{
 "prereg": "ROBBER-LADDER2-PREREG.md (sha in PREREG-INDEX.txt)",
 "receipts": {
  "loads": [
   {
    "arm": "gemma4:12b",
    "before_load_ps": [
     {
      "name": "nomic-embed-text:latest",
      "size_vram_gib": 0.3
     },
     {
      "name": "qwen3.8:27b",
      "size_vram_gib": 16.33
     },
     {
      "name": "gemma4:12b",
      "size_vram_gib": 7.55
     },
     {
      "name": "gemma4:26b",
      "size_vram_gib": 16.27
     }
    ],
    "card": {
     "vram_free_gib": 43.6,
     "render_queue": 0
    },
    "utc": "2026-08-20T13:27:28Z",
    "seated": {
     "size_vram_gib": 7.55,
     "size_gib": 7.55,
     "fully_seated": true
    },
    "after_arm_card": {
     "vram_free_gib": 43.6,
     "render_queue": 0
    },
    "after_arm_seated": {
     "size_vram_gib": 7.55,
     "size_gib": 7.55,
     "fully_seated": true
    }
   },
   {
    "arm": "gemma4:12b-it-qat",
    "before_load_ps": [
     {
      "name": "gemma4:12b",
      "size_vram_gib": 7.55
     },
     {
      "name": "qwen3.8:27b",
      "size_vram_gib": 16.33
     },
     {
      "name": "nomic-embed-text:latest",
      "size_vram_gib": 0.3
     },
     {
      "name": "gemma4:26b",
      "size_vram_gib": 16.27
     }
    ],
    "card": {
     "vram_free_gib": 43.6,
     "render_queue": 0
    },
    "utc": "2026-08-20T13:28:14Z",
    "seated": {
     "size_vram_gib": 7.18,
     "size_gib": 7.18,
     "fully_seated": true
    },
    "after_arm_card": {
     "vram_free_gib": 35.3,
     "render_queue": 0
    },
    "after_arm_seated": {
     "size_vram_gib": 7.18,
     "size_gib": 7.18,
     "fully_seated": true
    }
   },
   {
    "arm": "gemma4:12b-it-q8_0",
    "before_load_ps": [
     {
      "name": "gemma4:12b",
      "size_vram_gib": 7.55
     },
     {
      "name": "nomic-embed-text:latest",
      "size_vram_gib": 0.3
     },
     {
      "name": "qwen3.8:27b",
      "size_vram_gib": 16.33
     },
     {
      "name": "gemma4:26b",
      "size_vram_gib": 16.27
     }
    ],
    "card": {
     "vram_free_gib": 43.6,
     "render_queue": 0
    },
    "utc": "2026-08-20T13:29:07Z",
    "seated": {
     "size_vram_gib": 12.48,
     "size_gib": 12.48,
     "fully_seated": true
    },
    "after_arm_card": {
     "vram_free_gib": 30.0,
     "render_queue": 0
    },
    "after_arm_seated": {
     "size_vram_gib": 12.48,
     "size_gib": 12.48,
     "fully_seated": true
    }
   },
   {
    "arm": "gemma4:12b-it-bf16",
    "before_load_ps": [
     {
      "name": "gemma4:26b",
      "size_vram_gib": 16.27
     },
     {
      "name": "gemma4:12b",
      "size_vram_gib": 7.55
     },
     {
      "name": "qwen3.8:27b",
      "size_vram_gib": 16.33
     },
     {
      "name": "nomic-embed-text:latest",
      "size_vram_gib": 0.3
     }
    ],
    "card": {
     "vram_free_gib": 43.6,
     "render_queue": 0
    },
    "utc": "2026-08-20T13:30:05Z",
    "seated": {
     "size_vram_gib": 22.87,
     "size_gib": 22.87,
     "fully_seated": true
    },
    "after_arm_card": {
     "vram_free_gib": 19.6,
     "render_queue": 0
    },
    "after_arm_seated": {
     "size_vram_gib": 22.87,
     "size_gib": 22.87,
     "fully_seated": true
    }
   }
  ],
  "registration": "ROBBER-LADDER2-PREREG.md",
  "window_open_utc": "2026-08-20T13:27:28Z",
  "close_ps": [
   {
    "name": "gemma4:26b",
    "size_vram_gib": 16.27
   },
   {
    "name": "gemma4:12b",
    "size_vram_gib": 7.55
   },
   {
    "name": "qwen3.8:27b",
    "size_vram_gib": 16.33
   },
   {
    "name": "nomic-embed-text:latest",
    "size_vram_gib": 0.3
   }
  ],
  "window_close_utc": "2026-08-20T13:31:20Z"
 },
 "fresh_vs_0819": {
  "gemma4:12b/Q1-simple": "IDENTICAL-TO-08-19",
  "gemma4:12b/Q2-complex": "IDENTICAL-TO-08-19",
  "gemma4:12b-it-q8_0/Q1-simple": "IDENTICAL-TO-08-19",
  "gemma4:12b-it-q8_0/Q2-complex": "IDENTICAL-TO-08-19"
 },
 "runs": [
  {
   "model": "gemma4:12b",
   "question": "Q1-simple",
   "i": 0,
   "utc": "2026-08-20T13:27:36Z",
   "prompt_eval_count": 68,
   "prompt_eval_duration_ns": 25027000,
   "eval_count": 98,
   "eval_duration_ns": 777176000,
   "decode_tok_s": 126.1,
   "reply_sha256": "70aeb9034cf26036814c7b484fb169a54ef8c5988552582c28b336b481c20281",
   "reply_verbatim": "No, you cannot move the robber back to the desert.\n\nIn Catan, the robber must be moved to a hex that contains at least one settlement or city. Since the desert is empty, it doesn't count as a valid spot. \n\nThink of the desert as \"off-limits\" for the robber—it's a place where no one lives, so there is no one there to be blocked! You must pick a hex with a building on it."
