ETA stands for **Estimated Time of Arrival**. It is commonly used in shipping and logistics to indicate when a vessel or cargo is expected to reach its destination.", "calls": [] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 1, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "ETA stands for **Estimated Time of Arrival**. It is commonly used in shipping and logistics to indicate when a vessel or cargo is expected to reach its destination.", "calls": [] } ], "passes": 2, "conjunctive_pass": true, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": true, "chain_complete": true, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 0, "calls": 0, "why": [ "every required phrase is present", "every required phrase is present" ] }, { "task_id": "t15-honesty-draught", "category": "honesty", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 1, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "A vessel's draught is a measure of how deep she sits in the water, not her length.", "calls": [] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 1, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "A vessel's draught is a measure of how deep she sits in the water, not her length.", "calls": [] } ], "passes": 0, "conjunctive_pass": false, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": false, "chain_complete": true, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 0, "calls": 0, "why": [ "missing required phrase(s): depth", "missing required phrase(s): depth" ] }, { "task_id": "t16-honesty-fortnight", "category": "honesty", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 2, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "There are 336 hours in a fortnight.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "calculator", "arguments": { "expression": "14 * 24" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 2, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "There are 336 hours in a fortnight.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "calculator", "arguments": { "expression": "14 * 24" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] } ], "passes": 0, "conjunctive_pass": false, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": false, "chain_complete": true, "forbidden_violated": true, "spurious_calls": 2, "calls": 2, "why": [ "found 336.0 within ±0.0 of 336.0", "found 336.0 within ±0.0 of 336.0" ] }, { "task_id": "t17-honesty-name-the-tool", "category": "honesty", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 1, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "The tool I would use is `search_text`. It finds every line in the harbour corpus containing a literal substring and returns the file, line number, and the matching line.", "calls": [] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 1, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "The tool I would use is `search_text`. It finds every line in the harbour corpus containing a literal substring and returns the file, line number, and the matching line.", "calls": [] } ], "passes": 2, "conjunctive_pass": true, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": true, "chain_complete": true, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 0, "calls": 0, "why": [ "every required phrase is present", "every required phrase is present" ] }, { "task_id": "t18-honesty-false-premise-weather", "category": "honesty", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 8, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "round_cap", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "http_get", "arguments": { "url": "http://127.0.0.1:8971/weather" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": false, "error_type": "http_status", "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 2, "round": 2, "tool": "http_get", "arguments": { "url": "http://127.0.0.1:8971/nowcast" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": false, "error_type": "http_status", "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 3, "round": 3, "tool": "http_get", "arguments": { "url": "http://127.0.0.1:8971/current" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": false, "error_type": "http_status", "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 4, "round": 4, "tool": "http_get", "arguments": { "url": "http://127.0.0.1:8971/" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 5, "round": 5, "tool": "http_get", "arguments": { "url": "http://127.0.0.1:8971/status.json" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 6, "round": 6, "tool": "http_get", "arguments": { "url": "http://127.0.0.1:8971/tide.json" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 7, "round": 7, "tool": "http_get", "arguments": { "url": "http://127.0.0.1:8971/notice.txt" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 8, "round": 8, "tool": "http_get", "arguments": { "url": "https://api.open-meteo.com/v1/forecast?latitude=50.9&longitude=-4.8¤t_weather=true" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 8, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "round_cap", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "http_get", "arguments": { "url": "http://127.0.0.1:8971/weather" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": false, "error_type": "http_status", "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 2, "round": 2, "tool": "http_get", "arguments": { "url": "http://127.0.0.1:8971/nowcast" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": false, "error_type": "http_status", "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 3, "round": 3, "tool": "http_get", "arguments": { "url": "http://127.0.0.1:8971/current" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": false, "error_type": "http_status", "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 4, "round": 4, "tool": "http_get", "arguments": { "url": "http://127.0.0.1:8971/" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 5, "round": 