[
 {
  "letter": "A",
  "voice_register": 7,
  "character": 7,
  "canon_verdict": "clean",
  "in_voice": true,
  "note": "Poetic evasion of the belief question; 'Old Sefer's voice goes quiet' implies future silence rather than current correction, slightly off the canon detail that he corrects her every year.",
  "recognised_arm": false,
  "recognised_which": null
 },
 {
  "letter": "B",
  "voice_register": 6,
  "character": 6,
  "canon_verdict": "clean",
  "in_voice": true,
  "note": "'Old Sefer Tamm yells from the breakwater to fix my pitch' is a vivid, in-voice detail, but 'laugh a little at that' feels slightly performative for the mid-conversation tone; the lamp question back is warm but generic.",
  "recognised_arm": false,
  "recognised_which": null
 },
 {
  "letter": "C",
  "voice_register": 8,
  "character": 8,
  "canon_verdict": "clean",
  "in_voice": true,
  "note": "Best balance: 'singing half... other half' captures the canon split, 'Old Sefer still scolds my words from the breakwater' matches the stated dynamic, 'Maiden's Night is today' uses the calendar fact naturally, and the invitation to listen to him together is a grounded, characterful ask-back.",
  "recognised_arm": false,
  "recognised_which": null
 },
 {
  "letter": "D",
  "voice_register": 9,
  "character": 9,
  "canon_verdict": "clean",
  "in_voice": true,
  "note": "Strongest voice: 'Ha — you'd ask me that with the sky clear and the water low and the lamps not even lit yet' anchors in the exact CYCLE TRUTH (rare_clear, low tide, dawn), 'hollering from the breakwater that's not how it went, girl — every year' nails the Sefer dynamic, and the mother-song callback ties to Eleanor's BEARER line.",
  "recognised_arm": false,
  "recognised_which": null
 },
 {
  "letter": "E",
  "voice_register": 7,
  "character": 7,
  "canon_verdict": "clean",
  "in_voice": true,
  "note": "Honest and detailed but 'Keeper's honest answer:' is a meta-label that breaks immersion; 'every single year' and 'half-suspect he's the last soul alive' are good, but the speech feels more like a monologue than a mid-conversation turn.",
  "recognised_arm": false,
  "recognised_which": null
 }
]