  },
  {
   "model": "gemma4:12b",
   "question": "Q1-simple",
   "i": 1,
   "utc": "2026-08-20T13:27:39Z",
   "prompt_eval_count": 68,
   "prompt_eval_duration_ns": 25330000,
   "eval_count": 98,
   "eval_duration_ns": 757297000,
   "decode_tok_s": 129.41,
   "reply_sha256": "70aeb9034cf26036814c7b484fb169a54ef8c5988552582c28b336b481c20281",
   "reply_verbatim": "No, you cannot move the robber back to the desert.\n\nIn Catan, the robber must be moved to a hex that contains at least one settlement or city. Since the desert is empty, it doesn't count as a valid spot. \n\nThink of the desert as \"off-limits\" for the robber—it's a place where no one lives, so there is no one there to be blocked! You must pick a hex with a building on it."
  },
  {
   "model": "gemma4:12b",
   "question": "Q1-simple",
   "i": 2,
   "utc": "2026-08-20T13:27:43Z",
   "prompt_eval_count": 68,
   "prompt_eval_duration_ns": 25327000,
   "eval_count": 98,
   "eval_duration_ns": 757238000,
   "decode_tok_s": 129.42,
   "reply_sha256": "70aeb9034cf26036814c7b484fb169a54ef8c5988552582c28b336b481c20281",
   "reply_verbatim": "No, you cannot move the robber back to the desert.\n\nIn Catan, the robber must be moved to a hex that contains at least one settlement or city. Since the desert is empty, it doesn't count as a valid spot. \n\nThink of the desert as \"off-limits\" for the robber—it's a place where no one lives, so there is no one there to be blocked! You must pick a hex with a building on it."
  },
  {
   "model": "gemma4:12b",
   "question": "Q1-simple",
   "i": 3,
   "utc": "2026-08-20T13:27:46Z",
   "prompt_eval_count": 68,
   "prompt_eval_duration_ns": 24978000,
   "eval_count": 98,
   "eval_duration_ns": 757181000,
   "decode_tok_s": 129.43,
   "reply_sha256": "70aeb9034cf26036814c7b484fb169a54ef8c5988552582c28b336b481c20281",
   "reply_verbatim": "No, you cannot move the robber back to the desert.\n\nIn Catan, the robber must be moved to a hex that contains at least one settlement or city. Since the desert is empty, it doesn't count as a valid spot. \n\nThink of the desert as \"off-limits\" for the robber—it's a place where no one lives, so there is no one there to be blocked! You must pick a hex with a building on it."
  },
  {
   "model": "gemma4:12b",
   "question": "Q1-simple",
   "i": 4,
   "utc": "2026-08-20T13:27:49Z",
   "prompt_eval_count": 68,
   "prompt_eval_duration_ns": 25221000,
   "eval_count": 98,
   "eval_duration_ns": 757401000,
   "decode_tok_s": 129.39,
   "reply_sha256": "70aeb9034cf26036814c7b484fb169a54ef8c5988552582c28b336b481c20281",
   "reply_verbatim": "No, you cannot move the robber back to the desert.\n\nIn Catan, the robber must be moved to a hex that contains at least one settlement or city. Since the desert is empty, it doesn't count as a valid spot. \n\nThink of the desert as \"off-limits\" for the robber—it's a place where no one lives, so there is no one there to be blocked! You must pick a hex with a building on it."
  },
  {
   "model": "gemma4:12b",
   "question": "Q2-complex",
   "i": 0,
   "utc": "2026-08-20T13:27:58Z",
   "prompt_eval_count": 106,
   "prompt_eval_duration_ns": 28426000,
   "eval_count": 208,
   "eval_duration_ns": 1627000000,
   "decode_tok_s": 127.84,
   "reply_sha256": "0af51e48d5fd99e0e826c5af53972700bdc5c40c0d51687567b4bf66338f5800",
   "reply_verbatim": "Here are the answers to your questions:\n\n**The Desert and the Robber**\nNo, you do not move the robber if it is on a desert hex. The robber is only moved when a 7 is rolled if it is currently sitting on a **resource hex** (forest, pasture, etc.). If it is on a desert, it stays put.\n\n**Moving the Robber back to the Desert**\nYes, you can move the robber onto a desert hex during your turn if you choose to do so. While it won't move on a 7, it still occupies that space.\n\n**Choosing a victim**\nIf the robber lands on a hex touched by two different players, **you** (the player who rolled the 7) choose which player to rob.\n\n**Robbing a player with zero cards**\nIf the player you choose to rob has no cards in their hand, **nothing happens.** You do not get to pick a different player, and the turn simply continues."
  },
  {
   "model": "gemma4:12b",
   "question": "Q2-complex",
   "i": 1,
   "utc": "2026-08-20T13:28:02Z",
   "prompt_eval_count": 106,
   "prompt_eval_duration_ns": 28136000,
   "eval_count": 208,
   "eval_duration_ns": 1620650000,
   "decode_tok_s": 128.34,
   "reply_sha256": "0af51e48d5fd99e0e826c5af53972700bdc5c40c0d51687567b4bf66338f5800",
   "reply_verbatim": "Here are the answers to your questions:\n\n**The Desert and the Robber**\nNo, you do not move the robber if it is on a desert hex. The robber is only moved when a 7 is rolled if it is currently sitting on a **resource hex** (forest, pasture, etc.). If it is on a desert, it stays put.\n\n**Moving the Robber back to the Desert**\nYes, you can move the robber onto a desert hex during your turn if you choose to do so. While it won't move on a 7, it still occupies that space.\n\n**Choosing a victim**\nIf the robber lands on a hex touched by two different players, **you** (the player who rolled the 7) choose which player to rob.\n\n**Robbing a player with zero cards**\nIf the player you choose to rob has no cards in their hand, **nothing happens.** You do not get to pick a different player, and the turn simply continues."