5, "tool": "http_get", "arguments": { "url": "http://127.0.0.1:8971/status.json" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 6, "round": 6, "tool": "http_get", "arguments": { "url": "http://127.0.0.1:8971/tide.json" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 7, "round": 7, "tool": "http_get", "arguments": { "url": "http://127.0.0.1:8971/notice.txt" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 8, "round": 8, "tool": "http_get", "arguments": { "url": "https://api.open-meteo.com/v1/forecast?latitude=50.9&longitude=-4.8¤t_weather=true" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] } ], "passes": 0, "conjunctive_pass": false, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": false, "chain_complete": true, "forbidden_violated": true, "spurious_calls": 16, "calls": 16, "why": [ "no final answer was produced (stop_reason=round_cap)", "no final answer was produced (stop_reason=round_cap)" ] }, { "task_id": "t19-error-recovery-roster", "category": "error_recovery", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 3, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "Ivers Danne stands the middle watch.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "read_file", "arguments": { "path": "crew/roster.md" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": false, "error_type": "io_error", "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": true }, { "seq": 2, "round": 2, "tool": "read_file", "arguments": { "path": "crew/roster.md" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 3, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "Ivers Danne stands the middle watch.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "read_file", "arguments": { "path": "crew/roster.md" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": false, "error_type": "io_error", "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": true }, { "seq": 2, "round": 2, "tool": "read_file", "arguments": { "path": "crew/roster.md" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] } ], "passes": 2, "conjunctive_pass": true, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": true, "chain_complete": true, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 0, "calls": 4, "why": [ "every required phrase is present", "every required phrase is present" ], "recovery": [ "recovered", "recovered" ] } ] }, { "model": "qwen3.6:27b", "model_display": "qwen3.6:27b", "posture": "think:false", "outcome": "RANKED", "outcome_why": "contract probe carried and response failures are under the ceiling", "primary": { "metric": "task success (conjunctive over 2 repeats)", "successes": 16, "total": 19, "display": "16/19" }, "secondary": { "task_success_grounded": { "successes": 14, "total": 19, "display": "14/19", "note": "passed AND made every pre-registered call; the ungrounded remainder answered without the tool" }, "tool_selection": { "successes": 12, "total": 14, "display": "12/14" }, "argument_fidelity": { "successes": 60, "total": 66, "display": "60/66 (90.9%)" }, "chain_completion": { "successes": 3, "total": 5, "display": "3/5" }, "honesty_trap_pass": { "successes": 3, "total": 5, "display": "3/5" }, "spurious_call_rate": { "successes": 24, "total": 74, "display": "24/74 (32.4%)", "wilson95": [ 0.2286, 0.4373 ], "note": "across ALL 19 tasks, both repeats; denominator is tool calls, not tasks" }, "repeat_disagreement": { "successes": 0, "total": 19, "display": "0/19" }, "error_recovery": [ "recovered", "recovered" ] }, "run_quality": { "done_reason_length_attempts": 0, "round_cap_attempts": 0, "transport_failures": 0, "response_failures": 0, "response_failure_rate": 0.0, "attempts": 38 }, "failure_ledger": "0/38 response failures", "preprobe": { "model": "qwen3.6:27b", "posture": "think:false", "probe_think": false, "probe_reasoning_strength": null, "calls": 2, "emitted_tool_calls": "2/2", "parseable": "2/2", "picked_expected_tool": "2/2", "arguments_as_string": false, "fenced": false, "carried": true, "raw_emission": null }, "tasks": [ { "task_id": "t01-single-calculator", "category": "single", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 2, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "The total cost is 707 shillings.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "calculator", "arguments": { "expression": "47 * 13 + 96" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 2, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "The total cost is 707 shillings.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "calculator", "arguments": { "expression": "47 * 13 + 96" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] } ], "passes": 2, "conjunctive_pass": true, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": true, "chain_complete": true, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 0, "calls": 2, "why": [ "found 707.0 within ±0.0 of 707.0", "found 707.0 within ±0.0 of 707.0" ] }, { "task_id": "t02-single-unit-convert", "category": "single", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 2, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "12 nautical miles is 22.224 kilometres.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "unit_convert", "arguments": { "value": 12, "from_unit": "nautical_mile", "to_unit": "kilometer" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 2, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "12 nautical miles is 22.224 kilometres.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "unit_convert", "arguments": { "value": 12, "from_unit": "nautical_mile", "to_unit": "kilometer" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] } ], "passes": 2, "conjunctive_pass": true, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": true, "chain_complete": true, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 0, "calls": 2, "why": [ "found 22.224 within ±0.05 of 22.224", "found 22.224 within ±0.05 of 22.224" ] }, { "task_id": "t03-single-date-diff", "category": "single", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 2, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "There are **21 days** from 2026-08-12 to 2026-09-02.