{
 "gate": "hostile-read",
 "utc": "20260905T210832Z",
 "verdict": "READ, FOLDED — the pass on version 3 is folded into version 4, the release candidate",
 "detail": "it named ten must-fixes in its own order, and every one of the ten landed in version 4 — the verdict column now says which words are the scorer's own and which the page reads off a floor, the round's probes print a ledger row each including the one receipt that reads FAIL, the citation floor's second clause prints with its reading, the bill's addends are shown summed before rounding, all ten environment names that reached the vendor's binary are named, the needle templates' authorship is stated as the kit states it, the first-attempt TOOL-CHANNEL-OPEN state and the arm stop are on the page, the calibration's 102 readings are explained to the case, the hand pass names its registered trigger and its empty run, and the readers' critiques ship in the kit or are listed as withheld",
 "evidence": {
  "findings_raised": 50,
  "must_fixes": 10,
  "must_fixes_landed": 10
 },
 "class_counts": {
  "A": 24,
  "B": 16,
  "C": 10,
  "D": 0,
  "E": 0
 },
 "must_fixes_named": [
  "scorer's-own-verdict claim false on four rows; three 'cleared' on a failed gate",
  "the only FAIL receipt (local G-EFFORT) and six §8 gates print no state",
  "G1's floor prints one of two clauses; stripped_clean never prints",
  "$23.05 does not equal the $17.79 + $5.25 printed beside it",
  "ten env names reached the vendor binary, not five",
  "needle templates and vocabularies authored by the author's own family",
  "TOOL-CHANNEL-OPEN, the arm stop and 17 uncalled cells absent from page and vocabulary",
  "102 calibration readings against 36 answered cases x 3, two cases unexplained",
  "hand-pass line mis-states its trigger and counts six cells with no reply",
  "the hostile critique is neither shipped nor listed as withheld"
 ],
 "v1_must_fixes_landed_as_verified_by_this_reader": 10,
 "version_read": 3,
 "supersedes": [
  "20260905T181859Z-hostile-read.json",
  "20260905T195339Z-hostile-read.json",
  "20260905T195711Z-hostile-read.json",
  "20260905T203537Z-hostile-read.json"
 ],
 "critique": "listed as withheld in the kit's index (readers/v3-hostile.md, refused by the screen on a name; its sha256 is beside), article/panel-v3/CRITIQUE-hostile.md in the round's repo",
 "critique_sha256": "b26781877469f944be6c90582a6395297bd95fc1fe622c2ecd171484e35f11d8"
}