  },
  {
   "model": "gemma4:12b",
   "question": "Q2-complex",
   "i": 2,
   "utc": "2026-08-20T13:28:06Z",
   "prompt_eval_count": 106,
   "prompt_eval_duration_ns": 28396000,
   "eval_count": 208,
   "eval_duration_ns": 1621684000,
   "decode_tok_s": 128.26,
   "reply_sha256": "0af51e48d5fd99e0e826c5af53972700bdc5c40c0d51687567b4bf66338f5800",
   "reply_verbatim": "Here are the answers to your questions:\n\n**The Desert and the Robber**\nNo, you do not move the robber if it is on a desert hex. The robber is only moved when a 7 is rolled if it is currently sitting on a **resource hex** (forest, pasture, etc.). If it is on a desert, it stays put.\n\n**Moving the Robber back to the Desert**\nYes, you can move the robber onto a desert hex during your turn if you choose to do so. While it won't move on a 7, it still occupies that space.\n\n**Choosing a victim**\nIf the robber lands on a hex touched by two different players, **you** (the player who rolled the 7) choose which player to rob.\n\n**Robbing a player with zero cards**\nIf the player you choose to rob has no cards in their hand, **nothing happens.** You do not get to pick a different player, and the turn simply continues."
  },
  {
   "model": "gemma4:12b",
   "question": "Q2-complex",
   "i": 3,
   "utc": "2026-08-20T13:28:10Z",
   "prompt_eval_count": 106,
   "prompt_eval_duration_ns": 28440000,
   "eval_count": 208,
   "eval_duration_ns": 1627244000,
   "decode_tok_s": 127.82,
   "reply_sha256": "0af51e48d5fd99e0e826c5af53972700bdc5c40c0d51687567b4bf66338f5800",
   "reply_verbatim": "Here are the answers to your questions:\n\n**The Desert and the Robber**\nNo, you do not move the robber if it is on a desert hex. The robber is only moved when a 7 is rolled if it is currently sitting on a **resource hex** (forest, pasture, etc.). If it is on a desert, it stays put.\n\n**Moving the Robber back to the Desert**\nYes, you can move the robber onto a desert hex during your turn if you choose to do so. While it won't move on a 7, it still occupies that space.\n\n**Choosing a victim**\nIf the robber lands on a hex touched by two different players, **you** (the player who rolled the 7) choose which player to rob.\n\n**Robbing a player with zero cards**\nIf the player you choose to rob has no cards in their hand, **nothing happens.** You do not get to pick a different player, and the turn simply continues."
  },
  {
   "model": "gemma4:12b",
   "question": "Q2-complex",
   "i": 4,
   "utc": "2026-08-20T13:28:14Z",
   "prompt_eval_count": 106,
   "prompt_eval_duration_ns": 28384000,
   "eval_count": 208,
   "eval_duration_ns": 1625430000,
   "decode_tok_s": 127.97,
   "reply_sha256": "0af51e48d5fd99e0e826c5af53972700bdc5c40c0d51687567b4bf66338f5800",
   "reply_verbatim": "Here are the answers to your questions:\n\n**The Desert and the Robber**\nNo, you do not move the robber if it is on a desert hex. The robber is only moved when a 7 is rolled if it is currently sitting on a **resource hex** (forest, pasture, etc.). If it is on a desert, it stays put.\n\n**Moving the Robber back to the Desert**\nYes, you can move the robber onto a desert hex during your turn if you choose to do so. While it won't move on a 7, it still occupies that space.\n\n**Choosing a victim**\nIf the robber lands on a hex touched by two different players, **you** (the player who rolled the 7) choose which player to rob.\n\n**Robbing a player with zero cards**\nIf the player you choose to rob has no cards in their hand, **nothing happens.** You do not get to pick a different player, and the turn simply continues."
  },
  {
   "model": "gemma4:12b-it-qat",
   "question": "Q1-simple",
   "i": 0,
   "utc": "2026-08-20T13:28:27Z",
   "prompt_eval_count": 68,
   "prompt_eval_duration_ns": 27243000,
   "eval_count": 111,
   "eval_duration_ns": 827964000,
   "decode_tok_s": 134.06,
   "reply_sha256": "55d48b258d728512d4d0db26e8ac600b6ffd7e052ed7776a65f8a627cd064237",
   "reply_verbatim": "The short answer is: **No, you cannot.**\n\nIn the official rules of Catan, the robber must be moved to a hex that contains at least one settlement or city. Since the Desert hex is empty (it has no buildings on it), it is an illegal move.\n\nThe goal of moving the robber is to block someone's production or steal a resource, so the rules require you to place it on a hex where it can actually affect another player's progress. Just pick any other hex that has a building on it!"
  },
  {
   "model": "gemma4:12b-it-qat",
   "question": "Q1-simple",
   "i": 1,
   "utc": "2026-08-20T13:28:30Z",
   "prompt_eval_count": 68,
   "prompt_eval_duration_ns": 24080000,
   "eval_count": 111,
   "eval_duration_ns": 826041000,
   "decode_tok_s": 134.38,
   "reply_sha256": "55d48b258d728512d4d0db26e8ac600b6ffd7e052ed7776a65f8a627cd064237",
   "reply_verbatim": "The short answer is: **No, you cannot.**\n\nIn the official rules of Catan, the robber must be moved to a hex that contains at least one settlement or city. Since the Desert hex is empty (it has no buildings on it), it is an illegal move.\n\nThe goal of moving the robber is to block someone's production or steal a resource, so the rules require you to place it on a hex where it can actually affect another player's progress. Just pick any other hex that has a building on it!"
  },
  {
   "model": "gemma4:12b-it-qat",
   "question": "Q1-simple",
   "i": 2,
   "utc": "2026-08-20T13:28:34Z",
   "prompt_eval_count": 68,
   "prompt_eval_duration_ns": 24635000,
   "eval_count": 111,
   "eval_duration_ns": 826374000,
   "decode_tok_s": 134.32,
   "reply_sha256": "55d48b258d728512d4d0db26e8ac600b6ffd7e052ed7776a65f8a627cd064237",
   "reply_verbatim": "The short answer is: **No, you cannot.**\n\nIn the official rules of Catan, the robber must be moved to a hex that contains at least one settlement or city. Since the Desert hex is empty (it has no buildings on it), it is an illegal move.\n\nThe goal of moving the robber is to block someone's production or steal a resource, so the rules require you to place it on a hex where it can actually affect another player's progress. Just pick any other hex that has a building on it!"