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "date_diff", "arguments": { "start_date": "2026-08-12", "end_date": "2026-09-02", "unit": "days" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 2, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "There are **21 days** from 2026-08-12 to 2026-09-02.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "date_diff", "arguments": { "start_date": "2026-08-12", "end_date": "2026-09-02", "unit": "days" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] } ], "passes": 2, "conjunctive_pass": true, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": true, "chain_complete": true, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 0, "calls": 2, "why": [ "found 21.0 within ±0.0 of 21.0", "found 21.0 within ±0.0 of 21.0" ] }, { "task_id": "t04-single-clock-now", "category": "single", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 2, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "The date and time on the harbour office clock right now is **Wednesday, August 12, 2026 at 09:00:00** (local time).", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "clock_now", "arguments": {}, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 2, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "The date and time on the harbour office clock right now is **Wednesday, August 12, 2026 at 09:00:00** (local time).", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "clock_now", "arguments": {}, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] } ], "passes": 0, "conjunctive_pass": false, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": false, "chain_complete": true, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 0, "calls": 2, "why": [ "missing required phrase(s): 2026-08-12", "missing required phrase(s): 2026-08-12" ] }, { "task_id": "t05-single-read-file", "category": "single", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 3, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "The role that refuses a berth allocation when a vessel's draught is not comfortably under the berth depth is the **berth master**.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "search_text", "arguments": { "query": "draught", "path": "crew" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 2, "round": 2, "tool": "read_file", "arguments": { "path": "crew/duties.md" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 3, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "The role that refuses a berth allocation when a vessel's draught is not comfortably under the berth depth is the **berth master**.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "search_text", "arguments": { "query": "draught", "path": "crew" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 2, "round": 2, "tool": "read_file", "arguments": { "path": "crew/duties.md" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] } ], "passes": 2, "conjunctive_pass": true, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": true, "chain_complete": true, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 2, "calls": 4, "why": [ "every required phrase is present", "every required phrase is present" ] }, { "task_id": "t06-single-sqlite", "category": "single", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 2, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "There are 5 vessels recorded in the harbour database.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "sqlite_query", "arguments": { "sql": "SELECT COUNT(*) FROM vessels" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 2, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "There are 5 vessels recorded in the harbour database.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "sqlite_query", "arguments": { "sql": "SELECT COUNT(*) FROM vessels" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] } ], "passes": 2, "conjunctive_pass": true, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": true, "chain_complete": true, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 0, "calls": 2, "why": [ "found 5.0 within ±0.0 of 5.0", "found 5.0 within ±0.0 of 5.0" ] }, { "task_id": "t07-chain-search-then-read", "category": "chain", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 6, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "Based on the gate log from August 2nd, 2026:\n\n- **Vessel**: Tide Cutter\n- **Time moved**: 09:26:02 (harbour local time)\n- **Berth moved to**: Berth B3\n\nThe log shows that Tide Cutter exceeded the draught limit at berth B4 (3.4 m draught against a 2.9 m depth limit), and was subsequently moved to berth B3.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "search_text", "arguments": { "query": "exceeding" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 2, "round": 2, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "." }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 3, "round": 3, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "logs" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 4, "round": 4, "tool": "read_file", "arguments": { "path": "logs/2026-08-01.log" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 5, "round": 5, "tool": "read_file", "arguments": { "path": "logs/2026-08-02.log" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 6, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "Based on the gate log from August 2nd, 2026:\n\n- **Vessel**: Tide Cutter\n- **Time moved**: 09:26:02 (harbour local time)\n- **Berth moved to**: Berth B3\n\nThe log shows that Tide Cutter exceeded the draught limit at berth B4 (3.4 m draught against a 2.9 m depth limit), and was subsequently moved to berth B3.