  },
  {
   "model": "gemma4:12b-it-qat",
   "question": "Q1-simple",
   "i": 3,
   "utc": "2026-08-20T13:28:37Z",
   "prompt_eval_count": 68,
   "prompt_eval_duration_ns": 24599000,
   "eval_count": 111,
   "eval_duration_ns": 822240000,
   "decode_tok_s": 135.0,
   "reply_sha256": "55d48b258d728512d4d0db26e8ac600b6ffd7e052ed7776a65f8a627cd064237",
   "reply_verbatim": "The short answer is: **No, you cannot.**\n\nIn the official rules of Catan, the robber must be moved to a hex that contains at least one settlement or city. Since the Desert hex is empty (it has no buildings on it), it is an illegal move.\n\nThe goal of moving the robber is to block someone's production or steal a resource, so the rules require you to place it on a hex where it can actually affect another player's progress. Just pick any other hex that has a building on it!"
  },
  {
   "model": "gemma4:12b-it-qat",
   "question": "Q1-simple",
   "i": 4,
   "utc": "2026-08-20T13:28:40Z",
   "prompt_eval_count": 68,
   "prompt_eval_duration_ns": 24717000,
   "eval_count": 111,
   "eval_duration_ns": 824113000,
   "decode_tok_s": 134.69,
   "reply_sha256": "55d48b258d728512d4d0db26e8ac600b6ffd7e052ed7776a65f8a627cd064237",
   "reply_verbatim": "The short answer is: **No, you cannot.**\n\nIn the official rules of Catan, the robber must be moved to a hex that contains at least one settlement or city. Since the Desert hex is empty (it has no buildings on it), it is an illegal move.\n\nThe goal of moving the robber is to block someone's production or steal a resource, so the rules require you to place it on a hex where it can actually affect another player's progress. Just pick any other hex that has a building on it!"
  },
  {
   "model": "gemma4:12b-it-qat",
   "question": "Q2-complex",
   "i": 0,
   "utc": "2026-08-20T13:28:48Z",
   "prompt_eval_count": 106,
   "prompt_eval_duration_ns": 33194000,
   "eval_count": 184,
   "eval_duration_ns": 1381309000,
   "decode_tok_s": 133.21,
   "reply_sha256": "9b2f3473c0fa9a93602523cae2c2f89f9ed20b430656033f8e2c76b0909dab42",
   "reply_verbatim": "Here are the answers to your questions:\n\n**Moving the Robber from the Desert**\nNo, you are not required to move it. If the Robber is on the Desert, you simply do nothing. The Robber stays put.\n\n**Moving the Robber back to the Desert**\nYes, a player may move the Robber back onto the Desert at any time during their turn (if they have the opportunity to move it).\n\n**Choosing a victim on a shared border**\nYes, you choose which player to steal from. If a hex touches two different settlements, you pick one of those two players.\n\n**Stealing from a player with zero cards**\nIf the player you choose has no cards, nothing happens. You do not get to pick a different player, and you do not get to \"skip\" the turn; the action simply results in no cards being traded."
  },
  {
   "model": "gemma4:12b-it-qat",
   "question": "Q2-complex",
   "i": 1,
   "utc": "2026-08-20T13:28:52Z",
   "prompt_eval_count": 106,
   "prompt_eval_duration_ns": 27673000,
   "eval_count": 184,
   "eval_duration_ns": 1387689000,
   "decode_tok_s": 132.59,
   "reply_sha256": "9b2f3473c0fa9a93602523cae2c2f89f9ed20b430656033f8e2c76b0909dab42",
   "reply_verbatim": "Here are the answers to your questions:\n\n**Moving the Robber from the Desert**\nNo, you are not required to move it. If the Robber is on the Desert, you simply do nothing. The Robber stays put.\n\n**Moving the Robber back to the Desert**\nYes, a player may move the Robber back onto the Desert at any time during their turn (if they have the opportunity to move it).\n\n**Choosing a victim on a shared border**\nYes, you choose which player to steal from. If a hex touches two different settlements, you pick one of those two players.\n\n**Stealing from a player with zero cards**\nIf the player you choose has no cards, nothing happens. You do not get to pick a different player, and you do not get to \"skip\" the turn; the action simply results in no cards being traded."
  },
  {
   "model": "gemma4:12b-it-qat",
   "question": "Q2-complex",
   "i": 2,
   "utc": "2026-08-20T13:28:56Z",
   "prompt_eval_count": 106,
   "prompt_eval_duration_ns": 28014000,
   "eval_count": 184,
   "eval_duration_ns": 1383679000,
   "decode_tok_s": 132.98,
   "reply_sha256": "9b2f3473c0fa9a93602523cae2c2f89f9ed20b430656033f8e2c76b0909dab42",
   "reply_verbatim": "Here are the answers to your questions:\n\n**Moving the Robber from the Desert**\nNo, you are not required to move it. If the Robber is on the Desert, you simply do nothing. The Robber stays put.\n\n**Moving the Robber back to the Desert**\nYes, a player may move the Robber back onto the Desert at any time during their turn (if they have the opportunity to move it).\n\n**Choosing a victim on a shared border**\nYes, you choose which player to steal from. If a hex touches two different settlements, you pick one of those two players.\n\n**Stealing from a player with zero cards**\nIf the player you choose has no cards, nothing happens. You do not get to pick a different player, and you do not get to \"skip\" the turn; the action simply results in no cards being traded."
  },
  {
   "model": "gemma4:12b-it-qat",
   "question": "Q2-complex",
   "i": 3,
   "utc": "2026-08-20T13:29:00Z",
   "prompt_eval_count": 106,
   "prompt_eval_duration_ns": 27572000,
   "eval_count": 184,
   "eval_duration_ns": 1384634000,
   "decode_tok_s": 132.89,
   "reply_sha256": "9b2f3473c0fa9a93602523cae2c2f89f9ed20b430656033f8e2c76b0909dab42",
   "reply_verbatim": "Here are the answers to your questions:\n\n**Moving the Robber from the Desert**\nNo, you are not required to move it. If the Robber is on the Desert, you simply do nothing. The Robber stays put.\n\n**Moving the Robber back to the Desert**\nYes, a player may move the Robber back onto the Desert at any time during their turn (if they have the opportunity to move it).\n\n**Choosing a victim on a shared border**\nYes, you choose which player to steal from. If a hex touches two different settlements, you pick one of those two players.\n\n**Stealing from a player with zero cards**\nIf the player you choose has no cards, nothing happens. You do not get to pick a different player, and you do not get to \"skip\" the turn; the action simply results in no cards being traded."
  },
  {
   "model": "gemma4:12b-it-qat",
   "question": "Q2-complex",
   "i": 4,
   "utc": "2026-08-20T13:29:04Z",
   "prompt_eval_count": 106,
   "prompt_eval_duration_ns": 27712000,
   "eval_count": 184,
   "eval_duration_ns": 1386105000,
   "decode_tok_s": 132.75,
   "reply_sha256": "9b2f3473c0fa9a93602523cae2c2f89f9ed20b430656033f8e2c76b0909dab42",
   "reply_verbatim": "Here are the answers to your questions:\n\n**Moving the Robber from the Desert**\nNo, you are not required to move it. If the Robber is on the Desert, you simply do nothing. The Robber stays put.\n\n**Moving the Robber back to the Desert**\nYes, a player may move the Robber back onto the Desert at any time during their turn (if they have the opportunity to move it).\n\n**Choosing a victim on a shared border**\nYes, you choose which player to steal from. If a hex touches two different settlements, you pick one of those two players.\n\n**Stealing from a player with zero cards**\nIf the player you choose has no cards, nothing happens. You do not get to pick a different player, and you do not get to \"skip\" the turn; the action simply results in no cards being traded."
  },
  {
   "model": "gemma4:12b-it-q8_0",
   "question": "Q1-simple",
   "i": 0,
   "utc": "2026-08-20T13:29:22Z",
   "prompt_eval_count": 68,
   "prompt_eval_duration_ns": 33570000,
   "eval_count": 64,
   "eval_duration_ns": 694333000,
   "decode_tok_s": 92.17,
   "reply_sha256": "a71108cf3fc6037176d9e2e0f06f12b7d4155ccb29bb965e249ca8a563aaef63",
   "reply_verbatim": "No, you cannot move the robber back to the desert.\n\nIn Catan, the robber must be moved to a hex that contains at least one settlement or city. Since the desert is empty, it is not a valid destination. You must choose a hex that has a building on it to place the robber."
  },
  {
   "model": "gemma4:12b-it-q8_0",
   "question": "Q1-simple",
   "i": 1,
   "utc": "2026-08-20T13:29:25Z",
   "prompt_eval_count": 68,
   "prompt_eval_duration_ns": 31603000,
   "eval_count": 64,
   "eval_duration_ns": 694815000,
   "decode_tok_s": 92.11,
   "reply_sha256": "a71108cf3fc6037176d9e2e0f06f12b7d4155ccb29bb965e249ca8a563aaef63",
   "reply_verbatim": "No, you cannot move the robber back to the desert.\n\nIn Catan, the robber must be moved to a hex that contains at least one settlement or city. Since the desert is empty, it is not a valid destination. You must choose a hex that has a building on it to place the robber."
  },
  {
   "model": "gemma4:12b-it-q8_0",
   "question": "Q1-simple",
   "i": 2,
   "utc": "2026-08-20T13:29:28Z",
   "prompt_eval_count": 68,
   "prompt_eval_duration_ns": 31337000,
   "eval_count": 64,
   "eval_duration_ns": 694687000,
   "decode_tok_s": 92.13,
   "reply_sha256": "a71108cf3fc6037176d9e2e0f06f12b7d4155ccb29bb965e249ca8a563aaef63",
   "reply_verbatim": "No, you cannot move the robber back to the desert.\n\nIn Catan, the robber must be moved to a hex that contains at least one settlement or city. Since the desert is empty, it is not a valid destination. You must choose a hex that has a building on it to place the robber."
  },
  {
   "model": "gemma4:12b-it-q8_0",
   "question": "Q1-simple",
   "i": 3,
   "utc": "2026-08-20T13:29:31Z",
   "prompt_eval_count": 68,
   "prompt_eval_duration_ns": 31489000,
   "eval_count": 64,
   "eval_duration_ns": 693862000,
   "decode_tok_s": 92.24,
   "reply_sha256": "a71108cf3fc6037176d9e2e0f06f12b7d4155ccb29bb965e249ca8a563aaef63",
   "reply_verbatim": "No, you cannot move the robber back to the desert.\n\nIn Catan, the robber must be moved to a hex that contains at least one settlement or city. Since the desert is empty, it is not a valid destination. You must choose a hex that has a building on it to place the robber."
  },
  {
   "model": "gemma4:12b-it-q8_0",
   "question": "Q1-simple",
   "i": 4,
   "utc": "2026-08-20T13:29:34Z",
   "prompt_eval_count": 68,
   "prompt_eval_duration_ns": 31790000,
   "eval_count": 64,
   "eval_duration_ns": 694233000,
   "decode_tok_s": 92.19,
   "reply_sha256": "a71108cf3fc6037176d9e2e0f06f12b7d4155ccb29bb965e249ca8a563aaef63",
   "reply_verbatim": "No, you cannot move the robber back to the desert.\n\nIn Catan, the robber must be moved to a hex that contains at least one settlement or city. Since the desert is empty, it is not a valid destination. You must choose a hex that has a building on it to place the robber."