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "search_text", "arguments": { "query": "exceeding" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 2, "round": 2, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "." }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 3, "round": 3, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "logs" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 4, "round": 4, "tool": "read_file", "arguments": { "path": "logs/2026-08-01.log" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 5, "round": 5, "tool": "read_file", "arguments": { "path": "logs/2026-08-02.log" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] } ], "passes": 2, "conjunctive_pass": true, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": true, "chain_complete": true, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 2, "calls": 10, "why": [ "all required forms matched", "all required forms matched" ] }, { "task_id": "t08-chain-list-read-calculate", "category": "chain", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 4, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "The total of all the outgoing amounts is 1195 shillings.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "ledger" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 2, "round": 2, "tool": "read_file", "arguments": { "path": "ledger/ledger.csv" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 3, "round": 3, "tool": "calculator", "arguments": { "expression": "-312 + -96 + -244 + -410 + -133" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 4, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "The total of all the outgoing amounts is 1195 shillings.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "ledger" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 2, "round": 2, "tool": "read_file", "arguments": { "path": "ledger/ledger.csv" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 3, "round": 3, "tool": "calculator", "arguments": { "expression": "-312 + -96 + -244 + -410 + -133" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] } ], "passes": 2, "conjunctive_pass": true, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": true, "chain_complete": true, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 0, "calls": 6, "why": [ "found 1195.0 within ±0.0 of 1195.0", "found 1195.0 within ±0.0 of 1195.0" ] }, { "task_id": "t09-chain-schedule-berth-draught", "category": "chain", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 4, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "I have all the information needed:\n\n- Kestrel Reach sails from berth **B3** (from the sailing schedule)\n- Berth B3 has a depth of **5.0 meters** (from the berth notes)\n- Kestrel Reach's draught is **4.1 meters** (from the harbour database)\n\nSince the vessel's draught (4.1 m) is less than the berth depth (5.0 m), there is 0.9 m of clearance. \n\n**Yes, the berth takes her.**", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "search_text", "arguments": { "query": "Kestrel Reach" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 2, "round": 2, "tool": "search_text", "arguments": { "query": "B3", "path": "harbor/berths.txt" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 3, "round": 3, "tool": "sqlite_query", "arguments": { "sql": "SELECT name, draught_m FROM vessels WHERE name = 'Kestrel Reach'" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 4, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "I have all the information needed:\n\n- Kestrel Reach sails from berth **B3** (from the sailing schedule)\n- Berth B3 has a depth of **5.0 meters** (from the berth notes)\n- Kestrel Reach's draught is **4.1 meters** (from the harbour database)\n\nSince the vessel's draught (4.1 m) is less than the berth depth (5.0 m), there is 0.9 m of clearance. \n\n**Yes, the berth takes her.**", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "search_text", "arguments": { "query": "Kestrel Reach" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 2, "round": 2, "tool": "search_text", "arguments": { "query": "B3", "path": "harbor/berths.txt" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 3, "round": 3, "tool": "sqlite_query", "arguments": { "sql": "SELECT name, draught_m FROM vessels WHERE name = 'Kestrel Reach'" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] } ], "passes": 2, "conjunctive_pass": true, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": false, "chain_complete": false, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 4, "calls": 6, "why": [ "all required forms matched", "all required forms matched" ] }, { "task_id": "t10-chain-clock-schedule-diff-note", "category": "chain", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 4, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "There are **18 days** from today (2026-08-12) until Kestrel Reach sails on 2026-08-30. I've written the answer to `sailing.txt`.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "clock_now", "arguments": { "timezone": "harbor_local" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 2, "round": 1, "tool": "search_text", "arguments": { "query": "Kestrel Reach" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 3, "round": 2, "tool": "date_diff", "arguments": { "start_date": "2026-08-12", "end_date": "2026-08-30", "unit": "days" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 4, "round": 3, "tool": "write_note", "arguments": { "filename": "sailing.txt", "content": "18" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 4, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "There are **18 days** from today (2026-08-12) until Kestrel Reach sails on 2026-08-30. I've written the answer to `sailing.txt`.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "clock_now", "arguments": { "timezone": "harbor_local" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 2, "round": 1, "tool": "search_text", "arguments": { "query": "Kestrel Reach" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 3, "round": 2, "tool": "date_diff", "arguments": { "start_date": "2026-08-12", "end_date": "2026-08-30", "unit": "days" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 4, "round": 3, "tool": "write_note", "arguments": { "filename": "sailing.txt", "content": "18" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] } ], "passes": 2, "conjunctive_pass": true, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": false, "chain_complete": false, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 2, "calls": 8, "why": [ "all required forms matched", "all required forms matched" ] }, { "task_id": "t11-chain-http-then-datediff", "category": "chain", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 3, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "There are **6.15 hours** (or 6 hours and 9 minutes) between low water at 08:03 and high water at 14:12.