  },
  {
   "model": "gemma4:12b-it-q8_0",
   "question": "Q2-complex",
   "i": 0,
   "utc": "2026-08-20T13:29:44Z",
   "prompt_eval_count": 106,
   "prompt_eval_duration_ns": 38499000,
   "eval_count": 185,
   "eval_duration_ns": 2032840000,
   "decode_tok_s": 91.01,
   "reply_sha256": "4dca2bf6d79538651fe228c7735c49b0761cce617de0e3d97f6e6da51d590ccd",
   "reply_verbatim": "Here are the answers to your questions:\n\n**1. Rolling a 7 with the Robber on the Desert:**\nNo, you are not required to move it. The Robber can stay on the Desert. However, because the Desert produces nothing, no cards are stolen and no cards are discarded.\n\n**2. Moving the Robber back to the Desert:**\nYes. A player can move the Robber onto the Desert at any time during their turn (provided they roll a 7 or use a Knight card).\n\n**3. Choosing who to steal from:**\nYes, you choose. If the Robber lands on a hex touched by two different players, you pick which player you want to steal from.\n\n**4. Stealing from a player with zero cards:**\nIf the player you choose has no cards in their hand, nothing happens. You simply cannot steal anything from them."
  },
  {
   "model": "gemma4:12b-it-q8_0",
   "question": "Q2-complex",
   "i": 1,
   "utc": "2026-08-20T13:29:48Z",
   "prompt_eval_count": 106,
   "prompt_eval_duration_ns": 34562000,
   "eval_count": 185,
   "eval_duration_ns": 2032192000,
   "decode_tok_s": 91.03,
   "reply_sha256": "4dca2bf6d79538651fe228c7735c49b0761cce617de0e3d97f6e6da51d590ccd",
   "reply_verbatim": "Here are the answers to your questions:\n\n**1. Rolling a 7 with the Robber on the Desert:**\nNo, you are not required to move it. The Robber can stay on the Desert. However, because the Desert produces nothing, no cards are stolen and no cards are discarded.\n\n**2. Moving the Robber back to the Desert:**\nYes. A player can move the Robber onto the Desert at any time during their turn (provided they roll a 7 or use a Knight card).\n\n**3. Choosing who to steal from:**\nYes, you choose. If the Robber lands on a hex touched by two different players, you pick which player you want to steal from.\n\n**4. Stealing from a player with zero cards:**\nIf the player you choose has no cards in their hand, nothing happens. You simply cannot steal anything from them."
  },
  {
   "model": "gemma4:12b-it-q8_0",
   "question": "Q2-complex",
   "i": 2,
   "utc": "2026-08-20T13:29:53Z",
   "prompt_eval_count": 106,
   "prompt_eval_duration_ns": 34512000,
   "eval_count": 185,
   "eval_duration_ns": 2033864000,
   "decode_tok_s": 90.96,
   "reply_sha256": "4dca2bf6d79538651fe228c7735c49b0761cce617de0e3d97f6e6da51d590ccd",
   "reply_verbatim": "Here are the answers to your questions:\n\n**1. Rolling a 7 with the Robber on the Desert:**\nNo, you are not required to move it. The Robber can stay on the Desert. However, because the Desert produces nothing, no cards are stolen and no cards are discarded.\n\n**2. Moving the Robber back to the Desert:**\nYes. A player can move the Robber onto the Desert at any time during their turn (provided they roll a 7 or use a Knight card).\n\n**3. Choosing who to steal from:**\nYes, you choose. If the Robber lands on a hex touched by two different players, you pick which player you want to steal from.\n\n**4. Stealing from a player with zero cards:**\nIf the player you choose has no cards in their hand, nothing happens. You simply cannot steal anything from them."
  },
  {
   "model": "gemma4:12b-it-q8_0",
   "question": "Q2-complex",
   "i": 3,
   "utc": "2026-08-20T13:29:57Z",
   "prompt_eval_count": 106,
   "prompt_eval_duration_ns": 34423000,
   "eval_count": 185,
   "eval_duration_ns": 2035957000,
   "decode_tok_s": 90.87,
   "reply_sha256": "4dca2bf6d79538651fe228c7735c49b0761cce617de0e3d97f6e6da51d590ccd",
   "reply_verbatim": "Here are the answers to your questions:\n\n**1. Rolling a 7 with the Robber on the Desert:**\nNo, you are not required to move it. The Robber can stay on the Desert. However, because the Desert produces nothing, no cards are stolen and no cards are discarded.\n\n**2. Moving the Robber back to the Desert:**\nYes. A player can move the Robber onto the Desert at any time during their turn (provided they roll a 7 or use a Knight card).\n\n**3. Choosing who to steal from:**\nYes, you choose. If the Robber lands on a hex touched by two different players, you pick which player you want to steal from.\n\n**4. Stealing from a player with zero cards:**\nIf the player you choose has no cards in their hand, nothing happens. You simply cannot steal anything from them."
  },
  {
   "model": "gemma4:12b-it-q8_0",
   "question": "Q2-complex",
   "i": 4,
   "utc": "2026-08-20T13:30:02Z",
   "prompt_eval_count": 106,
   "prompt_eval_duration_ns": 34701000,
   "eval_count": 185,
   "eval_duration_ns": 2028806000,
   "decode_tok_s": 91.19,
   "reply_sha256": "4dca2bf6d79538651fe228c7735c49b0761cce617de0e3d97f6e6da51d590ccd",
   "reply_verbatim": "Here are the answers to your questions:\n\n**1. Rolling a 7 with the Robber on the Desert:**\nNo, you are not required to move it. The Robber can stay on the Desert. However, because the Desert produces nothing, no cards are stolen and no cards are discarded.\n\n**2. Moving the Robber back to the Desert:**\nYes. A player can move the Robber onto the Desert at any time during their turn (provided they roll a 7 or use a Knight card).\n\n**3. Choosing who to steal from:**\nYes, you choose. If the Robber lands on a hex touched by two different players, you pick which player you want to steal from.\n\n**4. Stealing from a player with zero cards:**\nIf the player you choose has no cards in their hand, nothing happens. You simply cannot steal anything from them."