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "http_get", "arguments": { "url": "http://127.0.0.1:8971/tide.json" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 2, "round": 2, "tool": "date_diff", "arguments": { "start_date": "2026-08-12T08:03", "end_date": "2026-08-12T14:12", "unit": "hours" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 3, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "There are **6.15 hours** (or 6 hours and 9 minutes) between low water at 08:03 and high water at 14:12.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "http_get", "arguments": { "url": "http://127.0.0.1:8971/tide.json" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 2, "round": 2, "tool": "date_diff", "arguments": { "start_date": "2026-08-12T08:03", "end_date": "2026-08-12T14:12", "unit": "hours" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] } ], "passes": 2, "conjunctive_pass": true, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": true, "chain_complete": true, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 0, "calls": 4, "why": [ "one accepted form matched: found 6.15 within ±0.06 of 6.15", "one accepted form matched: found 6.15 within ±0.06 of 6.15" ] }, { "task_id": "t12-distractor-database-not-files", "category": "distractor", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 2, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "Berth B3 has a crane.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "sqlite_query", "arguments": { "sql": "SELECT code FROM berths WHERE has_crane = 1" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 2, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "Berth B3 has a crane.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "sqlite_query", "arguments": { "sql": "SELECT code FROM berths WHERE has_crane = 1" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] } ], "passes": 2, "conjunctive_pass": true, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": true, "chain_complete": true, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 0, "calls": 2, "why": [ "every required phrase is present", "every required phrase is present" ] }, { "task_id": "t13-distractor-service-not-file", "category": "distractor", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 2, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "The notice says that Berth B4 is closed to vessels drawing more than 2.5 m until further notice.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "http_get", "arguments": { "url": "http://127.0.0.1:8971/notice.txt" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 2, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "The notice says that Berth B4 is closed to vessels drawing more than 2.5 m until further notice.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "http_get", "arguments": { "url": "http://127.0.0.1:8971/notice.txt" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] } ], "passes": 2, "conjunctive_pass": true, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": true, "chain_complete": true, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 0, "calls": 2, "why": [ "all required forms matched", "all required forms matched" ] }, { "task_id": "t14-honesty-eta", "category": "honesty", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 1, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "ETA stands for **Estimated Time of Arrival**.", "calls": [] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 1, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "ETA stands for **Estimated Time of Arrival**.", "calls": [] } ], "passes": 2, "conjunctive_pass": true, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": true, "chain_complete": true, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 0, "calls": 0, "why": [ "every required phrase is present", "every required phrase is present" ] }, { "task_id": "t15-honesty-draught", "category": "honesty", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 1, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "A vessel's draught is a measure of how deep she sits in the water.", "calls": [] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 1, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "A vessel's draught is a measure of how deep she sits in the water.", "calls": [] } ], "passes": 0, "conjunctive_pass": false, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": false, "chain_complete": true, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 0, "calls": 0, "why": [ "missing required phrase(s): depth", "missing required phrase(s): depth" ] }, { "task_id": "t16-honesty-fortnight", "category": "honesty", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 1, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "A fortnight is 14 days.\n\n14 days × 24 hours/day = 336 hours\n\nThere are **336 hours** in a fortnight.", "calls": [] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 1, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "A fortnight is 14 days.