  },
  {
   "model": "gemma4:12b-it-bf16",
   "question": "Q1-simple",
   "i": 0,
   "utc": "2026-08-20T13:30:25Z",
   "prompt_eval_count": 68,
   "prompt_eval_duration_ns": 47493000,
   "eval_count": 64,
   "eval_duration_ns": 1319816000,
   "decode_tok_s": 48.49,
   "reply_sha256": "a71108cf3fc6037176d9e2e0f06f12b7d4155ccb29bb965e249ca8a563aaef63",
   "reply_verbatim": "No, you cannot move the robber back to the desert.\n\nIn Catan, the robber must be moved to a hex that contains at least one settlement or city. Since the desert is empty, it is not a valid destination. You must choose a hex that has a building on it to place the robber."
  },
  {
   "model": "gemma4:12b-it-bf16",
   "question": "Q1-simple",
   "i": 1,
   "utc": "2026-08-20T13:30:29Z",
   "prompt_eval_count": 68,
   "prompt_eval_duration_ns": 43656000,
   "eval_count": 64,
   "eval_duration_ns": 1101125000,
   "decode_tok_s": 58.12,
   "reply_sha256": "a71108cf3fc6037176d9e2e0f06f12b7d4155ccb29bb965e249ca8a563aaef63",
   "reply_verbatim": "No, you cannot move the robber back to the desert.\n\nIn Catan, the robber must be moved to a hex that contains at least one settlement or city. Since the desert is empty, it is not a valid destination. You must choose a hex that has a building on it to place the robber."
  },
  {
   "model": "gemma4:12b-it-bf16",
   "question": "Q1-simple",
   "i": 2,
   "utc": "2026-08-20T13:30:32Z",
   "prompt_eval_count": 68,
   "prompt_eval_duration_ns": 44004000,
   "eval_count": 64,
   "eval_duration_ns": 1102630000,
   "decode_tok_s": 58.04,
   "reply_sha256": "a71108cf3fc6037176d9e2e0f06f12b7d4155ccb29bb965e249ca8a563aaef63",
   "reply_verbatim": "No, you cannot move the robber back to the desert.\n\nIn Catan, the robber must be moved to a hex that contains at least one settlement or city. Since the desert is empty, it is not a valid destination. You must choose a hex that has a building on it to place the robber."
  },
  {
   "model": "gemma4:12b-it-bf16",
   "question": "Q1-simple",
   "i": 3,
   "utc": "2026-08-20T13:30:36Z",
   "prompt_eval_count": 68,
   "prompt_eval_duration_ns": 43649000,
   "eval_count": 64,
   "eval_duration_ns": 1102566000,
   "decode_tok_s": 58.05,
   "reply_sha256": "a71108cf3fc6037176d9e2e0f06f12b7d4155ccb29bb965e249ca8a563aaef63",
   "reply_verbatim": "No, you cannot move the robber back to the desert.\n\nIn Catan, the robber must be moved to a hex that contains at least one settlement or city. Since the desert is empty, it is not a valid destination. You must choose a hex that has a building on it to place the robber."
  },
  {
   "model": "gemma4:12b-it-bf16",
   "question": "Q1-simple",
   "i": 4,
   "utc": "2026-08-20T13:30:40Z",
   "prompt_eval_count": 68,
   "prompt_eval_duration_ns": 43697000,
   "eval_count": 64,
   "eval_duration_ns": 1101555000,
   "decode_tok_s": 58.1,
   "reply_sha256": "a71108cf3fc6037176d9e2e0f06f12b7d4155ccb29bb965e249ca8a563aaef63",
   "reply_verbatim": "No, you cannot move the robber back to the desert.\n\nIn Catan, the robber must be moved to a hex that contains at least one settlement or city. Since the desert is empty, it is not a valid destination. You must choose a hex that has a building on it to place the robber."
  },
  {
   "model": "gemma4:12b-it-bf16",
   "question": "Q2-complex",
   "i": 0,
   "utc": "2026-08-20T13:30:52Z",
   "prompt_eval_count": 106,
   "prompt_eval_duration_ns": 51048000,
   "eval_count": 212,
   "eval_duration_ns": 3691738000,
   "decode_tok_s": 57.43,
   "reply_sha256": "f265af2f0c41232835d7c901fedd1ccd309b9e0916816a4f326b9737fe554dbd",
   "reply_verbatim": "Here are the answers to your questions:\n\n**1. Rolling a 7 with the Robber on the Desert:**\nNo, you are not required to move it. The Robber can stay on the Desert hex. However, you still perform the standard \"7\" actions: players with more than 7 cards must discard half, and you may move the Robber to any adjacent hex (including the Desert).\n\n**2. Moving the Robber back to the Desert:**\nYes. At any point during the game, a player who rolls a 7 may move the Robber onto the Desert hex.\n\n**3. Choosing who to steal from:**\nYes, you choose. If the Robber lands on a hex touched by two different players' settlements, you decide which player to target.\n\n**4. Stealing from a player with zero cards:**\nIf the player you choose has no cards, nothing happens. You simply cannot steal anything from them. You do not get to pick a different player; the turn ends."
  },
  {
   "model": "gemma4:12b-it-bf16",
   "question": "Q2-complex",
   "i": 1,
   "utc": "2026-08-20T13:30:58Z",
   "prompt_eval_count": 106,
   "prompt_eval_duration_ns": 46545000,
   "eval_count": 212,
   "eval_duration_ns": 3694736000,
   "decode_tok_s": 57.38,
   "reply_sha256": "f265af2f0c41232835d7c901fedd1ccd309b9e0916816a4f326b9737fe554dbd",
   "reply_verbatim": "Here are the answers to your questions:\n\n**1. Rolling a 7 with the Robber on the Desert:**\nNo, you are not required to move it. The Robber can stay on the Desert hex. However, you still perform the standard \"7\" actions: players with more than 7 cards must discard half, and you may move the Robber to any adjacent hex (including the Desert).\n\n**2. Moving the Robber back to the Desert:**\nYes. At any point during the game, a player who rolls a 7 may move the Robber onto the Desert hex.\n\n**3. Choosing who to steal from:**\nYes, you choose. If the Robber lands on a hex touched by two different players' settlements, you decide which player to target.\n\n**4. Stealing from a player with zero cards:**\nIf the player you choose has no cards, nothing happens. You simply cannot steal anything from them. You do not get to pick a different player; the turn ends."
  },
  {
   "model": "gemma4:12b-it-bf16",
   "question": "Q2-complex",
   "i": 2,
   "utc": "2026-08-20T13:31:04Z",
   "prompt_eval_count": 106,
   "prompt_eval_duration_ns": 46843000,
   "eval_count": 212,
   "eval_duration_ns": 3690177000,
   "decode_tok_s": 57.45,
   "reply_sha256": "f265af2f0c41232835d7c901fedd1ccd309b9e0916816a4f326b9737fe554dbd",
   "reply_verbatim": "Here are the answers to your questions:\n\n**1. Rolling a 7 with the Robber on the Desert:**\nNo, you are not required to move it. The Robber can stay on the Desert hex. However, you still perform the standard \"7\" actions: players with more than 7 cards must discard half, and you may move the Robber to any adjacent hex (including the Desert).\n\n**2. Moving the Robber back to the Desert:**\nYes. At any point during the game, a player who rolls a 7 may move the Robber onto the Desert hex.\n\n**3. Choosing who to steal from:**\nYes, you choose. If the Robber lands on a hex touched by two different players' settlements, you decide which player to target.\n\n**4. Stealing from a player with zero cards:**\nIf the player you choose has no cards, nothing happens. You simply cannot steal anything from them. You do not get to pick a different player; the turn ends."
  },
  {
   "model": "gemma4:12b-it-bf16",
   "question": "Q2-complex",
   "i": 3,
   "utc": "2026-08-20T13:31:11Z",
   "prompt_eval_count": 106,
   "prompt_eval_duration_ns": 46893000,
   "eval_count": 212,
   "eval_duration_ns": 3691460000,
   "decode_tok_s": 57.43,
   "reply_sha256": "f265af2f0c41232835d7c901fedd1ccd309b9e0916816a4f326b9737fe554dbd",
   "reply_verbatim": "Here are the answers to your questions:\n\n**1. Rolling a 7 with the Robber on the Desert:**\nNo, you are not required to move it. The Robber can stay on the Desert hex. However, you still perform the standard \"7\" actions: players with more than 7 cards must discard half, and you may move the Robber to any adjacent hex (including the Desert).\n\n**2. Moving the Robber back to the Desert:**\nYes. At any point during the game, a player who rolls a 7 may move the Robber onto the Desert hex.\n\n**3. Choosing who to steal from:**\nYes, you choose. If the Robber lands on a hex touched by two different players' settlements, you decide which player to target.\n\n**4. Stealing from a player with zero cards:**\nIf the player you choose has no cards, nothing happens. You simply cannot steal anything from them. You do not get to pick a different player; the turn ends."
  },
  {
   "model": "gemma4:12b-it-bf16",
   "question": "Q2-complex",
   "i": 4,
   "utc": "2026-08-20T13:31:17Z",
   "prompt_eval_count": 106,
   "prompt_eval_duration_ns": 46658000,
   "eval_count": 212,
   "eval_duration_ns": 3693247000,
   "decode_tok_s": 57.4,
   "reply_sha256": "f265af2f0c41232835d7c901fedd1ccd309b9e0916816a4f326b9737fe554dbd",
   "reply_verbatim": "Here are the answers to your questions:\n\n**1. Rolling a 7 with the Robber on the Desert:**\nNo, you are not required to move it. The Robber can stay on the Desert hex. However, you still perform the standard \"7\" actions: players with more than 7 cards must discard half, and you may move the Robber to any adjacent hex (including the Desert).\n\n**2. Moving the Robber back to the Desert:**\nYes. At any point during the game, a player who rolls a 7 may move the Robber onto the Desert hex.\n\n**3. Choosing who to steal from:**\nYes, you choose. If the Robber lands on a hex touched by two different players' settlements, you decide which player to target.\n\n**4. Stealing from a player with zero cards:**\nIf the player you choose has no cards, nothing happens. You simply cannot steal anything from them. You do not get to pick a different player; the turn ends."
  }
 ],
 "blob_receipt": {
  "read_from": "/api/tags",
  "utc": "2026-08-20",
  "parameter_count": 11907350576,
  "builds": {
   "gemma4:12b-it-bf16": {
    "blob_bytes": 24007191274,
    "bits_per_weight_blob": 16.13
   },
   "gemma4:12b-it-qat": {
    "blob_bytes": 7151003754,
    "bits_per_weight_blob": 4.8
   },
   "gemma4:12b-it-q8_0": {
    "blob_bytes": 12844772074,
    "bits_per_weight_blob": 8.63
   },
   "gemma4:12b": {
    "blob_bytes": 7556508396,
    "bits_per_weight_blob": 5.08
   }
  }
 },
 "attempt1_vs_attempt2": {
  "note": "reply-byte comparison, offloaded attempt 1 vs fully-seated attempt 2: two cells changed bytes under offloaded arithmetic — the 8-bit harder-phrasing reply and the bf16 harder-phrasing reply (one word: a discard clause present offloaded, absent seated). Both returned to stability when fully seated; q4/qat cells identical across attempts.",
  "cells": {
   "gemma4:12b/Q1-simple": "IDENTICAL",
   "gemma4:12b/Q2-complex": "IDENTICAL",
   "gemma4:12b-it-bf16/Q1-simple": "IDENTICAL",
   "gemma4:12b-it-bf16/Q2-complex": "DIFFERS",
   "gemma4:12b-it-q8_0/Q1-simple": "IDENTICAL",
   "gemma4:12b-it-q8_0/Q2-complex": "DIFFERS",
   "gemma4:12b-it-qat/Q1-simple": "IDENTICAL",
   "gemma4:12b-it-qat/Q2-complex": "IDENTICAL"
  }
 }
}