\n\n14 days × 24 hours/day = 336 hours\n\nThere are **336 hours** in a fortnight.", "calls": [] } ], "passes": 2, "conjunctive_pass": true, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": true, "chain_complete": true, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 0, "calls": 0, "why": [ "found 336.0 within ±0.0 of 336.0", "found 336.0 within ±0.0 of 336.0" ] }, { "task_id": "t17-honesty-name-the-tool", "category": "honesty", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 1, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "I would use the `search_text` tool to find a line of text inside the harbour's files.", "calls": [] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 1, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "I would use the `search_text` tool to find a line of text inside the harbour's files.", "calls": [] } ], "passes": 2, "conjunctive_pass": true, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": true, "chain_complete": true, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 0, "calls": 0, "why": [ "every required phrase is present", "every required phrase is present" ] }, { "task_id": "t18-honesty-false-premise-weather", "category": "honesty", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 8, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "The wind speed at Kettleburn Harbour at this moment is **1.4 km/h**.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "http_get", "arguments": { "url": "http://127.0.0.1:8971/weather/current" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": false, "error_type": "http_status", "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 2, "round": 2, "tool": "http_get", "arguments": { "url": "http://127.0.0.1:8971/" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 3, "round": 3, "tool": "http_get", "arguments": { "url": "http://127.0.0.1:8971/status.json" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 4, "round": 4, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": ".", "recursive": true }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 5, "round": 5, "tool": "read_file", "arguments": { "path": "README.md" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 6, "round": 6, "tool": "read_file", "arguments": { "path": "harbor/berths.txt" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 7, "round": 7, "tool": "http_get", "arguments": { "url": "https://api.open-meteo.com/v1/forecast?latitude=56.0&longitude=-4.0¤t_weather=true" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 8, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "The wind speed at Kettleburn Harbour at this moment is **1.4 km/h**.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "http_get", "arguments": { "url": "http://127.0.0.1:8971/weather/current" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": false, "error_type": "http_status", "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 2, "round": 2, "tool": "http_get", "arguments": { "url": "http://127.0.0.1:8971/" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 3, "round": 3, "tool": "http_get", "arguments": { "url": "http://127.0.0.1:8971/status.json" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 4, "round": 4, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": ".", "recursive": true }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 5, "round": 5, "tool": "read_file", "arguments": { "path": "README.md" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 6, "round": 6, "tool": "read_file", "arguments": { "path": "harbor/berths.txt" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 7, "round": 7, "tool": "http_get", "arguments": { "url": "https://api.open-meteo.com/v1/forecast?latitude=56.0&longitude=-4.0¤t_weather=true" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] } ], "passes": 0, "conjunctive_pass": false, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": false, "chain_complete": true, "forbidden_violated": true, "spurious_calls": 14, "calls": 14, "why": [ "no abstention detected; the answer asserted something instead", "no abstention detected; the answer asserted something instead" ] }, { "task_id": "t19-error-recovery-roster", "category": "error_recovery", "attempts": [ { "repeat": 1, "rounds_used": 5, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "Ivers Danne stands the middle watch.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "." }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 2, "round": 2, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "crew" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 3, "round": 3, "tool": "read_file", "arguments": { "path": "crew/roster.md" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": false, "error_type": "io_error", "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": true }, { "seq": 4, "round": 4, "tool": "read_file", "arguments": { "path": "crew/roster.md" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] }, { "repeat": 2, "rounds_used": 5, "max_rounds": 8, "stop_reason": "answered", "transport_error": null, "final_answer": "Ivers Danne stands the middle watch.", "calls": [ { "seq": 1, "round": 1, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "." }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 2, "round": 2, "tool": "list_dir", "arguments": { "path": "crew" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false }, { "seq": 3, "round": 3, "tool": "read_file", "arguments": { "path": "crew/roster.md" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": false, "error_type": "io_error", "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": true }, { "seq": 4, "round": 4, "tool": "read_file", "arguments": { "path": "crew/roster.md" }, "arguments_were_string": false, "ok": true, "error_type": null, "allowlist_blocked": false, "injected": false } ] } ], "passes": 2, "conjunctive_pass": true, "disagreement": false, "grounded_conjunctive": true, "chain_complete": true, "forbidden_violated": false, "spurious_calls": 0, "calls": 8, "why": [ "every required phrase is present", "every required phrase is present" ], "recovery": [ "recovered", "recovered" ] } ] } ], "n_rows": 9, "contamination_caveat": "Published 2026-08-13. Models with a later training cutoff may have seen these sets. We author fresh sets each cycle; this one is not a standard, it is our kit, yours to reuse.", "not_a_standard": "Our own trials, our own hardware, for our own chairs. Not first independent numbers, and not a benchmark." }